Andriy Andrushko
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Andriy Andrushko has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Oleksandr Oleksiiovych Dudorov
Київський національний університет імені Тараса Шевченка
3 shared publications - Andrii Vozniuk
The National Academy of Internal Affairs
2 shared publications - Dmitriy Kamensky
Berdyansk State Pedagogical University
2 shared publications - Roman Oleksandrovych Movchan
Донецький національний університет імені Василя Стуса
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 4 (92) , 13-26
Forcibly transferring children from one group to another as a form of genocide
The article examines problematic issues in the qualification of forcibly transferring children from one group to another (the formulation used in the Criminal Code of Ukraine) as a form of genocide (Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group – the formulation used in international law). The differences in the wording of this form of genocide in the 1948 Convention, the Rome Statute of the ICC, and Article 442 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine are analyzed, demonstrating the importance of terminological nuances in translation for the precise understanding of the essence of this crime. In particular, translating the phrase forcibly transferring children as “forced relocation of children” is legally inaccurate, as it shifts the focus from the violent change of the child’s group affiliation to their physical relocation, whereas the international legal meaning of this form of genocide lies in removing children from a protected group in order to destroy its identity. It has been established that the current wording of paragraph 5 of part 1 of Article 442 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, while using the more precise term “forcibly transferring,” does not emphasize the children’s belonging to a specific protected group. The most adequate formulation, therefore, is “forcibly transferring children of this group to another group,” which clearly reflects the direction of the act and its connection with the specific intent to destroy the protected group as such. It has been clarified that for the qualification of forcibly transferring children as genocide, the determining factor is not the number of victims but the presence of specific intent to destroy the protected group as such. At the same time, a literal interpretation of paragraph 5 of part 1 of Article 442 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine may unjustifiably narrow the scope of this provision. It has been established that the essence of forcibly transferring children as a form of genocide lies not only in causing physical or psychological suffering to individuals, but primarily in the long-term destruction of the group through forced assimilation of its most vulnerable members and the rupture of intergenerational cultural and social continuity. The forced removal of Ukrainian children from occupied territories and their subsequent assimilation, organized by the Russian authorities, confirms the systematic, centralized, and institutionally organized character of this policy. The aim of this policy is the targeted destruction of Ukrainian national identity in children and their integration into another national community as “new Russian citizens.” The systematic and normative organization of this practice, as well as specific measures – forced acquisition of Russian citizenship, changing of names and surnames, placement of children in “re-education camps,” educational and cultural assimilation – combined with official state propaganda denying the existence of the Ukrainian nation, indicate the presence of specific intent required for qualifying these actions as genocide in the form of forcibly transferring children of a protected group to another group.
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 4 (92) , 13-26
Open AccessForcibly transferring children from one group to another as a form of genocide
The article examines problematic issues in the qualification of forcibly transferring children from one group to another (the formulation used in the Criminal Code of Ukraine) as a form of genocide (Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group – the formulation used in international law). The differences in the wording of this form of genocide in the 1948 Convention, the Rome Statute of the ICC, and Article 442 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine are analyzed, demonstrating the importance of terminological nuances in translation for the precise understanding of the essence of this crime. In particular, translating the phrase forcibly transferring children as “forced relocation of children” is legally inaccurate, as it shifts the focus from the violent change of the child’s group affiliation to their physical relocation, whereas the international legal meaning of this form of genocide lies in removing children from a protected group in order to destroy its identity. It has been established that the current wording of paragraph 5 of part 1 of Article 442 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, while using the more precise term “forcibly transferring,” does not emphasize the children’s belonging to a specific protected group. The most adequate formulation, therefore, is “forcibly transferring children of this group to another group,” which clearly reflects the direction of the act and its connection with the specific intent to destroy the protected group as such. It has been clarified that for the qualification of forcibly transferring children as genocide, the determining factor is not the number of victims but the presence of specific intent to destroy the protected group as such. At the same time, a literal interpretation of paragraph 5 of part 1 of Article 442 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine may unjustifiably narrow the scope of this provision. It has been established that the essence of forcibly transferring children as a form of genocide lies not only in causing physical or psychological suffering to individuals, but primarily in the long-term destruction of the group through forced assimilation of its most vulnerable members and the rupture of intergenerational cultural and social continuity. The forced removal of Ukrainian children from occupied territories and their subsequent assimilation, organized by the Russian authorities, confirms the systematic, centralized, and institutionally organized character of this policy. The aim of this policy is the targeted destruction of Ukrainian national identity in children and their integration into another national community as “new Russian citizens.” The systematic and normative organization of this practice, as well as specific measures – forced acquisition of Russian citizenship, changing of names and surnames, placement of children in “re-education camps,” educational and cultural assimilation – combined with official state propaganda denying the existence of the Ukrainian nation, indicate the presence of specific intent required for qualifying these actions as genocide in the form of forcibly transferring children of a protected group to another group.
- Open Access
- 14 September 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (4) , 25-32
The creation of living conditions for a group aimed at its physical destruction, in whole or in part, as a form of genocide
This article explores the challenges associated with the form of genocide defined as the deliberate infliction on a group of conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part, under both international and national criminal law. It is argued that the substitution, in paragraph 3 of Article 442(1) of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, of the phrase “calculated to” with “aimed at” narrows the alignment of this form of genocide with the international legal standards established by the 1948 Genocide Convention and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Such terminology is less precise and creates the risk of misclassifying acts that do not meet the strict legal definition of genocide. Therefore, the article concludes that it is advisable to revert to the original wording, which more accurately reflects both the objective elements of the act – deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about the group’s physical destruction – and its consistency with the specific intent to destroy the protected group as such. The analysis shows that, unlike direct killing (an active and immediate act of physical destruction), the creation of such life conditions involves the gradual infliction of “slow death”, for example through the deprivation of food, medicine, shelter, and other essentials. It is demonstrated that the list of methods for deliberately inflicting such life-threatening conditions should not be exhaustive. These methods may vary depending on context, culture, historical circumstances, or the perpetrators’ tactics. A rigid, closed list may limit the legal system’s ability to respond to emerging or atypical patterns of genocidal conduct. Conversely, an open-ended list ensures greater legal flexibility and comprehensiveness. It is established that deportation alone does not constitute this form of genocide, as physical destruction must be clearly distinguished from the mere dispersion or expulsion of group members. However, deportation may qualify as genocide if it is accompanied by the deliberate infliction of conditions of life calculated to bring about the group’s physical destruction. The article affirms that, for conduct to be qualified as this form of genocide, it is sufficient that the imposed conditions of life be objectively capable of causing the destruction of at least part of the group; the actual death of individuals is not required. In the context of the Russian-Ukrainian war, actions such as the blockade of populated areas, destruction of civilian infrastructure, obstruction of evacuation and humanitarian access, and similar conduct may amount to the deliberate infliction of life conditions calculated to bring about the physical destruction of a protected group. However, such classification requires proving the specific intent to destroy the group as such, which remains the central evidentiary challenge. Finally, the article emphasizes that, unlike other forms of genocide, the deliberate infliction of life conditions calculated to bring about a group’s destruction is collective in nature and cannot be limited to the impact on a single group member.
- 14 September 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (4) , 25-32
Open AccessThe creation of living conditions for a group aimed at its physical destruction, in whole or in part, as a form of genocide
This article explores the challenges associated with the form of genocide defined as the deliberate infliction on a group of conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part, under both international and national criminal law. It is argued that the substitution, in paragraph 3 of Article 442(1) of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, of the phrase “calculated to” with “aimed at” narrows the alignment of this form of genocide with the international legal standards established by the 1948 Genocide Convention and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Such terminology is less precise and creates the risk of misclassifying acts that do not meet the strict legal definition of genocide. Therefore, the article concludes that it is advisable to revert to the original wording, which more accurately reflects both the objective elements of the act – deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about the group’s physical destruction – and its consistency with the specific intent to destroy the protected group as such. The analysis shows that, unlike direct killing (an active and immediate act of physical destruction), the creation of such life conditions involves the gradual infliction of “slow death”, for example through the deprivation of food, medicine, shelter, and other essentials. It is demonstrated that the list of methods for deliberately inflicting such life-threatening conditions should not be exhaustive. These methods may vary depending on context, culture, historical circumstances, or the perpetrators’ tactics. A rigid, closed list may limit the legal system’s ability to respond to emerging or atypical patterns of genocidal conduct. Conversely, an open-ended list ensures greater legal flexibility and comprehensiveness. It is established that deportation alone does not constitute this form of genocide, as physical destruction must be clearly distinguished from the mere dispersion or expulsion of group members. However, deportation may qualify as genocide if it is accompanied by the deliberate infliction of conditions of life calculated to bring about the group’s physical destruction. The article affirms that, for conduct to be qualified as this form of genocide, it is sufficient that the imposed conditions of life be objectively capable of causing the destruction of at least part of the group; the actual death of individuals is not required. In the context of the Russian-Ukrainian war, actions such as the blockade of populated areas, destruction of civilian infrastructure, obstruction of evacuation and humanitarian access, and similar conduct may amount to the deliberate infliction of life conditions calculated to bring about the physical destruction of a protected group. However, such classification requires proving the specific intent to destroy the group as such, which remains the central evidentiary challenge. Finally, the article emphasizes that, unlike other forms of genocide, the deliberate infliction of life conditions calculated to bring about a group’s destruction is collective in nature and cannot be limited to the impact on a single group member.
- Open Access
- 28 April 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 2,p. 788-809
Comparative Legal Analysis of Foreign States’ Legislation on Liability for Genocide
This article examines the diversity of approaches to the criminalization and penalization of the crime of genocide, based on a comparative analysis of the legislation of 90 states worldwide. It has been established that the majority of legislators have stipulated liability for the aforementioned crime directly within the criminal code. At the same time, the legislators of Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Denmark, Germany, Great Britain, Greece, Iceland, Indonesia, Ireland, Israel, Italy, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Philippines, Portugal, Rwanda, South Africa, Sweden, and Uruguay have prescribed liability for genocide in specific legislative acts. It has been determined that legislators have adopted varying approaches to the implementation of international legal norms concerning liability for the crime of genocide. While certain legislators have reproduced the relevant international legal norms contained in the 1948 Convention and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court verbatim or with minimal textual amendments that do not affect the substance, others have transformed the aforementioned norms of international law to a greater or lesser extent. It has been elucidated that in Argentina, Canada, Great Britain, Ireland, New Zealand, and Rwanda, the referral method was employed in the criminalization of genocide. It has been clarified that a number of legislators (specifically, Andorra, Austria, Belarus, Bolivia, Burkina Faso, Canada, Chad, Colombia, Costa Rica, Côte d’Ivoire, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Ethiopia, Finland, France, Gabon, Georgia, Honduras, Lesotho, Lithuania, Liechtenstein, Nicaragua, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Slovakia, Spain, Switzerland, Uruguay) provide an expanded range of groups protected from genocide, in comparison to the 1948 Convention. It has been established that, alongside those enumerated in the relevant international legal acts, the legislators of Angola, Andorra, Colombia, Côte d’Ivoire, Estonia, Ethiopia, Italy, Lithuania, Mongolia, Nicaragua, North Macedonia, Panama, Paraguay, Spain, Uruguay, and Vietnam have included other acts committed against members of a particular group of people within the objective element of genocide. The differences in the legislative formulation of the forms of genocide, as outlined in international legal acts, have been analyzed. Particular attention has been directed to the Italian experience in the endeavor to criminalize cultural genocide. The specificities of the criminalization by legislators of various states of conspiracy to commit genocide and direct and public incitement to commit genocide have been established. A significant diversity of existing approaches is noted, not only in the criminalization but also in the penalization of the crime of genocide. It is emphasized that the analyzed foreign experience may be useful in improving the domestic criminal law prohibition pertaining to liability for the specified crime. In particular, the identification by some legislators of other groups of people, not specified in international legal acts, against whom genocide is committed, as well as the expansion of the list of actions that constitute the objective element of this crime, deserve serious attention.
- 28 April 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 2,p. 788-809
Open AccessComparative Legal Analysis of Foreign States’ Legislation on Liability for Genocide
This article examines the diversity of approaches to the criminalization and penalization of the crime of genocide, based on a comparative analysis of the legislation of 90 states worldwide. It has been established that the majority of legislators have stipulated liability for the aforementioned crime directly within the criminal code. At the same time, the legislators of Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Denmark, Germany, Great Britain, Greece, Iceland, Indonesia, Ireland, Israel, Italy, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Philippines, Portugal, Rwanda, South Africa, Sweden, and Uruguay have prescribed liability for genocide in specific legislative acts. It has been determined that legislators have adopted varying approaches to the implementation of international legal norms concerning liability for the crime of genocide. While certain legislators have reproduced the relevant international legal norms contained in the 1948 Convention and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court verbatim or with minimal textual amendments that do not affect the substance, others have transformed the aforementioned norms of international law to a greater or lesser extent. It has been elucidated that in Argentina, Canada, Great Britain, Ireland, New Zealand, and Rwanda, the referral method was employed in the criminalization of genocide. It has been clarified that a number of legislators (specifically, Andorra, Austria, Belarus, Bolivia, Burkina Faso, Canada, Chad, Colombia, Costa Rica, Côte d’Ivoire, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Ethiopia, Finland, France, Gabon, Georgia, Honduras, Lesotho, Lithuania, Liechtenstein, Nicaragua, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Slovakia, Spain, Switzerland, Uruguay) provide an expanded range of groups protected from genocide, in comparison to the 1948 Convention. It has been established that, alongside those enumerated in the relevant international legal acts, the legislators of Angola, Andorra, Colombia, Côte d’Ivoire, Estonia, Ethiopia, Italy, Lithuania, Mongolia, Nicaragua, North Macedonia, Panama, Paraguay, Spain, Uruguay, and Vietnam have included other acts committed against members of a particular group of people within the objective element of genocide. The differences in the legislative formulation of the forms of genocide, as outlined in international legal acts, have been analyzed. Particular attention has been directed to the Italian experience in the endeavor to criminalize cultural genocide. The specificities of the criminalization by legislators of various states of conspiracy to commit genocide and direct and public incitement to commit genocide have been established. A significant diversity of existing approaches is noted, not only in the criminalization but also in the penalization of the crime of genocide. It is emphasized that the analyzed foreign experience may be useful in improving the domestic criminal law prohibition pertaining to liability for the specified crime. In particular, the identification by some legislators of other groups of people, not specified in international legal acts, against whom genocide is committed, as well as the expansion of the list of actions that constitute the objective element of this crime, deserve serious attention.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 1,p. 569-577
Rafał Lemkin’s Concept of the Crime of Genocide: Formation, Transformation, Modern Meaning
The article considers the formation and development of the concept of the crime of genocide of the prominent Polish-American lawyer Rafał (Raphael) Lemkin (1900–1959), as well as analyzes its modern meaning. The article establishes main biographical information about Lemkin; it is emphasized that the young years of his life are closely connected with the lands of present-day Ukraine: he studied at the Department of Law of Lviv University, worked as a junior prosecutor (assistant prosecutor) of the district court in Berezhany in the Ternopil region. It has been established that the first attempt at the international legal level to provide for punishment for acts committed not against individuals, but against groups of people on a certain basis or against individuals, if they are considered as representatives of these groups, was the concept of “acts of barbarity” and “acts of vandalism”, proposed by Lemkin in 1933. It is emphasized that these concepts formed the basis of the concept of “genocide” proposed by him. It is stated that the term “genocide” to a greater extent reflected the concept of “acts of bar-barity” previously proposed by Lemkin, although it also included the essential components of “acts of vandalism”. The article establishes that Rafał Lemkin’s views on the essence and ways to counteract the crime of genocide eventually formed the basis of the provisions of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide of 1948, of which he was the main author. It has been found that the text of this Convention does not fully reflect the totality of Lemkin’s views on the crime of genocide. It is stated that later this discrepancy led to problems in the qualification of specific acts as genocide. The significance of the concept of the crime of genocide by Rafał Lemkin for the present is analyzed. For this purpose, in particular, the criminal legislation of European states is studied in order to find out how the legislators of foreign states implemented the provisions of the Genocide Convention. It is emphasized that special attention should be paid to the identification by some legislators of other groups of people, not mentioned in international legal acts, against whom genocide is committed, as well as the expansion of the list of actions that form the objective side of this crime. Particular attention is paid to the Italian experience of the desire to criminalize cultural genocide, which conceptually reflects the views of Rafał Lemkin. It is suggested that some other national legislators will soon follow a similar path.
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 1,p. 569-577
Open AccessRafał Lemkin’s Concept of the Crime of Genocide: Formation, Transformation, Modern Meaning
The article considers the formation and development of the concept of the crime of genocide of the prominent Polish-American lawyer Rafał (Raphael) Lemkin (1900–1959), as well as analyzes its modern meaning. The article establishes main biographical information about Lemkin; it is emphasized that the young years of his life are closely connected with the lands of present-day Ukraine: he studied at the Department of Law of Lviv University, worked as a junior prosecutor (assistant prosecutor) of the district court in Berezhany in the Ternopil region. It has been established that the first attempt at the international legal level to provide for punishment for acts committed not against individuals, but against groups of people on a certain basis or against individuals, if they are considered as representatives of these groups, was the concept of “acts of barbarity” and “acts of vandalism”, proposed by Lemkin in 1933. It is emphasized that these concepts formed the basis of the concept of “genocide” proposed by him. It is stated that the term “genocide” to a greater extent reflected the concept of “acts of bar-barity” previously proposed by Lemkin, although it also included the essential components of “acts of vandalism”. The article establishes that Rafał Lemkin’s views on the essence and ways to counteract the crime of genocide eventually formed the basis of the provisions of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide of 1948, of which he was the main author. It has been found that the text of this Convention does not fully reflect the totality of Lemkin’s views on the crime of genocide. It is stated that later this discrepancy led to problems in the qualification of specific acts as genocide. The significance of the concept of the crime of genocide by Rafał Lemkin for the present is analyzed. For this purpose, in particular, the criminal legislation of European states is studied in order to find out how the legislators of foreign states implemented the provisions of the Genocide Convention. It is emphasized that special attention should be paid to the identification by some legislators of other groups of people, not mentioned in international legal acts, against whom genocide is committed, as well as the expansion of the list of actions that form the objective side of this crime. Particular attention is paid to the Italian experience of the desire to criminalize cultural genocide, which conceptually reflects the views of Rafał Lemkin. It is suggested that some other national legislators will soon follow a similar path.
- Open Access
- 11 September 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 4,p. 482-487
Analysis of the practice of applying punishment for human trafficking
Based on the analysis of 80 convictions that have entered into force, adopted by the courts of first instance for the period from 2020 to 2024, the article establishes the peculiarities of the application of punishment for human trafficking. For this purpose, data on 103 people convicted of this crime have been summarized. The peculiarities of the courts’ consideration of the identity of the perpetrator, the circumstances that mitigate and aggravate the punishment are clarified, attention is drawn to the main mistakes that occur in this case. It was established that 96,1% of persons convicted of human trafficking were sentenced by the court to imprisonment. Four (3,9%) convicts (in all cases convicted under Part 2 of Article 149 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine) were sentenced by the courts to a fine (in order to impose a milder punishment than provided for by law). Six (5,8%) convicts were sentenced to an additional punishment in the form of confiscation of property. It was found that the minimum term of punishment in the form of imprisonment for a certain period for human trafficking reached 2 years (in the order of imposing a milder punishment than provided for by law), the maximum - 8 years. For the most part, the courts imposed punishment in the form of imprisonment for a term of 5 years, which thus allowed them to release the convict from serving a sentence with probation. Attention is also drawn to the fact that the maximum term of punishment imposed by the court in the form of imprisonment (8 years) is the minimum term of this punishment provided for by the sanction of Part 3 of Art. 149 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. In this regard, it is concluded that Ukrainian legislator and domestic courts have different assessments of the social danger of trafficking in human beings. It was established that only 15 persons (14,6%) were sentenced to serve their sentences, the remaining 88 persons (85,4%) were released from serving a sentence on probation (Article 75 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine). Attention is drawn to the fact that only 11 people were sentenced to imprisonment for a certain period of time with its actual serving (out of 99 people to whom the court imposed this punishment), while a fine was applied to the rest. Thus, not even every seventh offender is sentenced to actual serving a sentence for human trafficking, and only every ninth person is sentenced to imprisonment with actual serving it. It was shown that decisions to release a person from serving a probationary sentence are often not supported by proper arguments or the relevant arguments are unconvincing due to their formal nature.
- 11 September 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 4,p. 482-487
Open AccessAnalysis of the practice of applying punishment for human trafficking
Based on the analysis of 80 convictions that have entered into force, adopted by the courts of first instance for the period from 2020 to 2024, the article establishes the peculiarities of the application of punishment for human trafficking. For this purpose, data on 103 people convicted of this crime have been summarized. The peculiarities of the courts’ consideration of the identity of the perpetrator, the circumstances that mitigate and aggravate the punishment are clarified, attention is drawn to the main mistakes that occur in this case. It was established that 96,1% of persons convicted of human trafficking were sentenced by the court to imprisonment. Four (3,9%) convicts (in all cases convicted under Part 2 of Article 149 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine) were sentenced by the courts to a fine (in order to impose a milder punishment than provided for by law). Six (5,8%) convicts were sentenced to an additional punishment in the form of confiscation of property. It was found that the minimum term of punishment in the form of imprisonment for a certain period for human trafficking reached 2 years (in the order of imposing a milder punishment than provided for by law), the maximum - 8 years. For the most part, the courts imposed punishment in the form of imprisonment for a term of 5 years, which thus allowed them to release the convict from serving a sentence with probation. Attention is also drawn to the fact that the maximum term of punishment imposed by the court in the form of imprisonment (8 years) is the minimum term of this punishment provided for by the sanction of Part 3 of Art. 149 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. In this regard, it is concluded that Ukrainian legislator and domestic courts have different assessments of the social danger of trafficking in human beings. It was established that only 15 persons (14,6%) were sentenced to serve their sentences, the remaining 88 persons (85,4%) were released from serving a sentence on probation (Article 75 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine). Attention is drawn to the fact that only 11 people were sentenced to imprisonment for a certain period of time with its actual serving (out of 99 people to whom the court imposed this punishment), while a fine was applied to the rest. Thus, not even every seventh offender is sentenced to actual serving a sentence for human trafficking, and only every ninth person is sentenced to imprisonment with actual serving it. It was shown that decisions to release a person from serving a probationary sentence are often not supported by proper arguments or the relevant arguments are unconvincing due to their formal nature.
- Open Access
- 29 December 2023
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 1,p. 6-21
Certain issues of responsibility for human trafficking under the criminal law of Ukraine and Poland
The purpose of the study is to analyze certain issues of responsibility for human trafficking under the criminal law of Ukraine and Poland, as well as to develop proposals aimed at improving the criminal legislation in the relevant part. The methodological basis of the research is the comparativist method. Results. The article proves that human freedom and dignity should be recognized as the object of human trafficking. The omission of the Polish legislator is that in the title of Chapter XXIII of the Special Part of the Criminal Code of Poland, unlike the title of Chapter III of the Special Part of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, human dignity is not mentioned. The article argues that it does not make sense to single out an independent article in the Criminal Code of Ukraine on responsibility for child trafficking, because the relevant actions may well be qualified under the current Article 149, which among the forms of human trafficking singles out human trafficking as such committed without the purpose of human’s exploitation. The problem of criminal legal countermeasures against child trafficking committed without the purpose of exploitation remains relevant for Poland. Possible options for its solution may include amendments to Art. 115 § 22 of the Polish Criminal Code or the inclusion to the criminal law of an independent article on responsibility for the specified offense. The opinion expressed in the legal literature about the expediency of completely refusing to indicate the methods of committing human trafficking should be recognized as unfounded. It is in view of deception, blackmail, being in a vulnerable state, etc., that a person gives his/her consent to the work offered to him/her, to engagement in prostitution, etc., and it is in view of this, and also in view of the purpose of further exploitation, that even his/her voluntary consent does not exclude criminal liability of the perpetrator. The article argues that indicating the purpose of exploitation allows to distinguish a criminal act from actions that are not criminally punishable. Persons who recruit, move, hide or transfer a person are, of course, primarily interested in the material benefit they wish to receive as a result of their actions. At the same time, they act in this way, realizing that the person recruited (moved, etc.) by them will be exploited by others in the future. The realization of the goal of exploitation lies outside the scope of human trafficking, and therefore human exploitation must be additionally qualified under other articles of the law on criminal liability. Conclusions. The article establishes that despite some differences in the wording of the criminal law prohibition of human trafficking the legislators of Ukraine and Poland have by now approximated their understanding of the essence of this act with its definition formulated in the Palermo Protocol and the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings. The analysis of scientific works devoted to the issue of human trafficking proved that many questions raised by Ukrainian and Polish researchers are identical. The solutions they offer are often similar too.
- 29 December 2023
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 1,p. 6-21
Open AccessCertain issues of responsibility for human trafficking under the criminal law of Ukraine and Poland
The purpose of the study is to analyze certain issues of responsibility for human trafficking under the criminal law of Ukraine and Poland, as well as to develop proposals aimed at improving the criminal legislation in the relevant part. The methodological basis of the research is the comparativist method. Results. The article proves that human freedom and dignity should be recognized as the object of human trafficking. The omission of the Polish legislator is that in the title of Chapter XXIII of the Special Part of the Criminal Code of Poland, unlike the title of Chapter III of the Special Part of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, human dignity is not mentioned. The article argues that it does not make sense to single out an independent article in the Criminal Code of Ukraine on responsibility for child trafficking, because the relevant actions may well be qualified under the current Article 149, which among the forms of human trafficking singles out human trafficking as such committed without the purpose of human’s exploitation. The problem of criminal legal countermeasures against child trafficking committed without the purpose of exploitation remains relevant for Poland. Possible options for its solution may include amendments to Art. 115 § 22 of the Polish Criminal Code or the inclusion to the criminal law of an independent article on responsibility for the specified offense. The opinion expressed in the legal literature about the expediency of completely refusing to indicate the methods of committing human trafficking should be recognized as unfounded. It is in view of deception, blackmail, being in a vulnerable state, etc., that a person gives his/her consent to the work offered to him/her, to engagement in prostitution, etc., and it is in view of this, and also in view of the purpose of further exploitation, that even his/her voluntary consent does not exclude criminal liability of the perpetrator. The article argues that indicating the purpose of exploitation allows to distinguish a criminal act from actions that are not criminally punishable. Persons who recruit, move, hide or transfer a person are, of course, primarily interested in the material benefit they wish to receive as a result of their actions. At the same time, they act in this way, realizing that the person recruited (moved, etc.) by them will be exploited by others in the future. The realization of the goal of exploitation lies outside the scope of human trafficking, and therefore human exploitation must be additionally qualified under other articles of the law on criminal liability. Conclusions. The article establishes that despite some differences in the wording of the criminal law prohibition of human trafficking the legislators of Ukraine and Poland have by now approximated their understanding of the essence of this act with its definition formulated in the Palermo Protocol and the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings. The analysis of scientific works devoted to the issue of human trafficking proved that many questions raised by Ukrainian and Polish researchers are identical. The solutions they offer are often similar too.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2022
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 1,p. 308-319
Comparative analysis of the legislation of foreign countries on criminal liability for enforced disappearance.
The article analyzes the foreign experience of criminal law counteraction to enforced disappearances on the basis of research of the legislation of 50 countries. A study of the criminal law of approximately 100 countries has shown that criminal law prohibitions on enforced disappearances are currently contained in the legislation of Albania, Angola, Argentina, Armenia, Australia, Austria, Azerbaijan, Belgium, Bolivia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cambodia, Chad, Colombia, Congo, Croatia, the Czech Republic, El Salvador, Finland, France, Gabon, Germany, Guatemala, Honduras, Kyrgyzstan, Lesotho, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Mali, Malta, Mexico, Moldova, Mongolia, Montenegro, Netherlands, Nicaragua, Norway, Northern Macedonia, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Poland, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland, Venezuela. It is found that the place of enforced disappearance in the system of the Special Part of foreign criminal laws is defined differently. The article establishes that the vast majority of legislators recognized this act as a crime against international law order. It is noteworthy that many legislators did not single out a separate article on liability for enforced disappearance, but recognized this act as a type of crime against humanity, mentioning it in the relevant “general” article. The article establishes that while formulating the disposition of the relevant criminal law prohibition, most legislators of foreign countries proceeded from the definition of enforced disappearance, given in Art. 2 of the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance, and from the definition of this act, given in paragraph “i” of Part 2 of Art. 7 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Attention is drawn to the fact that these international legal acts set different standards for criminalizing enforced disappearances. There is a significant variety of existing approaches not only to criminalization, but also to penalizing enforced disappearances. The article emphasizes that the studied foreign experience may be needed in improving the domestic criminal law prohibition on liability for such encroachment. In particular, the overwhelming majority of legislators attribute enforced disappearances to crimes against international law order rather than to encroachments on personal liberty.
- 2 July 2022
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 1,p. 308-319
Open AccessComparative analysis of the legislation of foreign countries on criminal liability for enforced disappearance.
The article analyzes the foreign experience of criminal law counteraction to enforced disappearances on the basis of research of the legislation of 50 countries. A study of the criminal law of approximately 100 countries has shown that criminal law prohibitions on enforced disappearances are currently contained in the legislation of Albania, Angola, Argentina, Armenia, Australia, Austria, Azerbaijan, Belgium, Bolivia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cambodia, Chad, Colombia, Congo, Croatia, the Czech Republic, El Salvador, Finland, France, Gabon, Germany, Guatemala, Honduras, Kyrgyzstan, Lesotho, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Mali, Malta, Mexico, Moldova, Mongolia, Montenegro, Netherlands, Nicaragua, Norway, Northern Macedonia, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Poland, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland, Venezuela. It is found that the place of enforced disappearance in the system of the Special Part of foreign criminal laws is defined differently. The article establishes that the vast majority of legislators recognized this act as a crime against international law order. It is noteworthy that many legislators did not single out a separate article on liability for enforced disappearance, but recognized this act as a type of crime against humanity, mentioning it in the relevant “general” article. The article establishes that while formulating the disposition of the relevant criminal law prohibition, most legislators of foreign countries proceeded from the definition of enforced disappearance, given in Art. 2 of the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance, and from the definition of this act, given in paragraph “i” of Part 2 of Art. 7 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Attention is drawn to the fact that these international legal acts set different standards for criminalizing enforced disappearances. There is a significant variety of existing approaches not only to criminalization, but also to penalizing enforced disappearances. The article emphasizes that the studied foreign experience may be needed in improving the domestic criminal law prohibition on liability for such encroachment. In particular, the overwhelming majority of legislators attribute enforced disappearances to crimes against international law order rather than to encroachments on personal liberty.
- Open Access
- 28 April 2022
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 4,p. 232-248
Victimological characteristics of victims of human trafficking
На підставі аналізу матеріалів 300 кримінальних проваджень, розглянутих судами України за період з 2010 по 2019 рік, розроблено віктимологічну характеристику жертв торгівлі людьми. Автором узагальнено дані, що стосуються 1167 потерпілих від вказаного посягання. Здійснений аналіз засвідчив, що 1147 (98,3%) жертв цього злочину – потерпілі від торгівлі людьми, вчиненої з метою експлуатації. Із цих осіб 918 (80%) – жертви торгівлі людьми, вчиненої з метою сексуальної експлуатації, 124 (10,8%) – з метою експлуатації у формі примусової праці, 49 (4,3%) – з метою примусового втягнення в зайняття жебрацтвом, 46 (4%) – з метою використання в порнобізнесі, 10 (0,9%) – з метою вилучення органів. Ще 20 (1,7%) осіб – жертви торгівлі дітьми, вчиненої їхніми батьками задля подальшого їх усиновлення (удочеріння) іншими особами. З’ясовано соціально-демографічні та інші характеристики жертв торгівлі людьми. Зокрема, встановлено, що серед 1167 потерпілих від аналізованого посягання 1019 (87,3%) – особи жіночої статі, 148 (12,7%) – чоловічої. Вік потерпілих від торгівлі людьми у процентному відношенні розподілився так: до 14 років – 2,6%, від 14 до 18 років – 6,1%, від 18 до 30 років – 75,9%, від 30 до 40 років – 13,2%, від 40 до 50 років – 1,5%, від 50 до 60 років – 0,6%, понад 60 років – 0,1%. Встановлено, що абсолютну більшість жертв торгівлі людьми об’єднує їх уразливий стан, в якому вони перебувають. Лише одиниці потерпілих від торгівлі людьми на момент вчинення щодо них вказаного злочину були працевлаштованими, однак скаржились своєму вербувальнику, що рівень доходів не дозволяє їм забезпечити навіть найелементарніші проблеми, вони погрузли в боргах, мусять утримувати неповнолітніх дітей, хворих батьків тощо. Абсолютна ж більшість досліджуваних осіб не мала ніякої оплачуваної роботи або ж перебивалась випадковими заробітками. Окремі з потерпілих від торгівлі людьми, вчиненої з метою сексуальної експлуатації, – особи, які раніше займалися проституцією. Проаналізовано особливості віктимної поведінки жертв торгівлі людьми на різних етапах вчинення цього злочину. Серед іншого, констатовано, що жертви торгівлі людьми зазвичай не ставляться до зроблених їм пропозицій щодо працевлаштування критично. При цьому нерідко має місце не просто відсутність достатньої пильності, а нічим не обґрунтована («сліпа») довіра до незнайомої людини, котра обіцяє легке вирішення матеріальних проблем.
- 28 April 2022
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 4,p. 232-248
Open AccessVictimological characteristics of victims of human trafficking
На підставі аналізу матеріалів 300 кримінальних проваджень, розглянутих судами України за період з 2010 по 2019 рік, розроблено віктимологічну характеристику жертв торгівлі людьми. Автором узагальнено дані, що стосуються 1167 потерпілих від вказаного посягання. Здійснений аналіз засвідчив, що 1147 (98,3%) жертв цього злочину – потерпілі від торгівлі людьми, вчиненої з метою експлуатації. Із цих осіб 918 (80%) – жертви торгівлі людьми, вчиненої з метою сексуальної експлуатації, 124 (10,8%) – з метою експлуатації у формі примусової праці, 49 (4,3%) – з метою примусового втягнення в зайняття жебрацтвом, 46 (4%) – з метою використання в порнобізнесі, 10 (0,9%) – з метою вилучення органів. Ще 20 (1,7%) осіб – жертви торгівлі дітьми, вчиненої їхніми батьками задля подальшого їх усиновлення (удочеріння) іншими особами. З’ясовано соціально-демографічні та інші характеристики жертв торгівлі людьми. Зокрема, встановлено, що серед 1167 потерпілих від аналізованого посягання 1019 (87,3%) – особи жіночої статі, 148 (12,7%) – чоловічої. Вік потерпілих від торгівлі людьми у процентному відношенні розподілився так: до 14 років – 2,6%, від 14 до 18 років – 6,1%, від 18 до 30 років – 75,9%, від 30 до 40 років – 13,2%, від 40 до 50 років – 1,5%, від 50 до 60 років – 0,6%, понад 60 років – 0,1%. Встановлено, що абсолютну більшість жертв торгівлі людьми об’єднує їх уразливий стан, в якому вони перебувають. Лише одиниці потерпілих від торгівлі людьми на момент вчинення щодо них вказаного злочину були працевлаштованими, однак скаржились своєму вербувальнику, що рівень доходів не дозволяє їм забезпечити навіть найелементарніші проблеми, вони погрузли в боргах, мусять утримувати неповнолітніх дітей, хворих батьків тощо. Абсолютна ж більшість досліджуваних осіб не мала ніякої оплачуваної роботи або ж перебивалась випадковими заробітками. Окремі з потерпілих від торгівлі людьми, вчиненої з метою сексуальної експлуатації, – особи, які раніше займалися проституцією. Проаналізовано особливості віктимної поведінки жертв торгівлі людьми на різних етапах вчинення цього злочину. Серед іншого, констатовано, що жертви торгівлі людьми зазвичай не ставляться до зроблених їм пропозицій щодо працевлаштування критично. При цьому нерідко має місце не просто відсутність достатньої пильності, а нічим не обґрунтована («сліпа») довіра до незнайомої людини, котра обіцяє легке вирішення матеріальних проблем.
- Open Access
- 12 April 2022
- Published by Penitentiary Association of Ukraine in Вісник Пенітенціарної асоціації України
- No. 4,p. 5-21
Зарубіжний досвід кримінально-правової протидії торгівлі людьми
У статті на підставі вивчення законодавства 54 держав світу проаналізовано зарубіжний досвід кримінально-правової протидії торгівлі людьми. Зроблено висновок про те, що на сьогодні більшість національних законодавців наблизили своє розуміння сутності вказаного діяння із його визначенням, сформульованим у Палермському протоколі та в Конвенції Ради Європи про заходи щодо протидії торгівлі людьми.
- 12 April 2022
- Published by Penitentiary Association of Ukraine in Вісник Пенітенціарної асоціації України
- No. 4,p. 5-21
Open AccessЗарубіжний досвід кримінально-правової протидії торгівлі людьми
У статті на підставі вивчення законодавства 54 держав світу проаналізовано зарубіжний досвід кримінально-правової протидії торгівлі людьми. Зроблено висновок про те, що на сьогодні більшість національних законодавців наблизили своє розуміння сутності вказаного діяння із його визначенням, сформульованим у Палермському протоколі та в Конвенції Ради Європи про заходи щодо протидії торгівлі людьми.