Yana Pankova
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Yana Pankova has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Yuliya Mikhaylova
Russian Research Institute of Health, Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation, Moscow, Russia
7 shared publications - Aleksandr Mikhaylov
Russian Research Institute of Health, Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation, Moscow, Russia
6 shared publications - Sergey A. Sterlikov
Russian Medical Academy of Continuous Professional Education
6 shared publications - Georgiy Vvedensky
A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Medical Care Station
4 shared publications - A. V. Gordina
National Medical Research Center of Phthisiopulmonology and Infectious Diseases
1 shared publication - D. A. Kucheryavaya
Russian Research Institute of Health
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 72 (3) , 7
REGULATORY AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION: MODERN CHALLENGES AND DEVELOPMENT VECTORS. AN ANALYTICAL REVIEW
Significance. The emergency medical service system is a critically important component of the national healthcare system, ensuring implementation of the constitutional guarantees for health protection. The legal and regulatory framework governing emergency medical service activities was primarily established between 2011 and 2013 and constitutes a complex multi-level system that requires continuous improvement in response to structural transformations within the healthcare sector and the need to adapt to evolving conditions, including ongoing digitalization processes. This need is particularly pronounced in metropolitan areas, where high population density, traffic congestion, and infrastructural complexity substantially increase the workload of emergency medical services, while the development of timely legal regulation is lagging behind operational demands. Addressing the challenges of legal and regulatory governance in the organization and delivery of emergency medical care requires objective and up-to-date knowledge of the current state of the regulatory environment. Purpose. To conduct a comprehensive analysis of the current legal and regulatory framework governing the organization and provision of emergency medical care in the Russian Federation to identify existing challenges, and develop proposals for optimizing the legal support for emergency medical service performance. Material and methods. An analytical review of the current legislative framework, including federal and regional regulatory legal acts governing the organization and delivery of emergency medical care, was conducted. Comparative legal analysis methods were employed. Results. A well-established legislative framework and a multi-level system of legal and regulatory governance for organizing and providing emergency medical care were identified. Key areas requiring attention and resolution have been identified: legal regulation of first aid; conceptual ambiguity in the classification of types of medical care in emergency and urgent cases; shortcomings of Order No.388n regarding the regulatory and time‑based management of emergency medical services’ functions; staffing issues; imbalance in the regulation of patients’ rights in the medical process; lack of legal protection for healthcare specialists and mandatory insurance of professional risks; imperfect regulation of routing during medical evacuation; and the accelerated implementation of digital technologies in healthcare organizations compared to their legal regulation. The experience of Moscow in establishing detailed regulations for emergency medical service operations is presented, and the feasibility of transitioning from a rigid regulatory model to a flexible and adaptive framework that accounts for regional specificities is substantia Conclusion. Improving the legal and regulatory framework for the organization and provision of emergency medical care requires eliminating conceptual ambiguities, updating foundational regulatory documents in accordance with contemporary realities, including the integration of digital technologies, developing comprehensive measures to address workforce shortages, and strengthening the legal protection of healthcare professionals. Specific approaches to optimization are proposed, including amendments to Federal Law No. 323-FZ and Order No. 388n of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation. Keywords: emergency medical services; legal and regulatory framework; first aid; emergency medical care; patient routing; medical evacuation; workforce provision; digitalization; artificial intelligence.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 72 (3) , 7
REGULATORY AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION: MODERN CHALLENGES AND DEVELOPMENT VECTORS. AN ANALYTICAL REVIEW
Significance. The emergency medical service system is a critically important component of the national healthcare system, ensuring implementation of the constitutional guarantees for health protection. The legal and regulatory framework governing emergency medical service activities was primarily established between 2011 and 2013 and constitutes a complex multi-level system that requires continuous improvement in response to structural transformations within the healthcare sector and the need to adapt to evolving conditions, including ongoing digitalization processes. This need is particularly pronounced in metropolitan areas, where high population density, traffic congestion, and infrastructural complexity substantially increase the workload of emergency medical services, while the development of timely legal regulation is lagging behind operational demands. Addressing the challenges of legal and regulatory governance in the organization and delivery of emergency medical care requires objective and up-to-date knowledge of the current state of the regulatory environment. Purpose. To conduct a comprehensive analysis of the current legal and regulatory framework governing the organization and provision of emergency medical care in the Russian Federation to identify existing challenges, and develop proposals for optimizing the legal support for emergency medical service performance. Material and methods. An analytical review of the current legislative framework, including federal and regional regulatory legal acts governing the organization and delivery of emergency medical care, was conducted. Comparative legal analysis methods were employed. Results. A well-established legislative framework and a multi-level system of legal and regulatory governance for organizing and providing emergency medical care were identified. Key areas requiring attention and resolution have been identified: legal regulation of first aid; conceptual ambiguity in the classification of types of medical care in emergency and urgent cases; shortcomings of Order No.388n regarding the regulatory and time‑based management of emergency medical services’ functions; staffing issues; imbalance in the regulation of patients’ rights in the medical process; lack of legal protection for healthcare specialists and mandatory insurance of professional risks; imperfect regulation of routing during medical evacuation; and the accelerated implementation of digital technologies in healthcare organizations compared to their legal regulation. The experience of Moscow in establishing detailed regulations for emergency medical service operations is presented, and the feasibility of transitioning from a rigid regulatory model to a flexible and adaptive framework that accounts for regional specificities is substantia Conclusion. Improving the legal and regulatory framework for the organization and provision of emergency medical care requires eliminating conceptual ambiguities, updating foundational regulatory documents in accordance with contemporary realities, including the integration of digital technologies, developing comprehensive measures to address workforce shortages, and strengthening the legal protection of healthcare professionals. Specific approaches to optimization are proposed, including amendments to Federal Law No. 323-FZ and Order No. 388n of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation. Keywords: emergency medical services; legal and regulatory framework; first aid; emergency medical care; patient routing; medical evacuation; workforce provision; digitalization; artificial intelligence.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 72 (2) , 21
METHODOLOGICAL APPROACHES TO ASSESSING THE SPATIAL INHOMOGENEITY OF TUBERCULOSIS
Significance. The relevance of the study is due, on the one hand, to the different severity of socio-economic, climatic, environmental, and medical factors, and, on the other hand, to the differences in the methods for determining the burden of tuberculosis. Purpose. To assess the spatial heterogeneity of the tuberculosis burden in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation and to assess the consistency of different methods for its determination. Material and methods. Using statistical observation data and four different methods (DALYs, incidence calculation, prevalence calculation, and calculation of annual labor losses from tuberculosis), indicators of the tuberculosis burden for the constituent entities of the Russian Federation were calculated and mapped, as well as a correlation analysis of the obtained intensive indicators of the tuberculosis burden (s) was carried out. Results. Cartographic and correlation analyses revealed satisfactory agreement between methods for calculating the burden of tuberculosis based on DALYs, incident and prevalent methods (s>0.85; p<0.05). There is a general trend towards an increase in the burden of tuberculosis from west to east and from north to south, comparable to geographical trends in tuberculosis incidence and mortality in border states. Conclusion. Despite the differences in the calculation methods, the burden of tuberculosis can be satisfactorily estimated not only using the time-consuming DALY, but also using simpler methods, such as the calculation of tuberculosis incidence and prevalence, which have a close statistical relationship both with each other and with DALYs. The results of using data on annual labor losses due to tuberculosis to estimate the burden of tuberculosis are poorly consistent with other methods and is not recommended for use for this purpose. The lowest burden of tuberculosis is observed in the Central and Northwestern Federal Districts and tends to increase from west to east within comparable latitude and from north to south within comparable longitude. Scope: monitoring of tuberculosis control measures. Keywords: TB burden; DALY; methods for determining the burden of disease; geographical features; spatial heterogeneity.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 72 (2) , 21
METHODOLOGICAL APPROACHES TO ASSESSING THE SPATIAL INHOMOGENEITY OF TUBERCULOSIS
Significance. The relevance of the study is due, on the one hand, to the different severity of socio-economic, climatic, environmental, and medical factors, and, on the other hand, to the differences in the methods for determining the burden of tuberculosis. Purpose. To assess the spatial heterogeneity of the tuberculosis burden in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation and to assess the consistency of different methods for its determination. Material and methods. Using statistical observation data and four different methods (DALYs, incidence calculation, prevalence calculation, and calculation of annual labor losses from tuberculosis), indicators of the tuberculosis burden for the constituent entities of the Russian Federation were calculated and mapped, as well as a correlation analysis of the obtained intensive indicators of the tuberculosis burden (s) was carried out. Results. Cartographic and correlation analyses revealed satisfactory agreement between methods for calculating the burden of tuberculosis based on DALYs, incident and prevalent methods (s>0.85; p<0.05). There is a general trend towards an increase in the burden of tuberculosis from west to east and from north to south, comparable to geographical trends in tuberculosis incidence and mortality in border states. Conclusion. Despite the differences in the calculation methods, the burden of tuberculosis can be satisfactorily estimated not only using the time-consuming DALY, but also using simpler methods, such as the calculation of tuberculosis incidence and prevalence, which have a close statistical relationship both with each other and with DALYs. The results of using data on annual labor losses due to tuberculosis to estimate the burden of tuberculosis are poorly consistent with other methods and is not recommended for use for this purpose. The lowest burden of tuberculosis is observed in the Central and Northwestern Federal Districts and tends to increase from west to east within comparable latitude and from north to south within comparable longitude. Scope: monitoring of tuberculosis control measures. Keywords: TB burden; DALY; methods for determining the burden of disease; geographical features; spatial heterogeneity.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 72 (1) , 17
MEDICAL AND SOCIAL FACTORS INFLUENCING THE DURATION OF TUBERCULOSIS TREATMENT IN THE YAMALO-NENETS AUTONOMOUS OKRUG
Significance. In the context of the stabilized TB incidence rates, coupled with a high treatment success rate in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug, the analysis of treatment duration and contributing factors is of great importance. Purpose. To analyze factors influencing the duration of treatment of patients with tuberculosis (from case registration to clinical cure). Material and methods. A retrospective longitudinal study of 1,602 newly diagnosed TB adults registered from 2010 to 2022 was conducted, with the analysis of the totality of treatment courses until clinical cure was achieved (the deceased patients and dropouts were excluded). A multivariate survival analysis was performed using the Cox regression model to estimate the hazard ratio (HR) and 95% confidence intervals (95% CI) for HR. Results. Factors increasing the duration of TB treatment include as follows: belonging to the indigenous minorities of the North (HR=0.77; 95% CI - 0.66-0.91; p=0.002), the use of psychoactive substances (HR=0.75; 95% CI - 0.59-0.94; p=0.015) and male gender (HR= 0.88; 95% CI- 0.79-0.99; p=0.03). Factors contributing to a reduction in the treatment duration include patient employment (HR=1.32; 95% CI 1.18-1.47; p<0.001), a fluorographic examination within two years prior to TB detection (HR=1.30; 95% CI 1.15-1.45; p<0.001), and active case detection (HR=1.17; 95% CI 1.05-1.30; p=0.006). Conclusion. Based on the results obtained, it can be asserted that the following measures are advisable to reduce the duration of TB treatment in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug: prevention and treatment of addiction to psychoactive substances, especially among males belonging to the indigenous minorities of the North; public awareness about the importance of regular fluorographic examination, with a focus on unemployed citizens of working age and indigenous minorities of the North; involving individuals who have not undergone a fluorographic examination for two years or more in preventive TB screening. The influence of the time since the last fluorographic examination on the duration of treatment is a statistically confirmed argument in favor of increasing the frequency of preventive fluorographic screening. Scope of application. Planning regional activities to reduce the burden of tuberculosis in the regions of the Far North. Keywords: tuberculosis; duration of treatment; active case detection; indigenous population; TB burden.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 72 (1) , 17
MEDICAL AND SOCIAL FACTORS INFLUENCING THE DURATION OF TUBERCULOSIS TREATMENT IN THE YAMALO-NENETS AUTONOMOUS OKRUG
Significance. In the context of the stabilized TB incidence rates, coupled with a high treatment success rate in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug, the analysis of treatment duration and contributing factors is of great importance. Purpose. To analyze factors influencing the duration of treatment of patients with tuberculosis (from case registration to clinical cure). Material and methods. A retrospective longitudinal study of 1,602 newly diagnosed TB adults registered from 2010 to 2022 was conducted, with the analysis of the totality of treatment courses until clinical cure was achieved (the deceased patients and dropouts were excluded). A multivariate survival analysis was performed using the Cox regression model to estimate the hazard ratio (HR) and 95% confidence intervals (95% CI) for HR. Results. Factors increasing the duration of TB treatment include as follows: belonging to the indigenous minorities of the North (HR=0.77; 95% CI - 0.66-0.91; p=0.002), the use of psychoactive substances (HR=0.75; 95% CI - 0.59-0.94; p=0.015) and male gender (HR= 0.88; 95% CI- 0.79-0.99; p=0.03). Factors contributing to a reduction in the treatment duration include patient employment (HR=1.32; 95% CI 1.18-1.47; p<0.001), a fluorographic examination within two years prior to TB detection (HR=1.30; 95% CI 1.15-1.45; p<0.001), and active case detection (HR=1.17; 95% CI 1.05-1.30; p=0.006). Conclusion. Based on the results obtained, it can be asserted that the following measures are advisable to reduce the duration of TB treatment in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug: prevention and treatment of addiction to psychoactive substances, especially among males belonging to the indigenous minorities of the North; public awareness about the importance of regular fluorographic examination, with a focus on unemployed citizens of working age and indigenous minorities of the North; involving individuals who have not undergone a fluorographic examination for two years or more in preventive TB screening. The influence of the time since the last fluorographic examination on the duration of treatment is a statistically confirmed argument in favor of increasing the frequency of preventive fluorographic screening. Scope of application. Planning regional activities to reduce the burden of tuberculosis in the regions of the Far North. Keywords: tuberculosis; duration of treatment; active case detection; indigenous population; TB burden.
- 30 October 2025
- Published by National Medical Research Center for Childrens Health in Russian Pediatric Journal
- Vol. 28 (5)
Epidemiology of neurofibromatosis in children in the Russian Federation over 2015–2024
Neurofibromatosis is an orphan disease of the phakomatose group, the timely treatment of which helps to reduce the burden of pain and surgical interventions. Aim. To analyze the trend in the neurofibromatosis epidemic in children over the past decade in the context of timely diagnosis of the disease and early treatment initiation.Materials and methods. The authors have analyzed official statistical data (federal statistical observation form No.12) for 2015–2024 for Russia as a whole and by urban and rural population, as well as by constituent entity of the Russian Federation.Results. The prevalence of neurofibromatosis in 0–4 year children increased from 3.9 in 2016 to 7.1 per 100,000 children of the corresponding age in 2024; in children aged 5–9 years — from 5.3 to 9.4; and in children aged 10–14 years — from 11.7 to 18.2; The incidence in 0–14 years children aged increased from 7.8 in 2015 to 16.6 in 2024, and in children aged 15–17 years — from 5.8 to 12.1. There was an increase in the incidence rate in 0–14 year children – from 1.3 in 2015 to 1.8 in 2023. The incidence rate in adolescents changed statistically insignificantly, amounting to 0.8 per 100,000 children aged of 15–17 years in both 2015 and 2024. Only 3.5% of children are detected during preventive examinations. The incidence of neurofibromatosis in rural residents is significantly lower than in urban areas. The average 10-year prevalence rate of neurofibromatosis in children aged 0–17 years varies across regions from 0.3 to 27.2 per 100,000 population (the interquartile range equaled to 7.2); the incidence rate ranges from 0.0 to 5.1. The highest values are associated with regions with an ethnic and genetic prevalence of the Finno-Ugric population.Conclusion. The increase in the incidence of neurofibromatosis is associated with underdiagnosis of this disease and low detection rates during preventive examinations. Given the availability of treatments that can reduce the burden of pain syndrome and surgical interventions, it is advisable to realize measures to identify patients with neurofibromatosis in organized children’s groups, for example, periodic surveys of schoolchildren for the neurofibromatosis symptoms, using online tools.Contribution: Vitkovskaya I.P. — concept and design of the study, writing the text; Sterlikov S.A. — statistical analysis, writing the text; Zelenova O.V. — management of scientific collaboration and coordination; Oskov Yu.I. — collection of statistical material and methodological consulting; Pankova Ya.Yu. — support for research planning, editing the text. All co-authors — approval of the final version of the article, responsibility for the integrity of all parts of the article.Acknowledgment. The study had no sponsorship.Conflict of interest. The authors declare no conflict of interest.Received: September 15, 2025Accepted: October 02, 2025Published: October 30, 2025
- 30 October 2025
- Published by National Medical Research Center for Childrens Health in Russian Pediatric Journal
- Vol. 28 (5)
Epidemiology of neurofibromatosis in children in the Russian Federation over 2015–2024
Neurofibromatosis is an orphan disease of the phakomatose group, the timely treatment of which helps to reduce the burden of pain and surgical interventions. Aim. To analyze the trend in the neurofibromatosis epidemic in children over the past decade in the context of timely diagnosis of the disease and early treatment initiation.Materials and methods. The authors have analyzed official statistical data (federal statistical observation form No.12) for 2015–2024 for Russia as a whole and by urban and rural population, as well as by constituent entity of the Russian Federation.Results. The prevalence of neurofibromatosis in 0–4 year children increased from 3.9 in 2016 to 7.1 per 100,000 children of the corresponding age in 2024; in children aged 5–9 years — from 5.3 to 9.4; and in children aged 10–14 years — from 11.7 to 18.2; The incidence in 0–14 years children aged increased from 7.8 in 2015 to 16.6 in 2024, and in children aged 15–17 years — from 5.8 to 12.1. There was an increase in the incidence rate in 0–14 year children – from 1.3 in 2015 to 1.8 in 2023. The incidence rate in adolescents changed statistically insignificantly, amounting to 0.8 per 100,000 children aged of 15–17 years in both 2015 and 2024. Only 3.5% of children are detected during preventive examinations. The incidence of neurofibromatosis in rural residents is significantly lower than in urban areas. The average 10-year prevalence rate of neurofibromatosis in children aged 0–17 years varies across regions from 0.3 to 27.2 per 100,000 population (the interquartile range equaled to 7.2); the incidence rate ranges from 0.0 to 5.1. The highest values are associated with regions with an ethnic and genetic prevalence of the Finno-Ugric population.Conclusion. The increase in the incidence of neurofibromatosis is associated with underdiagnosis of this disease and low detection rates during preventive examinations. Given the availability of treatments that can reduce the burden of pain syndrome and surgical interventions, it is advisable to realize measures to identify patients with neurofibromatosis in organized children’s groups, for example, periodic surveys of schoolchildren for the neurofibromatosis symptoms, using online tools.Contribution: Vitkovskaya I.P. — concept and design of the study, writing the text; Sterlikov S.A. — statistical analysis, writing the text; Zelenova O.V. — management of scientific collaboration and coordination; Oskov Yu.I. — collection of statistical material and methodological consulting; Pankova Ya.Yu. — support for research planning, editing the text. All co-authors — approval of the final version of the article, responsibility for the integrity of all parts of the article.Acknowledgment. The study had no sponsorship.Conflict of interest. The authors declare no conflict of interest.Received: September 15, 2025Accepted: October 02, 2025Published: October 30, 2025
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 71 (6) , 2
INNOVATIVE DEVELOPMENT IN HEALTHCARE THROUGH THE EYES OF MEDICAL WORKERS EXEMPLIFIED BY THE MOSCOW AMBULANCE SERVICE
Significance. Conducting sociological surveys of medical personnel of the ambulance service, their assessment of problems and factors requiring the introduction of innovations is a necessary condition for improving the organization of work of emergency medical services, including ambulance and specialized care. Purpose. Based on the opinion of managers and medical staff of ambulance teams to formulate recommendations for innovative development of ambulance service, including issues of technological and organizational development. Material and methods. A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Medical Care Station was the study base. It is an independent medical organization and is directly subordinate to the Moscow Healthcare Department. A sociological survey was based on an anonymous questioning of the heads of the ambulance, specialized and emergency services and medical workers of mobile ambulance teams, including doctors and nursing staff. The sample included 1257 people. Statistical processing of the obtained results was carried out using Microsoft Excel and descriptive statistics methods. Results. A sociological survey conducted among managers and medical professional of ambulance teams in Moscow, including specialized care teams, made it possible to assess the system of management and organizational structure of the ambulance service, identify key areas for improvement and most important factors affecting the service effectiveness. Based on the results of the analysis, recommendations have been made to improve organizational measures and develop innovative approaches to improving quality of emergency care delivery to the population. The analysis of responses by position of the respondent, length of service, gender and age made it possible to identify major areas for innovation: "Optimization of logistics and management" and "Ensuring safety and quality based on artificial intelligence". Conclusion. The analysis of the management methods and structure of the ambulance service, including specialized care delivery, conducted by direct actors in the process of management and organization of the ambulance service, has formed a reliable platform for the development of innovative strategies and the creation of effective organizational solutions aimed at improving the quality of and access to emergency care to the population. Keywords: emergency care; innovative development of emergency care; medical personnel; questionnaire; sociological research.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 71 (6) , 2
INNOVATIVE DEVELOPMENT IN HEALTHCARE THROUGH THE EYES OF MEDICAL WORKERS EXEMPLIFIED BY THE MOSCOW AMBULANCE SERVICE
Significance. Conducting sociological surveys of medical personnel of the ambulance service, their assessment of problems and factors requiring the introduction of innovations is a necessary condition for improving the organization of work of emergency medical services, including ambulance and specialized care. Purpose. Based on the opinion of managers and medical staff of ambulance teams to formulate recommendations for innovative development of ambulance service, including issues of technological and organizational development. Material and methods. A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Medical Care Station was the study base. It is an independent medical organization and is directly subordinate to the Moscow Healthcare Department. A sociological survey was based on an anonymous questioning of the heads of the ambulance, specialized and emergency services and medical workers of mobile ambulance teams, including doctors and nursing staff. The sample included 1257 people. Statistical processing of the obtained results was carried out using Microsoft Excel and descriptive statistics methods. Results. A sociological survey conducted among managers and medical professional of ambulance teams in Moscow, including specialized care teams, made it possible to assess the system of management and organizational structure of the ambulance service, identify key areas for improvement and most important factors affecting the service effectiveness. Based on the results of the analysis, recommendations have been made to improve organizational measures and develop innovative approaches to improving quality of emergency care delivery to the population. The analysis of responses by position of the respondent, length of service, gender and age made it possible to identify major areas for innovation: "Optimization of logistics and management" and "Ensuring safety and quality based on artificial intelligence". Conclusion. The analysis of the management methods and structure of the ambulance service, including specialized care delivery, conducted by direct actors in the process of management and organization of the ambulance service, has formed a reliable platform for the development of innovative strategies and the creation of effective organizational solutions aimed at improving the quality of and access to emergency care to the population. Keywords: emergency care; innovative development of emergency care; medical personnel; questionnaire; sociological research.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 71 (5) , 2
THE EXPERIENCE IN USING ULTRASOUND MONITORING IN THE PRACTICE OF THE MOSCOW AMBULANCE SERVICE
Significance. The use of ultrasound monitoring in the practice of ambulance service is one of the most significant and dynamically developing areas in modern disaster medicine and emergency care. In conditions of time pressure and lack of laboratory or instrumental data, ultrasound monitoring has become a crucial tool for ambulance teams. This method allows medical professionals to quickly obtain accurate information about a patient condition. High mobility, safety and informative value of ultrasound monitoring make it an essential tool for rapid assessment of critical conditions in emergency medical situations. Purpose. To assess the level of integration of the method, identify temporary, clinical and organizational patterns of its use as well as determine its diagnostic significance, based on a comprehensive analysis of ultrasound monitoring data performed by ambulance teams in Moscow. Material and methods. The study is based on a retrospective analysis of the database of the integrated automated control system of the A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Medical Care Station on the use of ultrasound monitoring by ambulance teams. Descriptive statistics, time series analysis (distribution by hour, day of the week, month), frequency analysis of nosologies and outcomes were carried out. The coefficient of difference in the use of ultrasound monitoring between structural divisions is calculated as the ratio of the maximum number of examinations in one division to the minimum number across all divisions. Results. The article presents the results of the analytical study on the use of ultrasound monitoring by ambulance teams of the A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Medical Care Station of the Moscow Healthcare Department during 2024 - 8 months of 2025. The patterns of ultrasound examinations (by hour of the day, day of the week, month), the distribution of workload across different teams and divisions, as well as the clinical indications for ultrasound monitoring and its results, are all determined. A steady trend towards increasing the number of examinations by 19.8% on a monthly basis has been observed. The method has been shown to have a significant diagnostic value, as confirmed by the high proportion of patients who were determined to need medical evacuation after it was implemented in specialized medical institutions providing inpatient care (81.5%). Conclusion. The study results indicate a successful integration of ultrasound monitoring into the algorithms of ambulance care, its key role in diagnosing emergency conditions, as well as expanding capabilities of paramedical personnel. The differences in the use of the method between different structural units indicate a need to ensure and improve control over the use of standardized ultrasound monitoring protocols for diagnostic purposes in the ambulance service. Keywords: ultrasound monitoring (diagnostics); emergency medical care; Point-of-Care Ultrasound (FOCUS); FAST; BLUE; emergency medicine; focused urgent sonography; injury diagnostics; lung disease diagnostics
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 71 (5) , 2
THE EXPERIENCE IN USING ULTRASOUND MONITORING IN THE PRACTICE OF THE MOSCOW AMBULANCE SERVICE
Significance. The use of ultrasound monitoring in the practice of ambulance service is one of the most significant and dynamically developing areas in modern disaster medicine and emergency care. In conditions of time pressure and lack of laboratory or instrumental data, ultrasound monitoring has become a crucial tool for ambulance teams. This method allows medical professionals to quickly obtain accurate information about a patient condition. High mobility, safety and informative value of ultrasound monitoring make it an essential tool for rapid assessment of critical conditions in emergency medical situations. Purpose. To assess the level of integration of the method, identify temporary, clinical and organizational patterns of its use as well as determine its diagnostic significance, based on a comprehensive analysis of ultrasound monitoring data performed by ambulance teams in Moscow. Material and methods. The study is based on a retrospective analysis of the database of the integrated automated control system of the A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Medical Care Station on the use of ultrasound monitoring by ambulance teams. Descriptive statistics, time series analysis (distribution by hour, day of the week, month), frequency analysis of nosologies and outcomes were carried out. The coefficient of difference in the use of ultrasound monitoring between structural divisions is calculated as the ratio of the maximum number of examinations in one division to the minimum number across all divisions. Results. The article presents the results of the analytical study on the use of ultrasound monitoring by ambulance teams of the A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Medical Care Station of the Moscow Healthcare Department during 2024 - 8 months of 2025. The patterns of ultrasound examinations (by hour of the day, day of the week, month), the distribution of workload across different teams and divisions, as well as the clinical indications for ultrasound monitoring and its results, are all determined. A steady trend towards increasing the number of examinations by 19.8% on a monthly basis has been observed. The method has been shown to have a significant diagnostic value, as confirmed by the high proportion of patients who were determined to need medical evacuation after it was implemented in specialized medical institutions providing inpatient care (81.5%). Conclusion. The study results indicate a successful integration of ultrasound monitoring into the algorithms of ambulance care, its key role in diagnosing emergency conditions, as well as expanding capabilities of paramedical personnel. The differences in the use of the method between different structural units indicate a need to ensure and improve control over the use of standardized ultrasound monitoring protocols for diagnostic purposes in the ambulance service. Keywords: ultrasound monitoring (diagnostics); emergency medical care; Point-of-Care Ultrasound (FOCUS); FAST; BLUE; emergency medicine; focused urgent sonography; injury diagnostics; lung disease diagnostics
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 71 (3S) , 7
MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR ROUTING PATIENTS REGUIRING MEDICAL EVACUATION TO INPATIENT FACILITIES IN THE MEGALOPOLIS DUE TO EMERGENCY AND URGENT INDICATIONS
Significance. The issues of improving emergency and specialized medical care remain highly relevant in the Russian Federation, which is confirmed by the adoption of the Federal Project «Improvement of Emergency Medical care» within the framework of the National Project «Long and Active Life». A stably high level of lethality at the pre-hospital stage is largely associated with the time factor of receiving emergency care in a critical patient condition, which in turn depends on the prompt adoption of management decisions on the organization of optimal routing of patients during evacuation to inpatient medical organizations The regulation of patient routing processes becomes particularly relevant in the case of special situations, including mass crisis situations with massive influx of patients or victims. A spatial heterogeneity of the Russian population health, peculiarities of the socio-economic development of the regions, that form the resource base of the healthcare system in general and emergency care in particular, regional heterogeneity of settlement and population density, and differences in transport accessibility are factors of the «external environment» or risk factors, that are not dependable upon the emergency medical service. Nevertheless, these risk factors largely determine the accessibility and quality of emergency care in managing the routing organization during evacuation of patients to inpatient medical organizations. The purpose of the study is to analyze the organization of routing and evacuation of patients to inpatient medical organizations in a megalopolis and evaluate the role of innovative technologies in improving operational management decisions. Material and methods. The basis of the study was the A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Care Station, Moscow. The Station performance was analyzed according to the data of the Federal statistical observation form No. 30 «Information about a medical organization» for 2014-2023. Results. The Station is entrusted with the functions of centralized routing in the course of medical evacuation. For the period 2018-2023, the frequency of evacuations of patients to inpatient medical organizations has a multidirectional character - against the background of a decrease in the number of persons delivered by ambulance crews to hospital organizations from 1339226 in 2018 to 882334 in 2023, there is an increase in this indicator in the period 2020-2022, i.e. during the Covid-19 pandemic with a subsequent decrease in 2023. In 2024, 1582 patients with circulatory arrest during continuous resuscitation measures were delivered to specialized medical institutions with spontaneous circulation restored. As part of the centralized management of routing during medical evacuation of patients to specialized hospitals, the Station has introduced modern medical and organizational technologies based on integrated management of innovative processes, including information systems and resources to handle calls and manage ambulance crews (Integrated automated control system and Automated navigation and dispatch system management), making it possible, under the “risk” conditions, to take prompt decisions on selecting the most optimal schemes and options for routing and reducing the hospital delivery time. In order to solve multidimensional problems of patient routing and evacuation, the Station has developed and implemented the target module «patient influx control» as a subsystem in the automated management system «Hospital». Implementing the developed module, coupled with establishing a separate post of a senior doctor in the medical evacuation department, made it possible to reach a 97-98% index of patient routing. Conclusion. The feasibility and effectiveness of introducing innovative technologies into the organization of the most important stage of emergency medical care delivery in critical cases, threatening the life of the patient —routing patients to inpatient medical facilities during medical evacuation—has been proven. The development of key innovative processes at all stages of emergency medical care organization can be highlighted: information systems and resources that ensure the reception of calls and management of ambulance crews. From the position of centralized regulation of the processes of routing and evacuation of patients to specialized medical organizations, an important role is played by the development and implementation of an automated navigation and dispatch management system. Keywords: emergency medical care; patient routing; medical evacuation; innovative information technologies
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 71 (3S) , 7
MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR ROUTING PATIENTS REGUIRING MEDICAL EVACUATION TO INPATIENT FACILITIES IN THE MEGALOPOLIS DUE TO EMERGENCY AND URGENT INDICATIONS
Significance. The issues of improving emergency and specialized medical care remain highly relevant in the Russian Federation, which is confirmed by the adoption of the Federal Project «Improvement of Emergency Medical care» within the framework of the National Project «Long and Active Life». A stably high level of lethality at the pre-hospital stage is largely associated with the time factor of receiving emergency care in a critical patient condition, which in turn depends on the prompt adoption of management decisions on the organization of optimal routing of patients during evacuation to inpatient medical organizations The regulation of patient routing processes becomes particularly relevant in the case of special situations, including mass crisis situations with massive influx of patients or victims. A spatial heterogeneity of the Russian population health, peculiarities of the socio-economic development of the regions, that form the resource base of the healthcare system in general and emergency care in particular, regional heterogeneity of settlement and population density, and differences in transport accessibility are factors of the «external environment» or risk factors, that are not dependable upon the emergency medical service. Nevertheless, these risk factors largely determine the accessibility and quality of emergency care in managing the routing organization during evacuation of patients to inpatient medical organizations. The purpose of the study is to analyze the organization of routing and evacuation of patients to inpatient medical organizations in a megalopolis and evaluate the role of innovative technologies in improving operational management decisions. Material and methods. The basis of the study was the A.S. Puchkov Ambulance and Emergency Care Station, Moscow. The Station performance was analyzed according to the data of the Federal statistical observation form No. 30 «Information about a medical organization» for 2014-2023. Results. The Station is entrusted with the functions of centralized routing in the course of medical evacuation. For the period 2018-2023, the frequency of evacuations of patients to inpatient medical organizations has a multidirectional character - against the background of a decrease in the number of persons delivered by ambulance crews to hospital organizations from 1339226 in 2018 to 882334 in 2023, there is an increase in this indicator in the period 2020-2022, i.e. during the Covid-19 pandemic with a subsequent decrease in 2023. In 2024, 1582 patients with circulatory arrest during continuous resuscitation measures were delivered to specialized medical institutions with spontaneous circulation restored. As part of the centralized management of routing during medical evacuation of patients to specialized hospitals, the Station has introduced modern medical and organizational technologies based on integrated management of innovative processes, including information systems and resources to handle calls and manage ambulance crews (Integrated automated control system and Automated navigation and dispatch system management), making it possible, under the “risk” conditions, to take prompt decisions on selecting the most optimal schemes and options for routing and reducing the hospital delivery time. In order to solve multidimensional problems of patient routing and evacuation, the Station has developed and implemented the target module «patient influx control» as a subsystem in the automated management system «Hospital». Implementing the developed module, coupled with establishing a separate post of a senior doctor in the medical evacuation department, made it possible to reach a 97-98% index of patient routing. Conclusion. The feasibility and effectiveness of introducing innovative technologies into the organization of the most important stage of emergency medical care delivery in critical cases, threatening the life of the patient —routing patients to inpatient medical facilities during medical evacuation—has been proven. The development of key innovative processes at all stages of emergency medical care organization can be highlighted: information systems and resources that ensure the reception of calls and management of ambulance crews. From the position of centralized regulation of the processes of routing and evacuation of patients to specialized medical organizations, an important role is played by the development and implementation of an automated navigation and dispatch management system. Keywords: emergency medical care; patient routing; medical evacuation; innovative information technologies
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 70 (S5) , 22
THE INFLUENCE OF CLIMATIC AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC FACTORS ON THE MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY FROM TUBERCULOSIS IN RUSSIA
Significance. Identification of reliably influencing natural-climatic, socio-economic and organizational factors makes it possible to build a system of management decisions aimed at reducing morbidity and mortality from tuberculosis. However, the multiplicity and interdependence of such influencing factors does not allow the construction of simple mathematical models. It requires the use of multifactorial analysis and the construction of complex algorithms to reliably prove the degree of influence of different factors. The purpose of the study was to build a model of differentiation of natural-climatic and socio-economic factors, correction of such models in scientific research related to morbidity and mortality from tuberculosis. Materials and methods. The data of departmental medical and statistical forms (No. 8 «Information about diseases with active tuberculosis», No. 30 «Information about a medical organization», No. 33 «Information about tuberculosis patients», No. 47 «Information about a network of medical institutions»), as well as official data of ROSSTAT for 2019-2023 were studied to determine the impact of socio-economic and natural-geographical factors on the epidemiological situation of tuberculosis. More than 50 different indicators were studied. The methodological base was based on statistical, mathematical, correlation and analytical methods. Results. Correlation analysis was carried out for all studied indicators characterizing epidemiological, resource, socio-economic and natural-geographical situation of all regions of the Russian Federation and nationwide. Five key indicators characterizing the epidemiological situation in the region in terms of tuberculosis, five most influential socio-economic indicators of the regions and two natural-geographical indicators were selected by expert method, on the basis of which all regions of the Russian Federation were segmented into 16 segments and distributed into 5 clusters. Further, a correlation analysis was carried out for all pairs of epidemiological and socio-economic indicators, both for the Russian Federation as a whole and for all clusters. Dependencies characteristic of each cluster were identified. For example, if there is no average correlation between the unemployment rate and the incidence of all types of tuberculosis (correlation coefficient 0.1) in clusters with moderate climate and average population density, this indicator reaches 0.64 (cluster 4), which confirms the significant influence of the unemployment rate on the incidence of tuberculosis. Also, the incidence of all forms of tuberculosis is more influenced by the level of housing supply of the population. In the regions of cluster 3, this dependence is much stronger than in clusters 1 and 5. The correlation coefficient is -0.88, which confirms a heavily dependent. Conclusion. As a result of the study, it was found that in the Russian Federation there are no obvious dependencies for all the selected parameters. A weak negative correlation was obtained between the provision of living space to the population and indicators characterizing morbidity and mortality from tuberculosis (correlation coefficient -0.43 ... - 0.47); a weak correlation was also found between clinical cure of tuberculosis and gross regional product per one inhabitant of the region (correlation coefficient 0.43). At the same time, strong dependencies characteristic for each cluster were found in different clusters. Scope of application of the results. The results of the study can be used in the development of strategic directions and differentiated organizational measures to combat tuberculosis in the Russian Federation at the level of the subjects. Keywords: tuberculosis; tuberculosis morbidity; tuberculosis clinical cure; tuberculosis mortality; socioeconomic and natural geographic factors; spatial heterogeneity
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 70 (S5) , 22
THE INFLUENCE OF CLIMATIC AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC FACTORS ON THE MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY FROM TUBERCULOSIS IN RUSSIA
Significance. Identification of reliably influencing natural-climatic, socio-economic and organizational factors makes it possible to build a system of management decisions aimed at reducing morbidity and mortality from tuberculosis. However, the multiplicity and interdependence of such influencing factors does not allow the construction of simple mathematical models. It requires the use of multifactorial analysis and the construction of complex algorithms to reliably prove the degree of influence of different factors. The purpose of the study was to build a model of differentiation of natural-climatic and socio-economic factors, correction of such models in scientific research related to morbidity and mortality from tuberculosis. Materials and methods. The data of departmental medical and statistical forms (No. 8 «Information about diseases with active tuberculosis», No. 30 «Information about a medical organization», No. 33 «Information about tuberculosis patients», No. 47 «Information about a network of medical institutions»), as well as official data of ROSSTAT for 2019-2023 were studied to determine the impact of socio-economic and natural-geographical factors on the epidemiological situation of tuberculosis. More than 50 different indicators were studied. The methodological base was based on statistical, mathematical, correlation and analytical methods. Results. Correlation analysis was carried out for all studied indicators characterizing epidemiological, resource, socio-economic and natural-geographical situation of all regions of the Russian Federation and nationwide. Five key indicators characterizing the epidemiological situation in the region in terms of tuberculosis, five most influential socio-economic indicators of the regions and two natural-geographical indicators were selected by expert method, on the basis of which all regions of the Russian Federation were segmented into 16 segments and distributed into 5 clusters. Further, a correlation analysis was carried out for all pairs of epidemiological and socio-economic indicators, both for the Russian Federation as a whole and for all clusters. Dependencies characteristic of each cluster were identified. For example, if there is no average correlation between the unemployment rate and the incidence of all types of tuberculosis (correlation coefficient 0.1) in clusters with moderate climate and average population density, this indicator reaches 0.64 (cluster 4), which confirms the significant influence of the unemployment rate on the incidence of tuberculosis. Also, the incidence of all forms of tuberculosis is more influenced by the level of housing supply of the population. In the regions of cluster 3, this dependence is much stronger than in clusters 1 and 5. The correlation coefficient is -0.88, which confirms a heavily dependent. Conclusion. As a result of the study, it was found that in the Russian Federation there are no obvious dependencies for all the selected parameters. A weak negative correlation was obtained between the provision of living space to the population and indicators characterizing morbidity and mortality from tuberculosis (correlation coefficient -0.43 ... - 0.47); a weak correlation was also found between clinical cure of tuberculosis and gross regional product per one inhabitant of the region (correlation coefficient 0.43). At the same time, strong dependencies characteristic for each cluster were found in different clusters. Scope of application of the results. The results of the study can be used in the development of strategic directions and differentiated organizational measures to combat tuberculosis in the Russian Federation at the level of the subjects. Keywords: tuberculosis; tuberculosis morbidity; tuberculosis clinical cure; tuberculosis mortality; socioeconomic and natural geographic factors; spatial heterogeneity
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 70 (3) , 12
INCIDENCE OF SOCIALLY SIGNIFICANT INFECTIOUS DISEASES IN PRISONS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION IN 2010–2023
Significance. Analyzing incidence of socially significant infectious diseases in prisons allows us to establish their prevalence among socially vulnerable groups of the population. The contingent of the prisons suffering from infectious diseases is able to maintain the tension of the epidemic situation. The purpose of the study: to analyze dynamics in the incidence of socially significant infectious diseases in prisons, including in the context of its dynamics among socially vulnerable segments of the population. Material and methods. Forms of departmental statistical observation, as well as statistical publications were analyzed. We calculated morbidity rates per 100,000 newly arrested in pre-trial detention centers, per 100,000 average convicts in correctional facilities, and for the penitentiary system as a whole for 2010–2023. Results. The incidence of syphilis decreased in pre-trial detention centers from 1459.3 to 237.6; in correctional facilities – from 95.5 to 6.7; in the penal system – from 492.9 to 100.7. A relative risk of syphilis in the penal system compared to the civil healthcare (RRps) was on average 7.8±0.5(1.7) in 2010–2013. The incidence of gonococcal infection decreased in pre-trial detention centers from 150.7 to 17.4; in correctional facilities from 14.8 to 0.7; in the penal system from 54.4 to 7.5. RRps=1.2±0.1(0.2). The HIV incidence in pre-trial detention centers in 2010–2017 increased from 2641.5 to 4356.2, followed by a decrease to 1965.0 in 2013. The HIV incidence in correctional institutions in 2010–2012 increased from 326.9 to 520.5, followed by a decrease to 109.6 in 2013. The HIV incidence in the penal system in 2010–2015 increased from 1001.4 to 1509.4, followed by a decrease in 2023 to 865.2. RRps=24.0±0.7(2.6). The incidence of viral hepatitis B and C changed in different directions. For viral hepatitis B, the median RRps was 4.6, for viral hepatitis C, RRps=8.7±0.7(2.5). The incidence of tuberculosis decreased in pre-trial detention centers from 1594.4 to 871.8; in correctional facilities from 1211.8 to 310.5; in the penal system from 1323.3 to 539.1. RRuis=18.7±0.4(1.3). Conclusion. A relative risk of identifying socially significant infectious diseases in prisons is the highest for HIV and tuberculosis, and much lower for syphilis, viral hepatitis B and C, and gonococcal infection. There is an improvement in the epidemiological situation regarding socially significant infections (except for hepatitis) among socially vulnerable groups of the population. Scope of application. The study results can be used by health executives.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 70 (3) , 12
INCIDENCE OF SOCIALLY SIGNIFICANT INFECTIOUS DISEASES IN PRISONS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION IN 2010–2023
Significance. Analyzing incidence of socially significant infectious diseases in prisons allows us to establish their prevalence among socially vulnerable groups of the population. The contingent of the prisons suffering from infectious diseases is able to maintain the tension of the epidemic situation. The purpose of the study: to analyze dynamics in the incidence of socially significant infectious diseases in prisons, including in the context of its dynamics among socially vulnerable segments of the population. Material and methods. Forms of departmental statistical observation, as well as statistical publications were analyzed. We calculated morbidity rates per 100,000 newly arrested in pre-trial detention centers, per 100,000 average convicts in correctional facilities, and for the penitentiary system as a whole for 2010–2023. Results. The incidence of syphilis decreased in pre-trial detention centers from 1459.3 to 237.6; in correctional facilities – from 95.5 to 6.7; in the penal system – from 492.9 to 100.7. A relative risk of syphilis in the penal system compared to the civil healthcare (RRps) was on average 7.8±0.5(1.7) in 2010–2013. The incidence of gonococcal infection decreased in pre-trial detention centers from 150.7 to 17.4; in correctional facilities from 14.8 to 0.7; in the penal system from 54.4 to 7.5. RRps=1.2±0.1(0.2). The HIV incidence in pre-trial detention centers in 2010–2017 increased from 2641.5 to 4356.2, followed by a decrease to 1965.0 in 2013. The HIV incidence in correctional institutions in 2010–2012 increased from 326.9 to 520.5, followed by a decrease to 109.6 in 2013. The HIV incidence in the penal system in 2010–2015 increased from 1001.4 to 1509.4, followed by a decrease in 2023 to 865.2. RRps=24.0±0.7(2.6). The incidence of viral hepatitis B and C changed in different directions. For viral hepatitis B, the median RRps was 4.6, for viral hepatitis C, RRps=8.7±0.7(2.5). The incidence of tuberculosis decreased in pre-trial detention centers from 1594.4 to 871.8; in correctional facilities from 1211.8 to 310.5; in the penal system from 1323.3 to 539.1. RRuis=18.7±0.4(1.3). Conclusion. A relative risk of identifying socially significant infectious diseases in prisons is the highest for HIV and tuberculosis, and much lower for syphilis, viral hepatitis B and C, and gonococcal infection. There is an improvement in the epidemiological situation regarding socially significant infections (except for hepatitis) among socially vulnerable groups of the population. Scope of application. The study results can be used by health executives.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 69 (2) , 10
MONITORING AND EVALUATION OF MICROBIOLOGICAL DIAGNOSTICS OF TUBERCULOSIS: RESOURCES AND PERFORMANCE OF MICROBIOLOGICAL LABORATORIES
Significance. The system of microbiological diagnostics is of key importance for organizing microbiological diagnostics in accordance with the modern recommendations, and fulfilling political commitments of the Russian Federation within the framework of the End TB Strategy Purpose: to assess the availability, use and results of the modern methods of microbiological diagnostics of tuberculosis in Russia in 2021. Material and methods. The study has analyzed forms #7-TB, ВР-4БЛ, ВР-1Ф of official statistical observation, results of external quality assessment of laboratories (Interlaboratory comparison system “Federal System of External Quality Assessment of Clinical Laboratory Testing (FSEQA)”). Results. The share of patients with pulmonary tuberculosis with a smear positive Ziehl-Nelsen, detected in medical organizations providing primary health care (PHC) decreased to 12.8%, while the share of new smear positive pulmonary TB patients increased to 37.4%; the share of newly diagnosed patients with pulmonary tuberculosis with a positive result of sputum bacterioscopy among patients with cavities increased to 60.6%.The share of laboratories with satisfactory results of the FSEQA participation regarding smear microscopy increased to 92.8%; the share of laboratories with the confirmed quality increased to 14.3%. The culture coverage of new pulmonary TB patients equaled to 98.0%. Culture-based confirmation of the diagnosis was obtained in 55.3% of the patients; the share of smear positive new pulmonary TB patients with the negative culture result decreased to 3.8%. The share of laboratories participating in FSEQA increased to 44.5%; the share of laboratories that showed satisfactory results - up to 90.8%, the share of laboratories with the confirmed quality - up to 40.4%. The coverage with molecular genetic testing added up to 90.8%. The drug susceptibility testing (DST) coverage equaled to 97.7%. The patient coverage with rifampicin resistance DST to fluoroquinolones reached 93.2%; coverage with pre-XDR-TB DST to linezolid - 35.0%, bedaquiline - 12.4%. Conclusion. Microbiological diagnostics of tuberculosis in PHC by smear microscopy is ineffective in modern conditions; there are prospects for its use in new Russian regions. The COVID-19 pandemic failed to produce any significant negative impact on the patient coverage with microbiological examination methods. In 2020–2021, the quality of bacterioscopic and culture testing for tuberculosis increased. DST coverage for bedaquiline and linezolid is poor; this does not allow to meet the current clinical guideline requirements. The cost of consumables per patient increased 3.1 times between 2015 and 2021.In the structure of financial expenses on TB microbiological diagnostics, consumables that require import substitution prevail. Scope of application. The study results can be used by heads of health authorities, chief physicians of TB facilities, heads of microbiological laboratories in order to increase effectiveness of TB care, timely detection of people excreting bacteria and MBT drug susceptibility testing.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics in Social Aspects of Population Health
- Vol. 69 (2) , 10
MONITORING AND EVALUATION OF MICROBIOLOGICAL DIAGNOSTICS OF TUBERCULOSIS: RESOURCES AND PERFORMANCE OF MICROBIOLOGICAL LABORATORIES
Significance. The system of microbiological diagnostics is of key importance for organizing microbiological diagnostics in accordance with the modern recommendations, and fulfilling political commitments of the Russian Federation within the framework of the End TB Strategy Purpose: to assess the availability, use and results of the modern methods of microbiological diagnostics of tuberculosis in Russia in 2021. Material and methods. The study has analyzed forms #7-TB, ВР-4БЛ, ВР-1Ф of official statistical observation, results of external quality assessment of laboratories (Interlaboratory comparison system “Federal System of External Quality Assessment of Clinical Laboratory Testing (FSEQA)”). Results. The share of patients with pulmonary tuberculosis with a smear positive Ziehl-Nelsen, detected in medical organizations providing primary health care (PHC) decreased to 12.8%, while the share of new smear positive pulmonary TB patients increased to 37.4%; the share of newly diagnosed patients with pulmonary tuberculosis with a positive result of sputum bacterioscopy among patients with cavities increased to 60.6%.The share of laboratories with satisfactory results of the FSEQA participation regarding smear microscopy increased to 92.8%; the share of laboratories with the confirmed quality increased to 14.3%. The culture coverage of new pulmonary TB patients equaled to 98.0%. Culture-based confirmation of the diagnosis was obtained in 55.3% of the patients; the share of smear positive new pulmonary TB patients with the negative culture result decreased to 3.8%. The share of laboratories participating in FSEQA increased to 44.5%; the share of laboratories that showed satisfactory results - up to 90.8%, the share of laboratories with the confirmed quality - up to 40.4%. The coverage with molecular genetic testing added up to 90.8%. The drug susceptibility testing (DST) coverage equaled to 97.7%. The patient coverage with rifampicin resistance DST to fluoroquinolones reached 93.2%; coverage with pre-XDR-TB DST to linezolid - 35.0%, bedaquiline - 12.4%. Conclusion. Microbiological diagnostics of tuberculosis in PHC by smear microscopy is ineffective in modern conditions; there are prospects for its use in new Russian regions. The COVID-19 pandemic failed to produce any significant negative impact on the patient coverage with microbiological examination methods. In 2020–2021, the quality of bacterioscopic and culture testing for tuberculosis increased. DST coverage for bedaquiline and linezolid is poor; this does not allow to meet the current clinical guideline requirements. The cost of consumables per patient increased 3.1 times between 2015 and 2021.In the structure of financial expenses on TB microbiological diagnostics, consumables that require import substitution prevail. Scope of application. The study results can be used by heads of health authorities, chief physicians of TB facilities, heads of microbiological laboratories in order to increase effectiveness of TB care, timely detection of people excreting bacteria and MBT drug susceptibility testing.