APAida Torres Pérez

Aida Torres Pérez

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Aida Torres Pérez has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • The constitutional impact of rule-of-law spending conditionality

    by Aida Torres Pérez

    The negotiation of an unprecedented recovery package to address the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic provided momentum for a new instrument to condition the disbursement of EU funds to compliance with the rule-of-law principles. Regulation 2020/2092 (“the Conditionality Regulation”) was aimed at protecting the financial interests of the European Union and the sound management of EU funds against breaches of the rule of law. The aim of this article is to assess the validity, effectiveness, and broader impact of rule-of-law conditionality upon the EU constitutional architecture. The effectiveness in practice of the Conditionality Regulation is evaluated, together with the role of other conditionality mechanisms that have been used to promote rule-of-law standards, mainly the Recovery and Resilience Facility, which is the centerpiece of the NextGenerationEU package, and the Common Provisions Regulation, which includes a horizontal enabling condition that makes EU funds contingent upon the effective implementation and application of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. The suitability of rule-of-law conditionality as a form of governance with the current EU constitutional architecture is critically examined. Conditioning funding to promote values raises concerns from a constitutional perspective that include the risk of competence creep, repercussions for citizenship, and, finally, the undermining of trust and solidarity in interactions among member states. The Conditionality Regulation represents a relevant addition to the toolbox of instruments devised to address rule-of-law backsliding in the European Union, yet the expansion of rule-of-law conditionality could also be consequential for the ethos of the European Union.


  • From the economic to the pandemic crisis: The impact upon the EU constitutional architecture—Introduction to the Symposium

    by Aida Torres Pérez, Joan Solanes Mullor

    The European Union has evolved significantly, shaped by crises as foreseen by Jean Monnet, who predicted that Europe would be “forged in crises.” Over recent decades, it has faced challenges such as the euro crisis, the COVID-19 pandemic, Brexit, rule-of-law backsliding, and ongoing geopolitical conflicts. These crises have tested and transformed the European Union’s constitutional framework, prompting institutional reforms and innovations in governance without necessarily revising the Treaties. This Symposium explores the European Union’s constitutional evolution through the lens of crises. Key reforms include the reinforcement of budgetary discipline during the euro crisis and the shift toward a stimulus-based approach in response to the pandemic, culminating in the NextGenerationEU framework. Contributors analyze the model of economic governance that has evolved from the convergence of both the economic and pandemic crises, the changing role of regions, the judiciary’s evolving oversight functions and its limits, and rule of law conditionality as a distinctive form of governance. The Symposium will delve into the post-crisis governance landscape of the European Union from a constitutional perspective, focusing on the structural adjustments implemented and their enduring impact. Despite these changes, the European Union has demonstrated resilience and adaptability, forging new governance structures that reflect its deepening constitutional identity. In the end, the Symposium provides a comprehensive examination of these shifts, highlighting how the European Union continues to integrate and innovate in response to ongoing challenges.

  • Introduction to Social Rights and the European Monetary Union

    by Maribel González Pascual, Aida Torres Pérez

    The need to advance a social Europe in the frame of the EMU was implicitly recognised by the EU even before the COVID-19. Still, the pandemic brought new challenges, putting into question some of the basic tenets of the European Economic Governance. In this context, "Social Rights in the European Monetary Union: Challenges Ahead" will contribute to the current debate focusing on the existing mechanisms of social rights protection in the EU. With this goal in mind, the first part of the book critically analyses the development building blocks of the social Europe. The second part examines the main challenges posed by the EMU, with reference also to the novelties brought by the pandemic. Third, the book strives to show the role that courts might play as watchdogs of social rights in Europe. In the end, "Social rights in the European Monetary Union: Challenges Ahead" provides a thorough analysis of the challenges and prospects for social rights' protection in the EMU beyond the economic and the pandemic crisis.

  • Adjudication of socioeconomic rights by the CJEU: towards a new form of judicial review?

    by Aida Torres Pérez

    The goal of this chapter is to examine the role of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in reviewing measures enacted in the context of the euro crisis against the backdrop of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. The overall research question is whether the CJEU's enforcement of socioeconomic rights might be legitimately strengthened, and if so how. First, I will address the main challenges to judicial review. The exceptionality of the economic crisis, the heterogeneous array of sources of Euro-crisis law, and the contested justiciability of socioeconomic rights have hindered a robust review by the CJEU. I will argue that the CJEU has moved from total deference to a weak form of review. Next, the analysis will follow a normative track. If we agree that there are theoretical and practical reasons against a strong from of judicial review for the adjudication of socioeconomic rights, then what model of judicial review best fulfills the EU's primordial commitment to the rule of law? I will consider relative advantages of procedural versus dialogic approaches to judicial review in the field of socioeconomic rights. In the end, I will argue that a dialogic approach better acknowledges the limits on the courts' authority to adopt a pure, strong-form approach to the judicial enforcement of socioeconomic rights, but also gives them more capacity and responsibility to counter political or structural factors that hinder the realization of socioeconomic rights than the procedural model does.

  • From Portugal to Poland: The Court of Justice of the European Union as watchdog of judicial independence

    by Aida Torres Pérez

    In Associação Sindical dos Juízes Portugueses, the CJEU seized the occasion to uphold the principle of judicial independence as a primary obligation for the Member States under the second subparagraph of Article 19(1) TEU. This newly crafted interpretation of Article 19(1) has crystallized in Commission v. Poland, in which the CJEU declared that the reform of the Polish law on the Supreme Court lowering the retirement age of judges breached the obligation to respect judicial independence. The goal of this piece is to assess the bold interpretation given to the second subparagraph of Article 19(1) as a building block of the EU’s constitutional order. First, the expansion of the substantive content of Article 19(1) TEU will be analysed. How did the CJEU justify the shift from an obligation to establish a system of remedies ensuring effective judicial review to an obligation of respect for judicial independence? Second, the scope of this obligation and its potential reach will be critically examined. I will argue that Article 19(1) TEU may actually trigger the application of the Charter. Eventually, Article 19(1) TEU has the potential to become an open door for enforcing the Charter against the States regardless of its limited scope of application.


  • Open Access

    The Constitution of Spain: The Challenges for the Constitutional Order Under European and Global Governance

    by Joan Solanes Mullor, Aida Torres Pérez

    Although the constitutional text has remained nearly untouched – only twice has the Spanish Constitution been amended since its enactment in 1978 – global and European governance have deeply transformed the constitutional order. The impact of the process of European integration upon the Constitution is an open and evolving phenomenon, encompassing the challenge to constitutional supremacy, the incorporation of new sources of law, an imbalance between the legislative and executive powers, the enhanced role of the judiciary, the multilevel protection of fundamental rights and the transformation of regionalism as a model for organising the territorial power. First, this report will analyse the constitutional amendments regarding EU membership and the constitutional limits to European integration. Indeed, the only two constitutional amendments were both prompted by the EU. Secondly, the impact of EU integration upon the protection of constitutional rights will be critically examined, with special emphasis on the economic crisis. The obligations deriving from the EU might undermine the protection of constitutional rights, as the introduction of the European Arrest Warrant, the Data Retention Directive and the austerity measures adopted in the context of the economic crisis have shown. Thirdly and more generally, global governance has had constitutional implications, for instance regarding the strengthening of the executive power vis-à-vis the legislative, pressures on the welfare state, the fight against terrorism, the curtailing of powers of the Autonomous Communities and the response to immigration. In this context, it is necessary to recast the relationship between the Global-European spheres and the national constitutional order to ensure respect for the principles of the rule of law, the separation of powers and the protection of fundamental rights.


  • On judicial mobilization: entrepreneuring for policy change at times of crisis

    by Juan A. Mayoral, Aida Torres Pérez

    National courts all over Europe have faced the challenge of how to protect rights in times of crisis. In the context of the Spanish housing crisis, judges adopted an activist role by mobilizing the Court of Justice of the EU in multiple cases to challenge national legislation. This forced the Spanish government to adopt reforms to strengthen the position of mortgage debtors to fulfil the obligations under EU consumer law. This article discerns the factors that lead Spanish judges to cooperate with the CJEU. We show that, although political and legal opportunities and resources play a role for the judicial mobilization of EU law, the degree to which they matter vary when we consider: the role of ‘judicial entrepreneurs’ who introduce EU law as a novel legal strategy, and the impact of this tactic on how judicial actors frame EU law, with important consequences for the politics within the judiciary.


  • The federalizing force of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights

    by Aida Torres Pérez

    In the EU, fundamental rights are inextricably intertwined with the federal structure of such a uniquely divided power composite. This article examines the structure of fundamental rights’ protection and the continuous bargaining over the allocation of judicial tasks between domestic and EU courts regarding the interpretation and enforcement of fundamental rights. First, I will analyze the latest Court of Justice case law to show how, since the Charter of Fundamental Rights entered into force, it has had a centralizing effect. Next, I will reflect upon how the “nationalist school of federalism” developed in the US literature might provide valuable insights for an argument grounding supranational authority while acknowledging the contribution of state constitutions and state courts to the supranational system of rights’ protection. In the end, it will be argued that the growing self-empowerment of the Court of Justice in the field of fundamental rights needs to be tempered by an understanding of how state courts and rights could actually promote supranational ends in this context.


  • From judicial independence to interdependence in the international sphere

    by Aida Torres Pérez

    The goal of this article is to develop an analytical framework for the conceptualization of international judicial independence. First, it will be argued that judicial independence is not to be conceived as an end in itself but rather as a condition for the legitimacy of international courts (ICs). Also, independence is not a monolithic concept, but one of degree and the optimal degree of independence might vary according to the function and type of ICs. Second, I will provide a taxonomy of judicial independence in the international sphere and identify and systematize the relevant actors and variables. While studies about international judicial independence tend to focus on the mechanisms available to state governments, this work will take into account a broader set of actors and variables. Finally, a notion of interdependence will be advanced as a framework for institutional design that combines the need to enable adjudication free from undue influence or pressure with mechanisms to counterbalance judicial power. Forms of interdependence on the grounds of the principles of accountability and checks and balances might contribute to the overall legitimacy of ICs.