The Effects of Employer and Client Identification on Internal and External Auditors' Evaluations of Internal Control Deficiencies
Authors:
- Chad M. StefaniakCSChad M. Stefaniak
- Richard W. HoustonRHRichard W. Houston
- Robert M. CornellRCRobert M. Cornell
- 1 January 2012
- journal article
- Published by American Accounting Association in AUDITING: A Journal of Practice & Theory
- Vol. 31 (1) , 39-56
Abstract
SUMMARY: The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board's (PCAOB) Auditing Standard No. 5 (AS5) encourages external auditors to rely on internal auditors to increase the efficiency of lower-risk internal control evaluations (PCAOB 2007). We use post-SOX experimental data to compare the levels and effects of employer (client) identification on the control evaluations of internal (external) auditors. First, we find that internal auditors perceive a greater level of identification with the evaluated firm than do external auditors. We also find some evidence that, ceteris paribus, internal auditors are less lenient than external auditors when evaluating internal control deficiencies (i.e., tend to support management's preferred position to a lesser extent). Further, while we support Bamber and Iyer's (2007) results by finding that higher levels of external auditor client identification are associated with more lenient control evaluations, we demonstrate an opposite effect for internal auditors—higher levels of internal auditor employer identification are associated with less lenient control evaluations. Our results are important because we are the first to capture the relative levels of identification between internal and external auditors, as well as the first to compare directly internal and external auditor leniency, both of which are important in light of AS5. That is, we provide initial evidence that external auditors' increased reliance on internal auditors' work, while increasing audit efficiency, also could improve audit quality by resulting in less lenient internal control evaluations, due, at least in part, to the effects of employer and client identification. Data Availability: Contact the first author.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- Internal Audit Sourcing Arrangement and the External Auditor's Reliance Decision*Contemporary Accounting Research, 2008
- Changes in Internal Auditing During the Time of the Major US Accounting ScandalsInternational Journal of Auditing, 2005
- COGNITIVE AND AFFECTIVE IDENTIFICATION IN ORGANIZATIONAL SETTINGS.Academy of Management Proceedings, 2005
- Managing internal auditing in a post-SOA worldJournal of Corporate Accounting & Finance, 2004
- The Contribution of Internal Audit as a Determinant of External Audit Fees and Factors Influencing This ContributionJournal of Accounting Research, 2001
- Auditors' Perceived Business Risk and Audit Fees: Analysis and EvidenceJournal of Accounting Research, 2001
- The Impact of Internal Auditor Compensation and Role on External Auditors' Planning Judgments and Decisions*Contemporary Accounting Research, 2001
- Internal auditors and a value‐added approach: the new business regimeManagerial Auditing Journal, 2000
- Identification of accounting firm alumni with their former firm: Antecedents and outcomesAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1997
- An examination of management's ability to bias the professional objectivity of internal auditorsAccounting, Organizations and Society, 1989