Open Archaeology, Open Source? Collaborative practices in an emerging community of archaeological software engineers
Authors:
- University of TorontoUTUniversity of Toronto
- Zachary BatistZBZachary Batist
- Joe RoeJRJoe Roe
- University of BernUBUniversity of Bern
Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Council for British Archaeology in Internet Archaeology
- No. 67
Abstract
In this article, we investigate modes of collaboration in this emerging community of practice using 'open-archaeo ', a curated list of archaeological software, and data on the activity of associated GitHub repositories and users. We conduct an exploratory quantitative analysis to characterise the nature and intensity of these collaborations and map the collaborative networks that emerge from them. We document uneven adoption of open source collaborative practices beyond the basic use of git as a version control system and GitHub to host source code. Most projects do make use of collaborative features and, through shared contributions, we can trace a collaborative network that includes the majority of archaeologists active on GitHub. However, a majority of repositories have 1-3 contributors, with only a few projects distinguished by an active and diverse developer base. Direct collaboration on code or other repository content - as opposed to the more passive, social media-style interaction that GitHub supports – remains very limited. In other words, there is little evidence that archaeologists ' adoption of open-source tools (git and GitHub) has been accompanied by the decentralised, participatory forms of collaboration that characterise other open-source communities. On the contrary, our results indicate that research software engineering in archaeology remains largely embedded in conventional professional norms and organisational structures of academia.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- It’s Not Just GitHub: Identifying Data and Software Sources Included in Publications2023
- Philosophy of Open Science2023
- The Rise of GitHub in Scholarly Publications2022
- To what extent is researchers' data-sharing motivated by formal mechanisms of recognition and credit?Scientometrics, 2021
- Evaluating the popularity of R in ecologyEcosphere, 2019
- Sociotechnical Obstacles to Archaeological Data ReuseAdvances in Archaeological Practice, 2018
- Other People’s Data: A Demonstration of the Imperative of Publishing Primary DataJournal of Archaeological Method and Theory, 2012
- A bit more to it: Scholarly Communication Forums as Socio‐Technical Interaction NetworksJournal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2002
- The cathedral and the bazaarKnowledge and Policy, 1999
- The computer in archaeology: A critical surveyComputers and the Humanities, 1972