International Relations Theory and the Case against Unilateralism
- 26 August 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Perspectives on Politics
- Vol. 3 (3) , 509-524
Abstract
What are the general costs associated with a U.S. shift toward unilateralism? According to the overwhelming majority of international relations (IR) scholars, the costs are very high. We evaluate the key arguments that underlie this assessment, namely that increased U.S. unilateralism will: (1) spur the formation of a coalition to check U.S. power; (2) reduce efficiency gains through lost opportunities for institutionalized cooperation; and (3) undermine the legitimacy of the American-led international order. We conclude that the theoretical arguments that IR scholars advance do not show that a shift toward unilateralism necessarily has high costs. Our analysis reveals the need to, first, distinguish clearly between criticisms of unilateral policies based on procedure and those based on substance and, second, to recognize the weakness of current procedural arguments.Keywords
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hard Times for Soft BalancingInternational Security, 2005
- Preemptive Self‐defense: Hegemony, Equality and Strategies of Legal Change*Journal of Political Philosophy, 2003
- An Unnecessary WarForeign Policy, 2003
- American Primacy in PerspectiveForeign Affairs, 2002
- Outside Options and the Logic of Security Council ActionAmerican Political Science Review, 2001
- The state that acts alone: bully, good samaritan or iconoclast?European Journal of International Law, 2000
- The Stability of a Unipolar WorldInternational Security, 1999
- The Promise of Constructivism in International Relations TheoryInternational Security, 1998
- The Promise of Institutionalist TheoryInternational Security, 1995
- Modeling the forms of international cooperation: distribution versus informationInternational Organization, 1994