Abstract
The outcomes for living kidney donors, shown in the study by Ibrahim et al. (Jan. 29 issue),1 are reassuring. Key strengths of the study are the large sample and the long follow-up. However, limitations include a highly selected and ethnically homogeneous population and the lack of acknowledgment that living donors today have an increasing number of health risk factors such as obesity. Also missing are considerations of the effect of unique regional practices and rates of end-stage renal disease (ESRD), socioeconomic influences, access to health care, educational level, and lifestyle choices. We would argue that the good survival and lower overall rate of ESRD as compared with the rates in the general population may have been due to the optimal condition of the donors at the time of their donation. The rate of ESRD should have been reported according to geographic area, since the rate varies substantially across the country. Furthermore, the ideal control group is not the general population but a group of people living in the same area who have been evaluated as candidates for donation but who did not donate. Even with the excellent research design, this study cannot be taken as the final word. Potential donors of nonwhite background need to be very carefully screened and counseled.2,3

This publication has 5 references indexed in Scilit: