Cost-effectiveness analysis of weekday and weeknight or weekend shifts for assessment of appendicitis
- 15 September 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Pediatric Radiology
- Vol. 35 (12) , 1186-1195
Abstract
Background: Assessment of appendicitis during a weeknight or weekend shift (after-hours period, AHP) might be more costly and less effective than its assessment on a weekday shift (standard hours period, SHP) because of increased costs (staff premium fees) and perforation risk (longer delays and less experience of fellows). Objectives: The objectives were to compare the costs and effectiveness of assessing children with suspected appendicitis who required a laparotomy and had US or CT after-hours with those of assessing children during standard hours, and to evaluate the importance of diagnostic imaging (DI) within the overall costs. Materials and methods: We retrospectively microcosted resource use within six areas of a tertiary hospital (emergency [ED], diagnostic imaging (DI), surgery, wards, transport, and pathology) in a tertiary hospital. About 41 children (1.8–17 years) in the AHP and 35 (2.9–16 years) in the SHP were evaluated. Work shift effectiveness was measured with a histological score that assessed the severity of appendicitis (non-perforated appendicitis: scores 1–3; perforated appendicitis: score 4). Results: The SHP was less costly and more effective regardless of whether the calculation included US or CT costs only. For a salary-based fee schedule, US$733 were saved per case of perforated appendicitis averted in the SHP. For a fee-for-service payment schedule, $847 were saved. Within the overall budget, the highest costs were those incurred on the ward for both shifts. The average cost per patient in DI ranged from 2 to 5% of the total costs in both shifts. Most perforation cases were found in the AHP (31.7%, AHP vs. 17.1%, SHP), which resulted in higher ward costs for patients in the AHP. Conclusion: A higher proportion of severe cases was seen in the AHP, which led to its higher costs. As a result, the SHP dominated the AHP, being less costly and more effective regardless of the fee schedule applied. The DI costs contributed little to the overall cost of the assessment of appendicitis.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Living Renal Donors: Optimizing the Imaging Strategy—Decision- and Cost-effectiveness AnalysisRadiology, 2003
- Day of the Week of Intensive Care Admission and Patient OutcomesMedical Care, 2002
- Mortality among Patients Admitted to Hospitals on Weekends as Compared with WeekdaysNew England Journal of Medicine, 2001
- Introduction of Appendiceal CTAnnals of Surgery, 1999
- HAVE THE EVALUATION AND TREATMENT OF ACUTE APPENDICITIS CHANGED WITH NEW TECHNOLOGY?Surgical Clinics of North America, 1997
- Appendicitis in children in the managed care eraJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 1996
- Clinical validity of ultrasound in children with suspected appendicitisAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 1993
- Contemporary management of the appendiceal massBritish Journal of Surgery, 1993
- THE WEEKEND—A DANGEROUS TIME TO BE BORN?BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 1981
- Neonatal Mortality by the Day of the Week in the 1974-75 Arkansas Live Birth CohortAmerican Journal of Public Health, 1981