Optimal cutoff estimation and evaluation of direct and indirect diagnostic methods for assessing bovine colostrum quality with Bayesian finite mixture models
Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 109 (1) , 636-646
Abstract
Ensuring high-quality colostrum for newborn calves is essential for their health and future productivity. We applied Bayesian finite mixture models to estimate optimal cutoff values and evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of 3 methods-radial immunodiffusion (RID) assay, transmission infrared (TIR) spectroscopy, and digital Brix (dBrix) refractometry-measured on a continuous scale for assessing bovine colostrum quality, using 591 colostrum samples from 42 Holstein dairy herds in Atlantic Canada. The mean and standard deviation of IgG concentrations for high-quality colostrum were 61.07 ± 39.8 g/L, 51.28 ± 27.38 g/L, and 24.32 ± 4.13% Brix for RID assay, TIR spectroscopy, and dBrix refractometry, respectively, compared with 19.93 ± 15.54 g/L, 7.78 ± 37.4 g/L, and 15.87 ± 3.45% Brix for low-quality samples. The prevalence of high-quality colostrum was estimated at 83% (95% credible interval [CrI]: 0.79-0.88). The dBrix refractometer demonstrated the highest discriminatory power, with an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.94 (95% CrI: 0.91-0.97), followed by RID assay (AUC: 0.92; 95% CrI: 0.88-0.96) and TIR spectroscopy (AUC: 0.82; 95% CrI: 0.76-0.88). Optimal cutoff values were determined using Youden's index: 34.15 g/L for RID assay (sensitivity [Se] = 0.86, specificity [Sp] = 0.83), 22.74 g/L for TIR spectroscopy (Se = 0.88, Sp = 0.66), and 19.62% Brix for dBrix refractometry (Se = 0.90, Sp = 0.85). Correlation between RID assay and TIR spectroscopy was stronger for high-quality colostrum samples (0.80; 95% CrI: 0.77-0.84) than for low-quality samples (0.36; 95% CrI: 0.16-0.55), indicating that these methods are not perfectly correlated and justifying the need for multiple diagnostic approaches. Among individual methods, dBrix refractometry showed the highest positive predictive value (PPV = 1.00), and all methods demonstrated moderate negative predictive values (NPV = 0.46-0.57). Combining methods in series interpretation increased PPV up to 1.00 when all 3 methods were used together, though with reduced NPV. Conversely, parallel interpretation substantially improved NPV, reaching 0.98 when all 3 methods were combined. By modeling continuous measurements instead of dichotomized test results, our analysis produced refined cutoff values for assessing colostrum quality. The findings indicate that existing thresholds remain largely adequate, offering only minor performance improvements, and emphasize the need to balance diagnostic refinements with their potential effects on calf management and passive immunity. Furthermore, our findings suggest that, although individual assessment methods offer valuable diagnostic information, combining multiple methods can optimize either Se or Sp, depending on the interpretation approach, thereby further enhancing the accuracy of colostrum quality evaluation.Keywords
Funding Information
- City University of Hong Kong (9610583)
- Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency
- Zoetis
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Estimation of diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of abattoir registrations and bulk tank milk ELISA as herd-level tests for Fasciola hepatica using Bayesian latent class modellingPreventive Veterinary Medicine, 2024
- Determination of an optimal ELISA cut-off for the diagnosis of Toxoplasma gondii infection in pigs using Bayesian latent class modelling of data from multiple diagnostic testsPreventive Veterinary Medicine, 2022
- Keeping continuous diagnostic data continuous: Application of Bayesian latent class models in veterinary researchPreventive Veterinary Medicine, 2022
- Colostrum Management for Dairy CalvesVeterinary Clinics of North America: Food Animal Practice, 2019
- Gold standards are out and Bayes is in: Implementing the cure for imperfect reference tests in diagnostic accuracy studiesPreventive Veterinary Medicine, 2019
- STARD-BLCM: Standards for the Reporting of Diagnostic accuracy studies that use Bayesian Latent Class ModelsPreventive Veterinary Medicine, 2017
- A novel method for the quantification of bovine colostral immunoglobulin G using infrared spectroscopyInternational Dairy Journal, 2016
- Factors associated with morbidity, mortality, and growth of dairy heifer calves up to 3 months of agePreventive Veterinary Medicine, 2014
- Colostrum Management for Dairy CalvesVeterinary Clinics of North America: Food Animal Practice, 2008
- Transmission of antibodies from mother to young: Evolutionary strategies in a proteolytic environmentVeterinary Immunology and Immunopathology, 2007