Causal Reasoning in Argumentative Contexts in the Classroom
Open Access
- 29 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by Universidad Pedagogica Nacional in Revista Colombiana de Educación
- No. 100,p. e22333
Abstract
The current education system in Colombia demands the development of scientific reasoning as a foundation for teaching and learning processes in the classroom. However, research has shown that students face difficulties with inferential processing and critical comprehension, which limits their ability to analyze and synthesize information and to solve complex problems. This study aims to describe the development of causal reasoning in secondary school students within a learning context based on argumentation around socio-scientific issues, highlighting the need to explore how this type of reasoning emerges and how it can be strengthened. A qualitative approach was adopted, privileging a dialogic-discursive analysis of argumentative productions from 150 cases selected through purposive sampling, identifying patterns and levels of causal relationships. The results reveal that causal relationships in students’ argumentative productions are predominantly multicausal, and that the structure of causal argumentation becomes progressively more complex as the number of statements included in viewpoints increases, as well as the types of causal relationships established between justifications and viewpoints, and among different argumentative lines. These findings suggest the need to engage students in activities that explicitly promote inferential processes and more complex ways of structuring reasoning. Consequently, the study proposes implementing strategies based on the mediation of argumentative reasoning as a tool for the development of causal reasoning, thereby fostering actions oriented towards strengthening it.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- An analysis of the forms of teacher-student dialogue that are most productive for learningLanguage and Education, 2021
- Choose Your EvidenceScience & Education, 2021
- An Empirically Grounded Framework That Evaluates Argument Quality in Scientific and Social ContextsInternational Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 2020
- Enhancing evidence-based argumentation in a Mainland China middle schoolContemporary Educational Psychology, 2019
- Argumentation for Learning: Well-Trodden Paths and Unexplored TerritoriesEducational Psychologist, 2016
- A classification system for argumentation schemesArgument & Computation, 2015
- The Relationship of Science Knowledge, Attitude and Decision Making on Socio-scientific Issues: The Case Study of Students’ Debates on a Nuclear Power Plant in KoreaScience & Education, 2013
- Dimensions of Causal Understanding: the Role of Complex Causal Models in Students' Understanding of ScienceStudies in Science Education, 2005
- : From inference to reasoning: The construction of rationalityThinking & Reasoning, 2004
- Causal theories1991