Just Words
Author:
Top Cited Papers
- 14 February 2019
- book
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
Abstract
We all know that speech is harmful but we need to be as clear as possible about what the harms are and how the speech in question brings about those harms. Clarity on these two points is important for jurisprudential reasons. It is also important for social, political, and moral reasons. Just Words identifies a previously overlooked mechanism by which speech constitutes, rather than merely causes, harm. Speech constitutes harm when it enacts a norm that prescribes that harm (so that following the norm brings about the harm). Just Words argues that there is a ubiquitous but hidden way that speech enacts norms thereby highlighting important but previously overlooked constitutive connections between speech and harm. The investigation begins in the kinematics of conversation where it is argued that conversational contributions (surreptitiously but routinely) enact highly localized norms for the very conversation to which they contribute. It is then argued that the phenomenon generalizes to extra-conversational social practices. Just Words explores many categories of speech including sexist remarks, racist hate speech, pornography, verbal triggers for stereotype threat, micro-aggressions, political dog whistles, SLAM poetry, and even the hanging of posters. It also explores a variety of harms including oppression, subordination, discrimination, domination, harassment, and marginalization. In addition to exploring how speech enacts such harms, Just Words also explores ways to remedy those harms.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Genocidal Language Games12012
- On ‘Whites Only’ Signs and Racist Hate Speech: Verbal Acts of Racial Discrimination12012
- Subordinating Speech12012
- Beyond Belief: Pragmatics in Hate Speech and Pornography12012
- Introduction and Overview2012
- Ideology, Generics, and Common Ground2010
- Assertion1999
- Scorekeeping in a Language Game1983
- Indirect speech acts1979
- A taxonomy of illocutionary acts1979