Patient Priorities for Transparency in AI-Enabled Care: A Multi-Panel Study (Preprint)
Authors:
- Matthew ElmoreMEMatthew Elmore
- Jessica SperlingJSJessica Sperling
- Raquel RuizRRRaquel Ruiz
- Adrian BrownABAdrian Brown
- Michelle LangloisMLMichelle Langlois
- Congwen ZhaoCZCongwen Zhao
- Kanecia ZimmermanKZKanecia Zimmerman
- Michelle WhiteMWMichelle White
- Kenisha BetheaKBKenisha Bethea
- Cecelia PlezCPCecelia Plez
- Rabail BaigRBRabail Baig
- Christina SmithCSChristina Smith
Preprint
- 30 October 2026
- preprint
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Abstract
BACKGROUND Transparency is widely recognized as an important principle for the use of AI in healthcare. However, patient-facing transparency requires decisions about what information should be communicated, and little is known about how patients prioritize different types of information when asked to distinguish what matters most. OBJECTIVE To examine how patients prioritize transparency elements derived from a health system AI governance process, and to identify which types of information are most important for patient-facing communication. METHODS Three patient panels participated in structured discussions and a constrained choice prioritization exercise focused on 17 AI transparency elements derived from Duke Health’s AI governance process. Panels included a demographically sampled advisory panel (n=17), and members of community groups serving predominantly African American (n=12) and Hispanic/Latino (n=7) communities. Participants selected the four transparency elements they considered most important for patient-facing communication. Frequencies and percentages were compared across panels, and qualitative rapid analysis was used to contextualize and interpret prioritization patterns. RESULTS Across the three panels, the most frequently selected transparency elements were risks and limitations (21/34, 62%), how AI outputs are used in clinical care (18/34, 53%), the purpose of the AI tool (14/34, 41%), and intended care population (12/34, 35%). Elements describing the technical and organizational context, including algorithm type, software application, implementation location, and supporting department, were selected less frequently. Qualitative findings indicated that participants valued information that helped them understand how AI may influence care decisions and whether tools were relevant to patients with clinical or demographic characteristics similar to their own. Several priorities were broadly shared across panels, although notable differences emerged. CONCLUSIONS When asked to prioritize AI transparency elements, participants favored information that helped them understand how AI could affect their care and whether tools were appropriate for patients like them. These findings suggest that patient-facing communication should emphasize these concerns while remaining responsive to community-specific priorities. More broadly, the study demonstrates how patient and community perspectives can help translate an existing AI governance process into priorities for patient-facing communication.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Building trust through transparency: Patient priorities, preferences, and guidance for effective AI disclosureHealth Policy and Technology, 2026
- Factors for Patient Trust and Acceptance of Medical Artificial IntelligenceJAMA Network Open, 2026
- A comprehensive review of explainable artificial intelligence in healthcare methods, evaluation, and clinical integrationiScience, 2026
- Ethical Obligations to Inform Patients About Use of AI ToolsJAMA, 2025
- Patient perspectives on artificial intelligence in healthcare: A global scoping review of benefits, ethical concerns, and implementation strategiesInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2025
- Could transparent model cards with layered accessible information drive trust and safety in health AI?npj Digital Medicine, 2025
- Patients’ Trust in Health Systems to Use Artificial IntelligenceJAMA Network Open, 2025
- Patient Consent and The Right to Notice and Explanation of AI Systems Used in Health CareThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2024
- A review of Explainable Artificial Intelligence in healthcareComputers and Electrical Engineering, 2024
- An Ethically Supported Framework for Determining Patient Notification and Informed Consent Practices When Using Artificial Intelligence in Health CareChest, 2024