Global finfish aquaculture has expanded rapidly, yet the effects of feed type on sediment biogeochemical processes remain poorly understood. This study investigated how feed type, raw fish (RF) versus extruded pellets (EP), affects organic carbon (Corg) mineralization rates and pathways, S-Fe-P cycling, and benthic nutrient fluxes in finfish farm sediments. Compared with the EP site, the RF site showed greater organic matter sedimentation, resulting in higher microbial metabolic rates, including anaerobic Corg mineralization rate (CorgMR), sediment oxygen demand, sulfate reduction rate (SRR), and iron reduction rate (FeRR). SR was the dominant anaerobic Corg mineralization pathway at both fish farms, accounting for 86% and 78% of CorgMR at the RF and EP sites, respectively, whereas FeR was relatively more important at the control site. The RF site also exhibited the highest SRR, leading to the accumulation of reduced sulfur compounds, particularly hydrogen sulfide and acid-volatile sulfide, and thereby creating more sulfidic and reducing sediment conditions. Elevated sulfide stimulated the reductive dissolution of Fe(III) oxides and enhanced sediment-bound phosphate release into pore water, thereby leading to substantially increased benthic dissolved inorganic phosphorus (DIP) flux. Notably, the DIP flux at the RF site corresponded to 240% of the phosphate demand for primary production in the overlying water column. Overall, these results demonstrate that raw fish feed enhances SR, sulfide accumulation, and phosphorus mobilization through coupled S–Fe–P cycling, suggesting fish feed type is a key regulator of sediment biogeochemistry and highlighting the need for optimized feed management to support sustainable aquaculture.