A Decision Support Approach for Context-Based Sustainability Assessment of Wastewater Treatment Systems
Authors:
- Theresa Gonzales CarreraTCTheresa Gonzales Carrera
- Carla Mae Jabar PaustaCPCarla Mae Jabar Pausta
- Regina DamalerioRDRegina Damalerio
- Michael PromentillaMichael Promentilla
- Aileen H. OrbecidoAOAileen H. Orbecido
- Ador TorneoATAdor Torneo
- Renan TanhuecoRTRenan Tanhueco
- Kathleen AvisoKAKathleen Aviso
- Randy Odtojan CachoRCRandy Odtojan Cacho
- Arnel BeltranABArnel Beltran
Preprint
- 27 May 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Untreated wastewater remains a major challenge in developing countries due to the complexity of implementing wastewater treatment systems while considering sustainable environmental management for long term impact. Existing sustainability assessments for wastewater treatment rely on predefined indicators, emphasize urban contexts, and fail to capture municipal realities. This study develops a sustainability assessment framework for municipal wastewater planning in developing countries, using multi‑criteria decision analysis and systematic literature review for relevant indicators. The Analytic Hierarchy Process was applied to derive priority weights from experts in academe, industry, and government sectors. Five wastewater treatment scenarios were evaluated: septage treatment plant, constructed wetlands, conventional activated sludge (CAS), CAS with biological nutrient removal (BNR), and CAS with BNR and struvite recovery. Results show that among the sustainability criteria, the environmental pillar received the highest weight (0.4985), followed by resilience (0.2535), social (0.1278), and economic (0.1203) pillars. The scenario incorporating CAS, BNR, and struvite recovery achieved the highest sustainability score (0.3048). Sensitivity analysis confirmed the robustness of scenario rankings. Sludge quality was identified as the most critical indicator capable of triggering a rank reversal. The findings highlight the potential advantages of centralized nutrient-removal systems while also recognizing the economic relevance of nature-based solutions in resource-constrained municipalities. The proposed framework provides a context-adaptable decision-support tool for wastewater planning in developing countries. Quantitative indicator values for the five scenarios were drawn from published literature and expert consultations with existing wastewater facilities in the Philippines, enabling application in data-scarce municipal contexts where primary field measurements are not available.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Advanced Biological Nutrient Removal Techniques for Enhanced Water Quality2026
- Risk assessment for wastewater treatment facilities using integrated picture fuzzy based AHP-DEMATEL decision support systemEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2025
- Criteria evaluation for the selection of biosolids management options for land application in the Philippines using analytic hierarchy processJournal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 2025
- Costs and benefits of improving water and sanitation in slums and non-slum neighborhoods in Dhaka, a fast-growing mega-cityEcological Economics, 2023
- Multi-attribute sustainability assessment of wastewater treatment technologies using combined fuzzy multi-criteria decision-making techniquesJournal of Cleaner Production, 2022
- A sustainable performance assessment framework for circular management of municipal wastewater treatment plantsJournal of Cleaner Production, 2022
- Systematic approach to evaluating environmental and ecological technologies for wastewater treatmentChemosphere, 2019
- A stochastic fuzzy multi-criteria decision-making model for optimal selection of clean technologiesJournal of Cleaner Production, 2018
- Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process to identify parameter weights for developing a water quality indexEcological Indicators, 2017
- Life cycle-based decision support tool for selection of wastewater treatment alternativesJournal of Cleaner Production, 2016