Abstract
Ethnographically exploring how German judges in administrative courts of first instance navigate the practical, political, legal and ethical dilemmas of deciding on asylum appeals, this article identifies the oral hearing in asylum adjudication as a site of citizenship struggles in which rights claims by noncitizens undergo subtle transformations through the manner in which procedural rules are interpreted and enacted. Building on observations of asylum appeal hearings, conversations and focus group discussions with judges, I show that practices and sentiments of procedural justice among asylum appeal judges are at the core of these transformations. Hence, I argue for renewed analytical and conceptual attention to citizenship struggles that take place in webs of social relations within the realm of state law and across a graduated set of formal legal statuses for noncitizens.
Funding Information
  • the Fritz Thyssen Stiftung (10.15.2.002RE)
  • German Research Foundation (DFG) in the framework of the CRC 1171 “Affective Societies” and the Department ‘Law & Anthropology’ at the Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology

This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit: