Judicial Precedents in Civil Law Systems: A Dynamic Analysis
Preprint
- 1 January 2004
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
This paper uses a simple dynamic model to describe the evolution of judicial decision making in civil law systems. Unlike the common law systems, civil law jurisdictions do not adopt a stare decisis principle in adjudication. In deciding any given legal issue, precedents serve a persuasive role. Civil law courts are expected to take past decisions into account when there is a sufficient level of consistency in case law. Generally speaking, when uniform case law develops, courts treat precedents as a source of “soft” law, taking them into account when reaching a decision. The higher the level of uniformity in past precedents, the greater the persuasive force of case law. Although civil law jurisdictions do not allow dissenting judges to attach a dissent to a majority opinion, cases that do not conform to the dominant trend serve as a signal of dissent among the judiciary. These cases influence future decisions in varying ways in different legal traditions. Judges may also be influenced by recent jurisprudential trends and fads in case law. The evolution of case law under these doctrines of precedents is modeled, considering the possibility for consolidation or corrosion of legal remedies and the permanence of unsettled case law.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: International Review of Law and Economics, 26 (4), 519.
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Litigation, Judicial Path-Dependence, and Legal ChangeEuropean Journal of Law and Economics, 2005
- Litigation and the Evolution of Legal Remedies: A Dynamic ModelPublic Choice, 2003
- Stampede to judgement: persuasive influence and herding behavior by courtsAmerican Law and Economics Review, 1999
- What Do Judges and Justices Maximize? (The Same Thing Everybody Else Does)Supreme Court Economic Review, 1993
- Imperfect Decisions and the Law: On the Evolution of Legal Precedent and RulesThe Journal of Legal Studies, 1986
- The Selection of Disputes for LitigationThe Journal of Legal Studies, 1984
- An Economic Theory of the Evolution of Common LawThe Journal of Legal Studies, 1978
- An Economic Analysis of Legal RulemakingThe Journal of Legal Studies, 1974
- An Economic Analysis of the CourtsThe Journal of Law and Economics, 1971
- The Case Method in Canada and the Possibilities of Its Adaptation to the Civil LawThe Yale Law Journal, 1929