The Necessity of Value Pluralism in Administrative Practice
- 24 September 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Administration & Society
- Vol. 46 (8) , 1020-1028
Abstract
Overeem and Verhoef’s critique of my understanding of value pluralism (VP) in public administration boils down to two points. First, VP is a meta-ethical position that has little or no truck with the practical field of public administration. And, second, as they argue, even if we granted that VP might be relevant to real-world events, it would be impossible to infer from it the kind of choices that I suggest, as is allegedly demonstrated by the “inconsistency” beween my position and that of Spicer in this issue. Against this I argue for a pragmatist perspective on VP. In a multi-faceted, conflictual world we have no choice but to engage in practical moral judgment. This is called moral awareness and it enhances our understanding of self and the world that we work and live in. Moral awareness also sustains one of the central tasks of public administration: the creation of a just and democratic society.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- The push and pull of the world: how experience animates practiceEvidence & Policy, 2011
- Songs of Experience2005
- “Knowing” the Rules: Administrative Work as PracticePublic Administration Review, 2004
- Beyond Realism and Antirealism2003
- Oedipus in the Welfare Office2000
- The Morality of Pluralism1993
- Creating Facts and ValuesPhilosophy, 1985
- Fact and value1981