Consumer Trust Deficit and Repair Mechanisms in Food Safety Certification: Evidence from China’s Online Fruit Market
Open Access
Abstract
This study examines why consumer trust in China’s food safety certification system remains deficient despite the widespread use of certification, and how this deficit can be repaired, with a focus on the Commitment Certificate of Compliance (CCC). Drawing on signaling theory, institutional trust theory, and decoupling theory, we develop a framework of signal failure under institutional trust deficit and test the asymmetric effects of decoupling perception and institutional efficacy cognition on consumer trust, willingness to buy (WTB), and willingness to pay a premium (WTP). Data were obtained from an online survey of 1047 consumers in 30 provincial-level regions of China through Wenjuanxing in 2026, with IP restrictions and attention checks to ensure data quality. We employ OLS, Probit, and ordered Probit models, together with Bootstrap mediation, propensity score matching, and moderation analyses. The results show that decoupling perception is negatively associated with trust (β = −0.0984, p < 0.01), WTB, and WTP, and this association remains robust after matching (ATET = −0.1027, p < 0.01). Institutional efficacy cognition is positively associated with trust (β = 0.0638, p < 0.01) and WTB, but not WTP. Perceived risk reduction, quality expectation improvement (indirect effect = 0.0371), and trust repair partially mediate these relationships. The repair effect is stronger on low-trust platforms and among consumers with high food safety awareness. Trust repair therefore requires a shift from issuing certificates to building institutional trust.Keywords
Funding Information
- Renmin University of China (2530195)
- Korea Foundation for Advanced Studies (202630009)
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trust, risk and organic food: Evidence from the UK and JapanOrganic Agriculture, 2026
- Predicting consumer switching decisions: the trust paradox and its impact on the efficiency of sustainability-label and food chain brandsSustainable Futures, 2025
- Consumers' lay theories on food safety: Insights from a Q-methodology studyFood Quality and Preference, 2025
- The effects of safety certification and nutrition messaging on the demand for nutritionally enhanced food in urban EthiopiaFood Security, 2022
- Evidence of a health risk ‘signalling effect’ following the introduction of a sugar-sweetened beverage taxFood Policy, 2021
- Romanian consumers’ food safety knowledge, awareness on certified labelled food and trust in information sourcesFood Control, 2021
- Decoupling from international food safety standards: how small-scale indigenous farmers cope with conflicting institutions to ensure market participationAgriculture and Human Values, 2018
- Assessments of the quality of organic versus conventional products, by category and cognitive styleFood Quality and Preference, 2017
- A Question of Trust: the Pursuit of Consumer Trust in the Financial Sector by Means of EU LegislationJournal of Consumer Policy, 2016
- The reliability of third-party certification in the food chain: From checklists to risk-oriented auditingFood Control, 2009