Appraising academic appraisal in the new public management university
Author:
- 2 February 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management
- Vol. 37 (2) , 172-189
Abstract
Against a backdrop of new public management (NPM) thinking and managerialism generally applied to universities in a range of countries, this study examines one of its manifestations – performance management for academics. Drawing on in-depth interviews with 40 academics at an Australian university, this article identifies six stances regularly adopted by those conducting performance appraisal interviews with academics. These are labelled ‘nurturing’, ‘hard-driving’, ‘self-serving’, ‘coddling’, ‘disengaged’ and ‘hostile’. Each of these appraisal stances is described in detail and then considered from two perspectives – that of academics themselves and of NPM. The material presented suggests that while a ‘nurturing’ stance was viewed favourably by the academics interviewed, it is out of step with NPM thinking. ‘Hard-driving’ and ‘self-serving’ stances, which directly reflect NPM thinking, were disliked by many (although not all) of the interviewees who had experienced them. The most common appraising stance – a ‘disengaged’ one – was widely condemned, as was the ‘hostile’ stance, yet both stances have much in common with the ruthlessness of NPM.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Management-by-results and performance measurement in universities – implications for work motivationStudies in Higher Education, 2012
- NEW PUBLIC MANAGEMENT IN PUBLIC SECTOR ORGANIZATIONS: THE DARK SIDES OF MANAGERIALISTIC ‘ENLIGHTENMENT’Public Administration, 2009
- Managing a modern university: is it time for a rethink?Higher Education Research & Development, 2009
- THE NPM AGENDA: BACK TO THE FUTUREFinancial Accountability & Management, 2008
- Looking over our shoulders: critical thinking and ontological insecurity in higher educationLondon Review of Education, 2007
- Assuring Quality/Resisting Quality Assurance: Academics’ responses to ‘quality’ in some Australian universitiesQuality in Higher Education, 2006
- What about the workers? The expansion of higher education and the transformation of academic workIndustrial Relations Journal, 2004
- Putting academics in their placeThe Australian Educational Researcher, 2000
- The New Public Management in Action1996
- Changing attitudes of Australian academicsHigher Education, 1994