Sham neurosurgery in patients with Parkinson's disease: is it morally acceptable?
Authors:
- Gerard BoerGBGerard Boer
Open Access
- 1 June 2001
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 27 (3) , 151-156
Abstract
For a few decades, patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) have been treated with intracerebral transplantations of fetal mesencephalic tissue. The results of open trials have been variable. Double blind, placebo-controlled studies have recently been started in order to further investigate the efficacy of this new medical technique. In this paper we challenge the need for sham surgery in neurotransplantation research on PD patients. Considerations regarding the research subjects' informed consent, therapeutic misconception, the integrity of the human body, and the assessment of risks and benefits argue against sham surgery for patients with PD. Moreover, there is an alternative, less harmful mode of research that can provide the same or comparable scientific evidence. A plea is made for intrapatient research based on quantitative measurements of the patient's pre- and post-operative condition combined with similar research on a reference group of patients who have received the standard treatment.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Ethical Problems with Sham Surgery in Clinical ResearchNew England Journal of Medicine, 1999
- Use of Placebo Surgery in Controlled Trials of a Cellular-Based Therapy for Parkinson's DiseaseNew England Journal of Medicine, 1999
- Research, ethics and conflicts of interest.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1999
- Cerebral implantation in movement disorders: State of the artMovement Disorders, 1999
- Fetal nigral transplantation as a therapy for Parkinson's diseaseTrends in Neurosciences, 1996
- Bilateral motor improvement and alteration of L-dopa effect in two patients with Parkinson's disease following intrastriatal transplantation of foetal ventral mesencephalonBrain, 1994
- Ethical guidelines for the use of human embryonic or fetal tissue for experimental and clinical neurotransplantation and researchJournal of Neurology, 1994
- The Polkinghorne Report on Fetal Research: nice recommendations, shame about the reasoning.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1993
- Core assessment program for intracerebral transplantations (CAPIT)Movement Disorders, 1992
- Equipoise and the Ethics of Clinical ResearchNew England Journal of Medicine, 1987