Kuhnian perspectives in science education: a comparative review of proponents and skeptics
Open Access
- 1 May 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Institute of Advanced Engineering and Science in Journal of Education and Learning (EduLearn)
- Vol. 19 (2) , 853-863
Abstract
Despite the abundance of literature discussing Kuhnian views, it is rare to find studies that comprehensively compare the arguments of Kuhnian supporters and skeptics. This study aims to fill the gap by providing a comparative review and synthesis between the two groups of views using the systematic literature review (SLR) analysis technique. The researcher found 1,413 articles reduced with the standard prism protocol to 32 articles that examined Kuhn's views. Proponents support the existence of Kuhn's scientific paradigm where they not only strengthen and consider the importance of Kuhn's theory, but also expand its application to various fields, showing the flexibility and relevance of the theory in understanding the scientific revolution that occurred in various disciplines. Skeptics criticize Kuhn's views such as the ambiguity of the term "paradigm", the non-recognition of scientific revolutions that lead to scientific evolution, and the doubt of the concept of incommensurability in various disciplines. This shows that Thomas Kuhn made a great contribution to the world of scientific education because it can provoke experts to study his thoughts for the benefit of science. The findings of this study are expected to contribute to policy makers and other researchers in applying and studying Kuhn's paradigm.Keywords
This publication has 60 references indexed in Scilit:
- Beyond Kuhnian paradigms: Normal science and theory dependence in ecologyEcology and Evolution, 2023
- A Kuhnian revolution in molecular biology: Most genes in complex organisms express regulatory RNAsBioEssays, 2023
- Thomas Kuhn and Science EducationScience & Education, 2022
- Symbolic revolutions. Mobilizing a neglected Bourdieusian concept for historical sociologyTheory and Society, 2021
- Cournot and Renouvier on Scientific RevolutionsJournal for General Philosophy of Science, 2021
- Religious Conversion and Loss of Faith: Cases of Personal Paradigm Shift?Sophia, 2021
- Paradigms in Structure: finally, a countScientometrics, 2020
- From Student of Physics to Historian of Science: T.S. Kuhn’s Education and Early Career, 1940–1958Physics in Perspective, 2012
- Kuhnian Science and Education Research: Analytics of Practice and Training2007
- Thomas Kuhn's impact on science education: What lessons can be learned?Science Education, 2003