PISA and policy-borrowing: A philosophical perspective on their interplay in mathematics education
Author:
Open Access
- 4 October 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Educational Philosophy and Theory
- Vol. 51 (12) , 1200-1215
Abstract
Mathematics achievement in different education systems around the world is assessed periodically in the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). PISA is deemed to yield robust international comparisons of mathematical attainment that enable individual countries and regions to monitor the performance of their education systems relative to standards being achieved internationally, with a view to informing their mathematics education policy decisions. Initially, the role of PISA in instigating mathematics education policy borrowing is outlined using England as a case study, and some existing technical critiques of PISA are then reviewed. Following this, aspects of Ludwig Wittgenstein’s later philosophy of mind are used to reason that an over-reliance on the use of PISA to inform policy decisions in mathematics education may be problematic. It is suggested that, when PISA is viewed through a later Wittgensteinian lens, a potential deficiency in the underpinning psychometric model, pertaining to the inherent indeterminism in unmeasured mathematical abilities, may weaken PISA’s utility in guiding mathematics education policy decisions. It is concluded that, whilst PISA mathematics scores may give some indication of the mathematical proficiency of a nation’s students, caution is required before mathematics education policies are borrowed from other jurisdictions on the basis of PISA performance. Implications for the other PISA domains are also outlined.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Methodologies for Investigating Item- and Test-Level Measurement Equivalence in International Large-Scale AssessmentsInternational Journal of Testing, 2012
- A computer game as a context for non-routine mathematical problem solving: The effects of type of question prompt and level of prior knowledgeComputers & Education, 2009
- Neocolonialism in education: Cooperative Learning in an Asian contextComparative Education, 2009
- Governing by numbers: the PISA ‘effect’ in EuropeJournal of Education Policy, 2009
- The politics of international league tables: PISA in Japan’s achievement crisis debateComparative Education, 2008
- Knowledge and Skills for PISA?Assessing the AssessmentJournal of Philosophy of Education, 2007
- Educational standards and the changing discourse on education: the reception and consequences of the PISA study in GermanyOxford Review of Education, 2006
- International comparisons of student attainment: some issues arising from the PISA studyAssessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 2004
- Processes of Policy Borrowing in Education: some explanatory and analytical devicesComparative Education, 2003
- Cautions on OECD'S Recent Educational Survey (PISA)Oxford Review of Education, 2003