God orTidibe? Melanesian Christianity and the Problem of Wholes
Author:
- 24 June 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Ethnos
- Vol. 73 (2) , 141-162
Abstract
The article examines the claim that some Melanesian Christians are caught between cultures; between a Melanesian ‘relationalism’ and a Christian ‘individualism’. It is suggested that such an argument attributes Western knowledge conventions and dilemmas, where understanding involves distinct but connected whole orders of knowledge, to Melanesians. The article questions the appropriateness of this. To illustrate the issue, case studies of understanding Melanesian Christianity from a historical and anthropological perspective are considered and it is shown that interpretive problems arise by being caught between these disciplinary wholes. It is argued instead that Melanesian Christians are not caught between cultures. Rather, the diverse forms of Melanesian Christianity express conventional Melanesian concerns about certainty, power and truth, concerns that are nonetheless influenced by Christian conceptions and conduct.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Continuity Thinking and the Problem of Christian CultureCurrent Anthropology, 2007
- When was modernity in Melanesia?1Social Anthropology/Anthropologie Sociale, 2007
- Landscape, Myth and TimeJournal of Material Culture, 2006
- A landscape of powers in Highland Papua, C. 1899-1918History and Anthropology, 2003
- AGENCY, PERSONHOOD AND THE ‘I’ OF DISCOURSE IN THE PACIFIC AND BEYONDJournal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 2000
- Modernity and forms of personhood in Melanesia1998
- Between Mission and Market: Events and Images in a Melanesian SocietyMan, 1994
- Contracting Colonialism1993
- Ku Waru1991
- Asiwinarong1986