Learning curves of the Glidescope, the McGrath and the Airtraq laryngoscopes: a manikin study
Authors:
- Georges L SavoldelliGSGeorges L Savoldelli
- Eduardo SchifferESEduardo Schiffer
- Christoph AbeggCAChristoph Abegg
- Vincent BaeriswylVBVincent Baeriswyl
- François ClergueFCFrançois Clergue
- Jean-Luc WaeberJWJean-Luc Waeber
- 1 July 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in European Journal of Anaesthesiology
- Vol. 26 (7) , 554-558
Abstract
Several video and optical laryngoscopes have been developed but few have been compared in terms of their learning curves and efficacy. Using a manikin with normal airways we compared the Glidescope, the McGrath, the Airtraq and the Macintosh laryngoscopes. Sixty anaesthetists (20 staff, 20 residents and 20 nurses) participated in the study. All subjects were novice with the new devices. They intubated a Laerdal SimMan manikin (with normal airway) five times in a row with all laryngoscopes. The sequence of use of the devices was randomized. Before using a device, a presentation and a demonstration were provided. Outcome measures were: duration of intubation attempt, modified Cormack grades, dental trauma and difficulty of use. The Airtraq had the most favourable learning curve and mirrored the Macintosh after two intubation attempts. The Glidescope and McGrath had steep learning curves but, after five attempts, differences persisted when compared with the Macintosh and Airtraq. Time taken to visualize the glottis was similar but time taken to position the endotracheal tube was shorter for the Airtraq when compared with the Glidescope and McGrath. Indirect laryngoscopes seemed to have advantages over the Macintosh blade in terms of laryngeal exposure and potential dental trauma. In a ‘normal airway’ model, intubation skills with the new devices appeared to be rapidly mastered. The three indirect laryngoscopes provided a better glottic exposure than the Macintosh. The Airtraq displayed the most favourable learning curve, probably reflecting differences in the techniques of endotracheal tube placement: guiding channel versus steering technique.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of the GlideScope video laryngoscope and Macintosh laryngoscope in simulated tracheal intubation scenariosEmergency Medicine Journal, 2008
- Cervical Spine Motion During Tracheal Intubation with Manual In-Line Stabilization: Direct Laryngoscopy versus GlideScope® VideolaryngoscopyAnesthesia & Analgesia, 2008
- Evaluation of the Airtraq ® and Macintosh laryngoscopes in patients at increased risk for difficult tracheal intubation*Anaesthesia, 2008
- Use of the McGrath® videolaryngoscope in the management of difficult and failed tracheal intubationBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2007
- Endotracheal Intubation in Patients with Cervical Spine ImmobilizationAnesthesiology, 2007
- Case series: The McGrath® videolaryngoscope — an initial clinical evaluationCanadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie, 2007
- Early clinical experience with a new videolaryngoscope (GlideScope®) in 728 patientsCanadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie, 2005
- Use of angulated video-intubation laryngoscope in children undergoing manual in-line neck stabilizationBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2001
- Comparison of two video‐assisted techniques for the difficult intubationActa Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, 2001
- Evaluation of the Bullard Laryngoscope Using the New Intubating StyletAnesthesia & Analgesia, 1994