Repeatability of wildlife surveys for estimating abundance: A method to assess the consistency of detection probability and animal availability
Open Access
- 23 April 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (4) , e0321619
Abstract
A primary consideration of abundance studies that use unmarked animals is whether survey counts accurately reflect the population size or if unknown variation in animal movement or detection probability biases counts irrespective of population size. We posited that high repeatability in counts among temporally replicated surveys would indicate that counts are a good index of abundance. We temporally replicated 49 nocturnal spotlight surveys of white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) up to three times each (n = 128 total samples) to test the repeatability of this commonly used wildlife monitoring technique. Repeatability was high (R = 0.86), suggesting spring spotlight surveys provide a reliable index of deer population size in Iowa, USA. Fourteen percent of the variation among replicated counts was explained by day of year and, to a lesser degree, a vegetation green-up index. Detection probability was high (~0.70) early in the sampling season and declined considerably during the following 6 weeks. Deer abundance was greater at sites with higher percent landcovers of forest and hay/pasture and was lower at sites with higher landcover in crops. Our findings suggest deer managers should sample prior to green-up in the spring to maximize the proportion of the population that is detectable, and that accounting for seasonality on detection estimation is important for reliable abundance estimates if sampling occurs over a range of phenological progression. Finally, we show that temporal replication of surveys is a logistically feasible method to assess the reliability of abundance estimates from study designs that are normally conducted with single visits.Keywords
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- Designing count‐based studies in a world of hierarchical modelsThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2024
- Understanding implications of detection heterogeneity in wildlife abundance estimationThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2023
- Hybrid mark–resight approaches account for heterogeneous detection bias in aerial surveysEcological Solutions and Evidence, 2023
- Weather conditions affecting white‐tailed deer harvest in IowaThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2023
- A review of N‐mixture modelsWIREs Computational Statistics, 2023
- Methodology matters when estimating deer abundance: a global systematic review and recommendations for improvementsThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2022
- Using spotlight observations to predict resource selection and abundance for white‐tailed deerThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2019
- On the robustness of N‐mixture modelsEcology, 2018
- Estimating abundance and population trends when detection is low and highly variable: A comparison of three methods for the Hermann's tortoiseThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2013
- Spotlight surveys for white‐tailed deer: Monitoring panacea or exercise in futility?The Journal of Wildlife Management, 2012