The pursuitworthiness of informational biology
Open Access
- 15 September 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Biology & Philosophy
- Vol. 40 (5) , 1-29
Abstract
The debate of “scientific pursuit” has been revitalized by philosophers of science in recent years. In this article, we adopt the analytic distinction between appraisals of pursuit and appraisals of acceptance as a useful tool to analyze a historical episode that remains poorly understood in contemporary philosophy and history of science. Namely, we propose to identify an “informational research tradition” in molecular biology, spanning from the mid-twentieth century to today, and assess it as a research tradition that has persistently passed appraisals of pursuit despite struggling to pass appraisals of acceptance. This historical case, in turn, allows us to rethink the notion of scientific pursuit in a more pluralistic fashion. We argue that biologists’ perception of the pursuitworthiness of the informational research tradition entailed three distinct promises, often in trade-off with one another: a promise of unification, a promise of understanding, and a promise of quantitative prediction. Distinguishing between these promises is fundamental to highlighting the variety of expectations involved in actual epistemic evaluations involved in contexts of pursuit.Keywords
Funding Information
- Universidad de Sevilla
This publication has 75 references indexed in Scilit:
- Promisingness in Theory Choice2020
- Rational endorsementPhilosophical Studies, 2017
- What is Shannon information?Synthese, 2015
- Epistemic justification in the context of pursuit: a coherentist approachSynthese, 2014
- Explanatory Models Versus Predictive Models: Reduced Complexity Modeling in Geomorphology2013
- Pragmatic Unification, Observation and Realism in Astroparticle PhysicsJournal for General Philosophy of Science, 2012
- Kuhn and the Question of Pursuit WorthinessTopoi, 2012
- The structure of tradeoffs in model buildingSynthese, 2008
- HEURISTIC APPRAISAL: CONTEXT OF DISCOVERY OR JUSTIFICATION?2006
- The Fertility of Theory and the Unit for Appraisal in Science1976