Contested Frameworks: Understanding the Lived Experience of Human Rights Defenders in the Mapuche Struggle in Chile
Author:
- 16 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Human Rights Practice
- Vol. 18 (2)
Abstract
Despite growing recognition within global human rights frameworks of the need to protect human rights defenders (HRDs), understanding the nuanced threats and risks they face—and developing effective monitoring mechanisms—remains a complex and unresolved challenge. At the same time, the question of ‘Who are HRDs?’ is not straightforward and encompasses various contested issues in the field. In this article, we focus on the situation of legal defenders advocating for Indigenous communities in Southern Chile within a context of dual judicialization—state-led criminalization through anti-terrorism laws and community-driven reliance on human rights frameworks. Through qualitative research comprising interviews with 35 HRDs, including lawyers, activists, and experts, this article examines (1) the contested meaning of the HRD category in the local scenario; (2) the multiple risks and threats that legal defenders of Indigenous rights encounter; and (3) the strategies they employ to respond to these threats. The findings show that legal HRDs operate as intermediaries between Indigenous communities, national courts, and international human rights frameworks. While some actors adopt the HRD label strategically, others question or distance themselves from it, revealing tensions surrounding the application of this category in Indigenous struggles. At the same time, legal defenders are exposed to a range of risks, from state-sponsored criminalization and extra-institutional harassment to everyday stigmatization. These experiences are shaped by broader contextual factors, including systemic racism, multifaceted violence, and complex power dynamics. The article concludes by advocating for a multidimensional approach to understanding and addressing violence impacting environmental and Indigenous struggles, while recognizing both the potential and limitations of the HRD framework in such contexts.Keywords
Funding Information
- Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo
- FONDECYT de Iniciación (11221265)
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Environmental democracy: Examining the interplay between Escazu Agreement’s innovations and EU economic lawEarth System Governance, 2024
- Environmental conflicts and defenders: A global overviewGlobal Environmental Change, 2020
- The supply chain of violenceNature Sustainability, 2019
- Human Rights as Battlefields2019
- Indigenous Peoples in Chile: Contesting Violence, Building New Meanings for Rights and Democracy2018
- Violence in environmental conflicts: the need for a multidimensional approachSustainability Science, 2018
- Contemporary debates on social-environmental conflicts, extractivism and human rights in Latin AmericaThe International Journal of Human Rights, 2017
- Children and the Afterlife of State Violence2016
- Towards developing a critical and ethical approach for better recognising and protecting human rights defendersThe International Journal of Human Rights, 2015
- The Cultural Politics of Human Rights2009