Trade-off between disease resistance and crop yield: a landscape-scale mathematical modelling perspective
Open Access
- 31 October 2016
- journal article
- Published by The Royal Society in Journal of The Royal Society Interface
- Vol. 13 (123) , 20160451
Abstract
The deployment of crop varieties that are partially resistant to plant pathogens is an important method of disease control. However, a trade-off may occur between the benefits of planting the resistant variety and a yield penalty, whereby the standard susceptible variety outyields the resistant one in the absence of disease. This presents a dilemma: deploying the resistant variety is advisable only if the disease occurs and is sufficient for the resistant variety to outyield the infected standard variety. Additionally, planting the resistant variety carries with it a further advantage in that the resistant variety reduces the probability of disease invading. Therefore, viewed from the perspective of a grower community, there is likely to be an optimal trade-off and thus an optimal cropping density for the resistant variety. We introduce a simple stochastic, epidemiological model to investigate the trade-off and the consequences for crop yield. Focusing on susceptible–infected–removed epidemic dynamics, we use the final size equation to calculate the surviving host population in order to analyse the yield, an approach suitable for rapid epidemics in agricultural crops. We identify a single compound parameter, which we call the efficacy of resistance and which incorporates the changes in susceptibility, infectivity and durability of the resistant variety. We use the compound parameter to inform policy plots that can be used to identify the optimal strategy for given parameter values when an outbreak is certain. When the outbreak is uncertain, we show that for some parameter values planting the resistant variety is optimal even when it would not be during the outbreak. This is because the resistant variety reduces the probability of an outbreak occurring.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Durable Resistance to Crop Pathogens: An Epidemiological Framework to Predict Risk under UncertaintyPLOS Computational Biology, 2013
- Durable strategies to deploy plant resistance in agricultural landscapesNew Phytologist, 2012
- Perceptions of Disease Risk: From Social Construction of Subjective Judgments to Rational Decision MakingPhytopathology®, 2011
- Impact of scale on the effectiveness of disease control strategies for epidemics with cryptic infection in a dynamical landscape: an example for a crop diseaseJournal of The Royal Society Interface, 2007
- Optimizing the control of disease infestations at the landscape scaleProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2007
- The plant immune systemNature, 2006
- Botanical Epidemiology: Some Key Advances and its Continuing Role in Disease ManagementEuropean Journal of Plant Pathology, 2006
- Perspectives on the basic reproductive ratioJournal of The Royal Society Interface, 2005
- Effect of Leaf Rust Resistance Gene Lr34 on Grain Yield and Agronomic Traits of Spring WheatCrop Science, 1997
- Components of Resistance that Reduce the Rate of Epidemic DevelopmentAnnual Review of Phytopathology, 1979