A comparative analysis of congruent triangle units in textbooks from China and the United States
Authors:
Open Access
- 26 July 2024
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Asian Journal for Mathematics Education
- Vol. 3 (3) , 312-327
Abstract
In this article, we report findings from a comparative study of the introduction and development of triangle congruence in two textbooks: a high school geometry textbook from the United States and an eighth-grade mathematics textbook from China. Using the mathematics curriculum as a story (MCS) framework developed by Dietiker and additional coding schemes, we illustrate how each textbook designs its congruent triangle lessons with the goal to provide students a fertile ground for the development of geometry reasoning and proof. Through the analysis of the characters, actions, settings, and plots of each story, we identify both similarities and differences. Both textbooks introduced the same sets of side–angle criteria that proved the existence of the unique triangle as well as that did not support a unique triangle. Yet, the U.S. textbooks introduced side–angle–side first while the Chinese textbooks started with side–side–side. In addition, the findings demonstrate the illuminating power of the MCS framework to fill the gap of current textbook analysis research.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Does a transformation approach improve students’ ability in constructing auxiliary lines for solving geometric problems? An intervention-based study with two Chinese classroomsEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2017
- What Can We Learn from Textbook Analysis?2017
- An Analysis of Problem-Posing Tasks in Chinese and US Elementary Mathematics TextbooksInternational Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 2016
- Mathematical story: a metaphor for mathematics curriculumEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2015
- The Mathematical Nature of Reasoning-and-Proving Opportunities in Geometry TextbooksMathematical Thinking and Learning, 2014
- The introduction of proof in secondary geometry textbooksInternational Journal of Educational Research, 2014
- Textbook research in mathematics education: development status and directionsZDM – Mathematics Education, 2013
- Students’ Conceptions of Congruency Through the Use of Dynamic Geometry SoftwareInternational Journal of Computers for Mathematical Learning, 2009
- Representation of problem-solving procedures: A comparative look at China, Singapore, and US mathematics textbooksEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2007
- According to the Book2002