High-value decisions are made quickly, with no consistent effect on accuracy
Open Access
- 13 November 2025
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in PNAS Nexus
- Vol. 4 (12)
Abstract
High-value decisions tend to be made more quickly. For instance, decision-makers are generally faster when choosing between two preferred options than when choosing between two less preferred options. Several theories have been developed to explain why people are faster for higher overall values, such as facilitation of information processing, reduced caution, or increased processing noise. Importantly, these theories make different predictions for how overall value should influence accuracy, though current results in the literature provide mixed conclusions. Here, we reanalyzed data from 40 previous studies to examine whether decision accuracy is consistently influenced by the overall value of the options. We find that, aside from low-level stimuli-driven effects, decision accuracy does not show a consistent pattern of increase or decrease based on overall value. Our results suggest that earlier claims of a systematic effect of overall value on decision accuracy may have been premature. We provide a mechanistic account of results, discuss why these results may challenge many prevailing theories of decision-making, and highlight open questions for future research.Keywords
Funding Information
- Leverhulme Trust (RPG-2025-145)
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Variability and accessibility of information guide gaze dynamics in decision making.Decision, 2025
- Divergent effects of absolute evidence magnitude on decision accuracy and confidence in perceptual judgementsCognition, 2022
- Magnitude-sensitivity: rethinking decision-makingTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2022
- Attention as a source of variability in decision-making: Accounting for overall-value effects with diffusion modelsJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 2021
- Equal evidence perceptual tasks suggest a key role for interactive competition in decision-making.Psychological Review, 2021
- Does Attention Increase the Value of Choice Alternatives?Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2021
- Perceptual change-of-mind decisions are sensitive to absolute evidence magnitudeCognitive Psychology, 2021
- Modeling 2-alternative forced-choice tasks: Accounting for both magnitude and difference effectsCognitive Psychology, 2018
- Evidence for the speed–value trade-off: Human and monkey decision making is magnitude sensitive.Decision, 2018
- The time course of perceptual choice: The leaky, competing accumulator model.Psychological Review, 2001