Prediction of Three-Year Outcome of Renal Transplantation from Optimal Donors versus Expanded Criteria Donors
Authors:
- Gaetano La MannaGaetano La Manna
- Giorgia ComaiGCGiorgia Comai
- Maria L. CappuccilliMCMaria L. Cappuccilli
- Giovanni Liviano D’aRcangeloGDGiovanni Liviano D’aRcangelo
- Benedetta FabbrizioBFBenedetta Fabbrizio
- Chiara ValentiniCVChiara Valentini
- Elisa CarrettaECElisa Carretta
- Matteo RavaioliMatteo Ravaioli
- Maria P. ScolariMSMaria P. Scolari
- Lorenza RidolfiLRLorenza Ridolfi
- Giorgio FeliciangeliGFGiorgio Feliciangeli
- Franco W. GrigioniFGFranco W. Grigioni
- 2 February 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by S. Karger AG in American Journal of Nephrology
- Vol. 37 (2) , 158-166
Abstract
Background/Aims: The shortage in organ supply has required the use of expanded criteria donors (ECD) for kidney transplantation. Current pre-transplant evaluations of ECD organs are based on histological, clinical or mixed criteria. This monocentric study investigates the predictivity of Karpinski’s histological score on 3-year graft function in renal transplant. Ex-post classification using Nyberg’s score was carried out to assess the reliability of a purely clinical score and its applicability for organ allocation. Methods: We evaluated 407 deceased donors (251 optimal and 156 ECD) for renal transplants performed between 2001 and 2006. The differences in creatinine levels and MDRD-GFR at transplant and 1, 2 and 3 years post-transplant between optimal donors and ECD were recorded. Amongst ECD organs, the effect of different Karpinski score classes (0–1, 2, 3, 4, double transplants) on 3-year graft outcomes was analyzed. We then compared renal function over time across the Nyberg grades (A, B, C, and D). Results: Karpinski scores 0–1 and 2 and double transplants were associated with improved graft function compared to scores 3 and 4. Nyberg’s clinical score shows a good fit with medium-term outcome and Karpinski’s score, but among the donors with a high Nyberg grade (C and D), it fails to differentiate between allocable or non-allocable organs (due to Karpinski’s score ≥7). Conclusions: Our data demonstrate a correlation of histological damage at the time of transplant with 3-year graft function, but at present we are unable to provide any supposition on the possible outcome of the discarded kidneys.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Donor risk scores: can they predict renal transplant outcomes?Nature Reviews Nephrology, 2011
- Donor risk score and baseline biopsy CADI value predict kidney graft outcomeClinical Transplantation, 2011
- The Kidney Allocation Score: Methodological Problems, Moral Concerns and Unintended ConsequencesAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2009
- A Systematic Review of Kidney Transplantation From Expanded Criteria DonorsAmerican Journal of Kidney Diseases, 2008
- Shared decision making in deceased-donor transplantationThe Lancet, 2006
- Evaluation of pre-implantation kidney biopsies: Comparison of Banff criteria to a morphometric approachKidney International, 2005
- The Broad Spectrum of Quality in Deceased Donor KidneysAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2005
- Improved Scoring System to Assess Adult Donors For Cadaver Renal TransplantationAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2003
- Expanded criteria donors for kidney transplantationAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2003
- Donor Scoring System for Cadaveric Renal TransplantationAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2001