Use of Clinical Judgment Analysis to Explain Regional Variations in Physicians' Accuracies in Diagnosing Pneumonia
Authors:
- Paul S. HeckerlingPHPaul S. Heckerling
- Joseph P. OrnatoJOJoseph P. Ornato
- Robert S. WigtonRWRobert S. Wigton
- 1 August 1991
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
- Vol. 11 (3) , 189-197
Abstract
The authors sought to explain regional differences in physicians' accuracies in diagnosing pneumonia by prospectively studying emergency department patients at three sites and analyzing differences in physicians' diagnostic strategies and patient characteristics. They enrolled 1,119 Illinois patients, 150 Nebraska patients, and 142 Virginia patients presenting with fever or respiratory symptoms for whom physicians ordered a chest radiograph because of suspicion of pneumonia. Emergency department physicians recorded patients' clinical findings and estimated the probability that a chest radiograph would show pneumonia. A measure of accuracy, the correlation between physicians' probability estimates and actual outcomes, was 0.41 (95% Cl 0.36-0.46) at Illinois, 0.66 (95% Cl 0.54-0.75) at Nebraska, and 0.55 (95% Cl 0.42-0.65) at Virginia. Physicians' strategies at the three sites differed markedly in their weightings of asthma, signs of consolidation, cough, tachypnea, age, and gender. These differences in weighting paralleled differences in the optimal clinical strategies derived from patient data at the three sites. Differences in diagnostic accuracy were best explained by differences in the difficulties of diagnosing pneumonia in the populations. Phy sicians at each site used clinical findings in a way that was close to optimal for their location. This type of analysis provides a new tool for understanding the sources of regional variations in clinical practice. Key words: judgment analysis; variation research; pneumonia. (Med Decis Making 1991 ;11 :189-197)Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Clinical Prediction Rule for Pulmonary InfiltratesAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1990
- An Assessment of Prostatectomy for Benign Urinary Tract ObstructionJAMA, 1988
- Temporomandibular DisordersMedical Care, 1988
- Does Inappropriate Use Explain Geographic Variations in the Use of Health Care Services?JAMA, 1987
- Exploring Physician Responses to Patients?? Extramedical CharacteristicsMedical Care, 1987
- The Determinants of Treatment Choice in End-stage Renal DiseaseMedical Decision Making, 1986
- Inappropriate Use of Hospitals in a Randomized Trial of Health Insurance PlansNew England Journal of Medicine, 1986
- Physician Characteristics and Organizational Factors Influencing Use of Ambulatory TestsMedical Decision Making, 1985
- A Comparison of Surgical Rates in Canada and in England and WalesNew England Journal of Medicine, 1973
- Variations in the Incidence of SurgeryNew England Journal of Medicine, 1969