The applicability of acute-to-chronic ratios and in silico tools in estimating chronic aquatic toxicity of ingredients in cosmetics and personal care products
Authors:
- Júlia Beatriz Vaz de OliveiraJOJúlia Beatriz Vaz de Oliveira
- Natália de Albuquerque Vita de AbreuNANatália de Albuquerque Vita de Abreu
- Dâmaris Cristine Marios Ferreira PintoDPDâmaris Cristine Marios Ferreira Pinto
- Gabriela de Oliveira Prado CorrêaGabriela de Oliveira Prado Corrêa
- Andrezza Di Pietro Micali CanavezACAndrezza Di Pietro Micali Canavez
- Desirée Cigaran SchuckDSDesirée Cigaran Schuck
- Cynthia Bomfim PestanaCPCynthia Bomfim Pestana
- Daniela Morais LemeDLDaniela Morais Leme
- 5 August 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
Abstract
Understanding the potential environmental impact of cosmetics and personal care products (PCPs) and successfully developing eco-friendly formulations requires knowledge of the aquatic toxicity of ingredients. However, for the cosmetics industry, aquatic toxicity assessments are challenged by the large number of ingredients, restrictions on animal testing, and lack of chronic toxicity data. Therefore, alternative approaches are required to fill these gaps. This study aimed to evaluate the potential applicability of acute-to-chronic ratios (ACRs) and in silico tools (VEGA and OECD QSAR Toolbox) to estimate chronic aquatic toxicity values (no observed effect concentrations [NOECs] for algae, daphnids, and fish) for a set of 41 ingredients of cosmetics and PCPs with well-defined molecular structures. Extrapolations and predictions were compared with experimental chronic toxicity data. We observed that ACR-based extrapolations were strongly correlated with experimental NOECs, particularly when using the lowest ACRs, with algae showing the strongest correlation. Mode of action (MoA)-based ACRs did not improve the prediction of chronic values when compared with general ACRs. Extrapolated values were not consistently conservative, with both over and underpredictions observed. The OECD QSAR Toolbox yielded more acceptable chronic toxicity predictions than VEGA, yet both exhibited weaker correlations with experimental data than the ACR-based approach. Predictive performance of the in silico models improved when analyzing the subgroup of MoA 1 substances for algae. Overall, our findings support the use of ACRs for filling chronic toxicity data gaps in screening-level assessments within environmental hazard-based tools for developing eco-friendly cosmetics and PCPs, whereas the freely available in silico tools require further refinement to improve performance in this context.Keywords
Funding Information
- Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (421823/2022-4)
- Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (311120/2023-7)
- Grupo Boticário
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- The development and application of a novel hazard scoring tool for assessing impacts of cosmetic ingredients on aquatic ecosystems: A case study of rinse-off cosmeticsIntegrated Environmental Assessment and Management, 2023
- Algorithm for environmental risk assessment of cosmetics to reduce their environmental impactToxicological Research, 2022
- Derivation of algal acute to chronic ratios for use in chemical toxicity extrapolationsChemosphere, 2020
- Polycyclic musks in surface water and sediments from an urban catchment in the megacity Beijing, ChinaEnvironmental Pollution, 2020
- Extrapolation Factors for Characterizing Freshwater Ecotoxicity EffectsEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 2019
- Automated and standardized workflows in the OECD QSAR ToolboxComputational Toxicology, 2019
- Fish embryo tests and acute fish toxicity tests are interchangeable in the application of the threshold approachEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 2019
- How in silico and QSAR approaches can increase confidence in environmental hazard and risk assessmentIntegrated Environmental Assessment and Management, 2018
- A Systematic Approach for Evaluating the Quality of Experimental Toxicological and Ecotoxicological DataRegulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, 1997
- Classifying environmental pollutantsChemosphere, 1992