IRBs and the Protection-Inclusion Dilemma: Finding a Balance
- 28 April 2022
- journal article
- other
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 23 (6) , 75-88
Abstract
Institutional review boards, tasked with facilitating ethical research, are often pulled in competing directions. In what we call the protection-inclusion dilemma, we acknowledge the tensions IRBs face in aiming to both protect potential research participants from harm and include under-represented populations in research. In this manuscript, we examine the history of protectionism that has dominated research ethics oversight in the United States, as well as two responses to such protectionism: inclusion initiatives and critiques of the term vulnerability. We look at what we know about IRB decision-making in relation to protecting and including “vulnerable” groups in research and examine the lack of regulatory guidance related to this dilemma, which encourages protection over inclusion within IRB practice. Finally, we offer recommendations related to how IRBs might strike a better balance between inclusion and protection in research ethics oversight.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences (3UL1TR002541)
This publication has 72 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Delphi Study to Establish Important Aspects of Ethics ReviewJournal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics, 2011
- Rethinking Research EthicsThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2010
- Inclusion of Women, Minorities, and Children in Clinical Trials: Opinions of Research Ethics Board AdministratorsJournal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics, 2009
- Vulnerability as a Regulatory Category in Human Subject ResearchJournal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 2009
- Review of a mock research protocol in functional neuroimaging by Canadian research ethics boardsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2006
- Conducting ethical research in pediatrics: A brief historical overview and review of pediatric regulationsThe Journal of Pediatrics, 2006
- Exclusion and Inclusion of Nonwhite Ethnic Minority Groups in 72 North American and European Cardiovascular Cohort StudiesPLOS Medicine, 2006
- Evaluation of "Subject Advocate" Procedures in the Clinical Antipsychotic Trials of Intervention Effectiveness (CATIE) Schizophrenia StudySchizophrenia Bulletin, 2005
- Wanted: Women in Clinical TrialsScience, 2005
- The Limitations of “Vulnerability” as a Protection for Human Research ParticipantsThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2004