This chapter addresses the question, “How might teachers cultivate historical inquiry in the face of historical silence?” I ground this discussion within my own context as a queer Japanese American cis-male who taught for many years in New York City public schools. I draw from my previous teaching experiences to consider possibilities for history pedagogy and curriculum in schools. I answer this question by first turning to history scholars who grapple with related questions of historical silence, absence, and negation. I then apply their approaches to secondary social studies classrooms. In particular, I turn to historical scholarship in cultural studies, subaltern studies, queer studies, decolonial studies, and critical theory. Such scholarship forefronts various power dynamics that arise when centering marginalized voices within a history discipline grounded in European epistemology. The scholars I reference work within academic contexts for academic audiences, some writing outside of formal history departments, but all engage historical inquiry in relation to (albeit in tension with) how the history discipline has been traditionally defined through academia. This chapter is limited within and by that boundary. I first frame this inquiry through the power dynamics embedded in the production of history. Second, I address how scholars engage in dialogue through historical inquiry into archival silences. Third, I build upon this historical scholarship to consider how to address archival silences when teaching history in the classroom.