Safe return to driving after severe acquired brain injury: toward a tiered multidisciplinary rehabilitation pathway

Authors:

Abstract
Driving is among the most demanding instrumental activities of daily living requiring continuous integration of perception, cognition, motor control, and behavioral regulation under real-time conditions (Schultheis and Whipple, 2014). For people recovering from severe acquired brain injury (sABI), driving symbolizes regained autonomy, social integration, and reduced family dependence (Schultheis and Whipple, 2014), and is linked to return to employment (Perna et al., 2021).Michon's hierarchical model of driving control remains a useful framework to understand why brain injury threatens driving safety (Michon, 1985). Damage to frontal and parietal networks may disrupt strategic planning, such as route choice and risk evaluation, as well as tactical decision-making, including lane positioning and speed adjustment. Even when gross motor recovery is achieved, subtle impairments in attention, spatial exploration, executive control, or emotional regulation can significantly affect driving performance (Saviola et al., 2018a).Empirical studies show that resuming driving enhances social engagement, functional performance, mood, and life satisfaction (Novack et al., 2021). Yet post-injury driving management varies widely (Schultheis and Whipple, 2014), as many regulations focus primarily on medical eligibility or legal "fitness-to-drive" criteria (e.g., seizure-free intervals, minimum visual fields) that, while necessary, do not adequately reflect functional driving competence.(e.g., seizure-free intervals, minimum visual fields) that, while necessary.A major barrier is system-level fragmentation: neurologists, neuropsychologists, occupational therapists, and rehabilitation specialists often work separately, without a unified framework linking assessment, rehabilitation, and licensing. This can lead to both premature exclusion and unsafe return to driving.Taken together, these limitations highlight the need to reconceptualize post-ABI driving as a structured rehabilitation process rather than a one-time fitness-to-drive examination. A Tiered Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation Pathway can integrate medical, functional, and legal dimensions within a coherent, equitable, and evidence-based system. The proposed model draws on clinical experience at the Centro Cardinal Ferrari hospital and international evidence from the neurorehabilitation and occupational therapy literature.Current practice remains highly fragmented. Many patients are referred for driving assessment only at the end of general neurorehabilitation. At the same time, licensing authorities frequently rely on static measures such as visual acuity, seizure history, or motor deficits, despite evidence that neuropsychological performance, visual scanning behavior, and executive self-monitoring correlate more strongly with real on-road outcomes (Saviola et al., 2018a;Devos et al., 2011). This mismatch creates ethically problematic situations: some individuals return to driving without adequate rehabilitation, while others are restricted despite having compensable or trainable deficits. Fragmentation across disciplines (neurology, physiatry, neuropsychology, ophthalmology, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, and driving instruction) further limits coherent decision-making, as services often operate in parallel rather than within an integrated pathway.Neuropsychological domain. Safe driving depends on attention, working memory, executive function, processing speed, and visuospatial abilities, domains frequently affected after sABI.Importantly, impairments may persist even when global screening tests appear within normal limits, and specific deficits in divided attention, executive control, visuo-spatial organization, and visual processing speed are among the strongest predictors of on-road failure (Saviola et al., 2018a;McKay et al., 2016;Owsley & McGwin, 2010). Targeted neuropsychological rehabilitation increasingly uses computerized exercises to train sustained and divided attention, working memory, and visuospatial processing. Platforms like Cogniplus (Schuhfried, 2016) or Vienna Test (Schuhfried, 2017) provide structured, measurable exercises that complement simulator-based training and facilitate transfer of cognitive improvements to real-world driving performance. These tools allow clinicians to monitor progress quantitatively and adjust therapy intensity over time.Collateral information from relatives is also essential, as it can reveal real-world functioning and uncover inefficiency, inertia, impulsivity, poor adherence to routines, such as sleep patterns, medication, or substance use, which patients may underestimate or fail to report. This perspective is important because unreported risk-taking behaviors or disinhibition can undermine driving safety even when formal cognitive scores appear adequate (Bivona et al., 2019;Ciurli et al., 2010).A further crucial issue is impaired self-awareness: individuals with frontal or right-hemisphere lesions may underestimate their deficits, exhibiting overconfidence and unsafe behaviors (Dromer et al., 2021). For this reason, rehabilitation should integrate metacognitive and risk-management interventions addressing insight, behavior, medication, fatigue, and alcohol use. Studies suggest that combining neuropsychological findings with simulator-based training enhances the ecological validity of training and supports safer return-to-driving decisions (De Tanti et al., 2015, 2020).Visual and ophthalmologic domain. Although vision is fundamental to safe driving, licensing standards still rely mainly on visual acuity, a parameter that only partially reflects functional performance. Individuals may meet legal thresholds yet present with hemianopia, quadrantanopia, neglect, impaired oculomotor control, diplopia, or slowed visual processing, all of which compromise hazard detection, spatial judgment, and reaction time (Bowers et al., 2005;Owsley & McGwin, 2010). A functional vision assessment should...

This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit: