Percutaneous versus Open Fetal Surgical Intervention for Sacrococcygeal Teratomas: Is Less Really More?
Authors:
- 21 August 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by S. Karger AG in Fetal Diagnosis and Therapy
- Vol. 50 (5) , 313-331
Abstract
Introduction: Sacrococcygeal teratomas (SCTs) may require in utero intervention for survival. Open surgical intervention (OSI) was first described, but increasing reports of percutaneous intervention (PI) with variable indications and outcomes exist. We reviewed the literature for all published cases of fetal SCT intervention and compared OSI to PI cohorts. Methods: A keyword search of PubMed was conducted. Inclusion criteria were as follows: data available per individual fetus including gestational age at intervention, type of intervention, primary indication, survival, gestational age at birth, and complications. Complications were grouped into categories: placenta/membrane, procedural, or hemorrhagic. Failure was defined as little/no improvement or recurrence of the primary indication. χ2 analysis was performed for solid tumor PI versus OSI to assess significant trends in these intervention groups. A meta-analysis was not feasible due to small numbers and heterogeneity. Results: Twenty-seven articles met inclusion criteria. In the PI group, 38 fetuses underwent intervention for solid tumors, 21 for cystic tumors, and 3 for solid and cystic tumor components. Among fetuses with solid tumors, OSI was associated with lower need for multiple interventions (0% vs. 31.6%, p = 0.01) and higher survival to discharge (50% vs. 39.5%, p = 0.02). A fetal intervention was performed in the absence of hydrops/early hydrops in 45% of fetuses receiving PI, compared to 21% receiving OSI. Failure to resolve the primary indication was higher in the PI group (55.9% vs. 11.1% OSI, p = 0.02). The overall complication rates were high in both groups (90% OSI, 87% PI), though bleeding was unique to the PI group (26.5%). Preemptive cyst drainage, for purely cystic tumors, was universally successful and associated with a low complication risk (18.2%). Conclusions: For solid tumors, OSI appears to be superior with regard to survival to discharge, fewer interventions, and lower failure rates. PIs to drain a cyst may facilitate delivery or preempt future complications, though consideration should be given to long-term oncologic outcomes.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- The migration and loss of human primordial germ stem cells from the hind gut epithelium towards the gonadal ridgeThe International Journal of Developmental Biology, 2012
- Perinatal outcome of sacrococcygeal teratomaPrenatal Diagnosis, 2011
- Peripartum Ultrasound-Guided Drainage of Cystic Fetal Sacrococcygeal Teratoma for the Prevention of the Labor Dystocia: A Report of Two CasesAmerican Journal of Perinatology Reports, 2011
- Tumor volume to fetal weight ratio as an early prognostic classification for fetal sacrococcygeal teratomaJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 2011
- Sacrococcygeal teratoma—a 25-year experience in a UK regional centerJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 2006
- OP06.20: In utero Doppler ultrasound‐guided embolization for the treatment of a large, vascular sacrococcygeal teratoma causing fetal hydropsUltrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology, 2006
- Outcome of antenatally diagnosed sacrococcygeal teratomas: single-center experience (1993-2004)Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 2006
- In utero Repair of Rectal Atresia after Complete Resection of a Sacrococcygeal TeratomaFetal Diagnosis and Therapy, 2000
- In utero Decompression of a Cystic Grade IV Sacrococcygeal TeratomaFetal Diagnosis and Therapy, 1998
- High-output cardiac failure in fetuses with large sacrococcygeal teratoma: Diagnosis by echocardiography and Doppler ultrasoundThe Journal of Pediatrics, 1989