Dealing with inappropriate honorifics in a structured and defensible way is possible
Abstract
In a recent article electronically published in Taxon as a “Point of View” in 2021 (and subsequently in hardcopy as a “Perspective” in 2022), Gideon F. Smith and Estrela Figueiredo commented on the undesirability of the continued commemoration of people of severely questionable ethics, including the imperialist Cecil John Rhodes (1853–1902), in botanical nomenclature. Independently addressing a similar topic at around the same time, Timothy A. Hammer and Kevin R. Thiele published proposals to amend Articles 51 and 56 and Division III of the Code, to allow the considered rejection of culturally offensive and inappropriate names. Subsequently, widely circulated responses to Smith & Figueiredo (2022) and Hammer & Thiele (2021) severely misrepresented our positions and views. We here respond to allegations that what we proposed will damage plant nomenclature, and clarify and further substantiate our views.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- If “Rhodes‐” must fall, who shall fall next?Taxon, 2022
- (119–122) Proposals to amend Articles 51 and 56 and Division III, to allow the rejection of culturally offensive and inappropriate namesTaxon, 2021
- “Rhodes‐” must fall: Some of the consequences of colonialism for botany and plant nomenclatureTaxon, 2021
- International Code of Nomenclature for algae, fungi, and plants2018
- English and Latin as alternative languages for validating the names of organisms covered by the International Code of Nomenclature for algae, fungi, and plants : The final chapter?Taxon, 2011
- Latin diagnoses: An unnecessary impediment — A response to JørgensenTaxon, 2010
- Latin diagnosis: Time to let goTaxon, 2010