Reciprocal peer review for quality improvement: an ethnographic case study of the Improving Lung Cancer Outcomes Project
- 9 August 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Quality & Safety
- Vol. 21 (12) , 1034-1041
Abstract
Background Peer review offers a promising way of promoting improvement in health systems, but the optimal model is not yet clear. We aimed to describe a specific peer review model—reciprocal peer-to-peer review (RP2PR)—to identify the features that appeared to support optimal functioning. Methods We conducted an ethnographic study involving observations, interviews and documentary analysis of the Improving Lung Cancer Outcomes Project, which involved 30 paired multidisciplinary lung cancer teams participating in facilitated reciprocal site visits. Analysis was based on the constant comparative method. Results Fundamental features of the model include multidisciplinary participation, a focus on discussion and observation of teams in action, rather than paperwork; facilitated reflection and discussion on data and observations; support to develop focused improvement plans. Five key features were identified as important in optimising this model: peers and pairing methods; minimising logistic burden; structure of visits; independent facilitation; and credibility of the process. Facilitated RP2PR was generally a positive experience for participants, but implementing improvement plans was challenging and required substantial support. RP2PR appears to be optimised when it is well organised; a safe environment for learning is created; credibility is maximised; implementation and impact are supported. Discussion RP2PR is seen as credible and legitimate by lung cancer teams and can act as a powerful stimulus to produce focused quality improvement plans and to support implementation. Our findings have identified how RP2PR functioned and may be optimised to provide a constructive, open space for identifying opportunities for improvement and solutions.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ten challenges in improving quality in healthcare: lessons from the Health Foundation's programme evaluations and relevant literature: Table 1BMJ Quality & Safety, 2012
- Why is UK medicine no longer a self-regulating profession? The role of scandals involving “bad apple” doctorsSocial Science & Medicine, 2011
- Explaining Michigan: Developing an Ex Post Theory of a Quality Improvement ProgramThe Milbank Quarterly, 2011
- The UK National Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Resources and Outcomes Project – a feasibility study of large‐scale clinical service peer reviewJournal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 2010
- The language of teamwork: Reproducing professional divisions in the operating theatreHuman Relations, 2008
- WHAT’S MEASURED IS WHAT MATTERS: TARGETS AND GAMING IN THE ENGLISH PUBLIC HEALTH CARE SYSTEMPublic Administration, 2006
- Evidence-Based Quality Improvement: The State Of The ScienceHealth Affairs, 2005
- What can ethnography do for quality and safety in health care?Quality and Safety in Health Care, 2003
- Auditing and the production of legitimacyAccounting, Organizations and Society, 2003
- A Regional Intervention to Improve the Hospital Mortality Associated With Coronary Artery Bypass Graft SurgeryJAMA, 1996