Estimation of Vaccine Efficacy and Critical Vaccination Coverage in Partially Observed Outbreaks
Open Access
- 2 May 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 9 (5) , e1003061
Abstract
Classical approaches to estimate vaccine efficacy are based on the assumption that a person's risk of infection does not depend on the infection status of others. This assumption is untenable for infectious disease data where such dependencies abound. We present a novel approach to estimating vaccine efficacy in a Bayesian framework using disease transmission models. The methodology is applied to outbreaks of mumps in primary schools in the Netherlands. The total study population consisted of 2,493 children in ten primary schools, of which 510 (20%) were known to have been infected, and 832 (33%) had unknown infection status. The apparent vaccination coverage ranged from 12% to 93%, and the apparent infection attack rate varied from 1% to 76%. Our analyses show that vaccination reduces the probability of infection per contact substantially but not perfectly ( = 0.933; 95CrI: 0.908–0.954). Mumps virus appears to be moderately transmissible in the school setting, with each case yielding an estimated 2.5 secondary cases in an unvaccinated population ( = 2.49; 95%CrI: 2.36–2.63), resulting in moderate estimates of the critical vaccination coverage (64.2%; 95%CrI: 61.7–66.7%). The indirect benefits of vaccination are highest in populations with vaccination coverage just below the critical vaccination coverage. In these populations, it is estimated that almost two infections can be prevented per vaccination. We discuss the implications for the optimal control of mumps in heterogeneously vaccinated populations. Less than two decades ago, it was generally believed that in developed countries infectious diseases such as measles, mumps, and pertussis were under firm control via vaccination. Nowadays, it is increasingly recognized that this picture has been overly optimistic. A central question is whether recurrent disease outbreaks are caused by vaccination coverage having dropped below safe levels, or by vaccines having become less effective. To answer this question, the authors study outbreaks of mumps in primary schools in the Netherlands. Using disease transmission models, the authors estimate vaccine efficacy and the critical vaccination coverage needed to prevent large outbreaks. The analyses show that the vaccine has been highly effective in preventing infection, but that vaccination coverage has been insufficient in some schools. The authors argue that catch-up vaccination campaigns aimed at populations with intermediate vaccination coverage will be most efficient, as these would maximize the (direct and indirect) benefits of vaccination.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Mapping Between Interactions and InterferenceEpidemiology, 2012
- Recent Mumps Outbreaks in Vaccinated Populations: No Evidence of Immune EscapeJournal of Virology, 2012
- The role of schools in the spread of mumps among unvaccinated children: a retrospective cohort studyBMC Infectious Diseases, 2011
- Methods to infer transmission risk factors in complex outbreak dataJournal of The Royal Society Interface, 2011
- Estimation of measles vaccine efficacy and critical vaccination coverage in a highly vaccinated populationJournal of The Royal Society Interface, 2010
- Toward Causal Inference With InterferenceJournal of the American Statistical Association, 2008
- Large Measles Outbreak at a German Public School, 2006The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal, 2007
- Detecting Emerging Transmissibility of Avian Influenza Virus in Human HouseholdsPLOS Computational Biology, 2007
- Vaccine Effectiveness Estimates, 2004–2005 Mumps Outbreak, EnglandEmerging Infectious Diseases, 2007
- Estimation of Vaccine Effectiveness Using the Screening MethodInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 1993