Barriers to Obtaining Family Consent for Potential Organ Donors
Authors:
- Carlos V. R. BrownCBCarlos V. R. Brown
- Kelli H. FoulkrodKFKelli H. Foulkrod
- Sarah DworaczykSDSarah Dworaczyk
- Kit ThompsonKTKit Thompson
- Eric ElliotEEEric Elliot
- Hassie CooperHCHassie Cooper
- Ben CoopwoodBCBen Coopwood
- 1 February 2010
- journal article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection & Critical Care
- Vol. 68 (2) , 447-451
Abstract
Our country suffers from a chronic shortage of organ donors, and the list of individuals in desperate need of life-saving organ transplants is growing every year. Family consent represents an important limiting factor for successful donation. We hypothesize that specific barriers to obtaining family consent can be identified and improved upon to increase organ donation consent rates. The purpose of this study was to compare families who declined organ donation to those who granted consent, specifically to identify barriers to family consent for successful organ donation. We performed a 4-year (2004-2007) retrospective study of potential organ donors covered by our regional organ procurement organization (OPO). Variables collected included age, gender, race, cause of brain death (trauma vs. medical) of the potential organ donor, and elapsed time from declaration of brain death to family approach by OPO. Potential organ donors whose family declined organ donation (DECLINE group) were compared with potential organ donors whose family consented to organ donation (CONSENT group). Groups were compared using univariate and multivariate analysis. There were a total of 827 potential organ donors during the 4-year period within our OPO region. Overall, 471 families (57%) consented to organ donation, whereas 356 families (43%) declined. Although there was no difference in male gender between the DECLINE and CONSENT groups (59% vs. 53%, p = 0.12), the DECLINE group had more medical brain deaths (73% vs. 58%, p < 0.001), more potential donors aged 50 years or older (43% vs. 34%, p < 0.001), as well as more potential organ donors of Hispanic (67% vs. 43%, p < 0.001) and African American (10% vs. 4%, p < 0.001) descent. In addition, time from declaration of brain death to family approach by OPO was longer for the DECLINE group (350 minutes vs. 112 minutes, p = 0.001). Logistic regression identified race, older age, and death from a medical cause as independent risk factors for failure of obtaining consent. Several barriers exist to family consent for successful organ donation. Family members of minority populations, medical brain deaths, and older potential donors more often decline consent for organ donation. Family education and resource utilization toward these specific populations of potential organ donors may help to improve organ donation consent rates. In addition, delayed family approach by OPO seems to be associated with decreased consent rates. System improvements to expedite family approach by OPO may likewise lead to improved consent rates.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Using thyroid hormone in brain‐dead donors to maximize the number of organs available for transplantationClinical Transplantation, 2007
- The Effect of a Protocol of Aggressive Donor Management: Implications for the National Organ Donor Shortage2006
- Promoting Organ Donation to Hispanics: The Role of the Media and MedicineJournal of Health Communication, 2006
- Report of a National Conference on Donation after Cardiac DeathAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2006
- Outcomes of 385 Adult-to-Adult Living Donor Liver Transplant RecipientsAnnals of Surgery, 2005
- Aggressive Organ Donor Management Significantly Increases the Number of Organs Available for Transplantation2005
- Comparison of black and white families’ experiences and perceptions regarding organ donation requestsCritical Care Medicine, 2003
- Hispanic Perceptions of Organ DonationProgress in Transplantation, 2002
- The Role of Thyroid Hormone Administration in Potential Organ DonorsArchives of Surgery, 2001
- Racial impact: Increasing minority consent rate by altering the racial mix of an organ procurement organizationTransplantation Proceedings, 1997