Countering demand for ineffective health remedies: Do consumers respond to risks, lack of benefits, or both?
- 8 June 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Psychology & Health
- Vol. 36 (5) , 593-611
Abstract
Objective: We tested whether targeting the illusion of causality and/or misperceptions about health risks had the potential to reduce consumer demand for an ineffective health remedy (multivitamin supplements). Design: We adopted a 2 (contingency information: no/yes) × 2 (fear appeal: no/yes) factorial design, with willingness-to-pay as the dependent variable. The contingency information specified, in table format, the number of people reporting a benefit vs. no benefit from both multivitamins and placebo, plus a causal explanation for lack of efficacy over placebo. The fear appeal involved a summary of clinical-trial results that indicated multivitamins can cause health harms. The control condition received only irrelevant information. Main outcome measure: Experimental auctions measured people’s willingness-to-pay for multivitamins. Experiment 1 (N = 260) elicited hypothetical willingness-to-pay online. Experiment 2 (N = 207) elicited incentivised willingness-to-pay in the laboratory. Results: Compared to a control group, we found independent effects of contingency information (-22%) and the fear appeal (-32%) on willingness-to-pay. The combination of both interventions had the greatest impact (-50%) on willingness-to-pay. Conclusion: We found evidence that consumer choices are influenced by both perceptions of efficacy and risk. The combination of both elements can provide additive effects that appear superior to either approach alone.Keywords
Funding Information
- This research was facilitated by an Australian Government Research Training Program Scholarship awarded to the first author.
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Changing smokers’ risk perceptions – for better or worse?Journal of Health Psychology, 2013
- Estimating the impact of pictorial health warnings and “plain” cigarette packaging: Evidence from experimental auctions among adult smokers in the United StatesHealth Policy, 2011
- The Effects of Message Framing, Involvement, and Nicotine Dependence on Anti-Smoking Public Service AnnouncementsHealth Marketing Quarterly, 2011
- WHAT'S TO KNOW ABOUT HYPOTHETICAL BIAS IN STATED PREFERENCE VALUATION STUDIES?Journal of Economic Surveys, 2011
- Explicit warnings reduce but do not eliminate the continued influence of misinformationMemory & Cognition, 2010
- Do Loss-Framed Persuasive Messages Engender Greater Message Processing Than Do Gain-Framed Messages? A Meta-Analytic ReviewCommunication Studies, 2008
- The influence of self‐efficacy on the effects of framed health messagesEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2008
- Unbiased Value Estimates for Environmental Goods: A Cheap Talk Design for the Contingent Valuation MethodAmerican Economic Review, 1999
- A Psychological Study of the Inverse Relationship Between Perceived Risk and Perceived BenefitRisk Analysis, 1994
- Fear control and danger control: A test of the extended parallel process model (EPPM)Communication Monographs, 1994