RISK ANALYSIS OF RESTORATION WORKS BY FINE KINNEY METHOD: AN EVALUATION OVER MASONRY CIVIL ARCHITECTURE EXAMPLES IN FATIH DISTRICT, ISTANBUL
Authors:
- Pinar TabakPTPinar Tabak
- Banu Yeşim BÜYÜKAKINCIBBBanu Yeşim BÜYÜKAKINCI
- 15 March 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Asociatia Forumul Inventatorilor Romani in International Journal of Conservation Science
- Vol. 14 (1) , 19-32
Abstract
Restoration interventions aims at conserving heritage structures. Different situations may occur during restoration works comparing to standard construction works. These differences may cause special risks for workers and the structure itself. Risk analysis is widely used in restoration field in the world as a work plan routine. Definite division between restoration and standard works hasn’t been defined in Turkey. Aim of the study is revealing what kind of different risks restoration works carry, creating awareness and making recommendations for avoiding these risks. As method of this study, Fine Kinney Method was chosen. The risk factor was obtained by using probability, severity and frequency values. Listed masonry houses from Fatih district were chosen. The region is composed of civil architectural examples more densely comparing to whole Istanbul. The most important criteria is the fact that these houses are among the oldest masonry examples in Istanbul. They carry more risks with their current deterioration levels. The possible risks were listed and documented. The results were presented using Fine Kinney Method. Falling from height and partial collapse are found as main risks in restoration works. Risk levels and risk types of potential risks in restoration works show differences than the standard construction applications.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Risk Assessment of Artifact Degradation in a Museum, Based on Indoor Climate Monitoring—Case Study of “Poni-Cernătescu” Museum from Iași CityApplied Sciences, 2022
- Mimari Restorasyon ve Konservasyon Projelerinde İşçi Sağlığı ve İş Güvenliği UygulamalarıTeknik Dergi, 2020
- Metal Sektöründe 5x5 Matris ve Fine-Kinney Yöntemi ile Risk DeğerlendirmesiKaraelmas İş Sağlığı ve Güvenliği Dergisi, 2020
- Multianalytical Study for Establishing the Historical Contexts of the Church of the Holy Archangels from Cicau, Alba County, Romania, for its Promotion as a World Heritage Good I. Assessing the preservation-restoration works from the 18th centuryRevista de Chimie, 2019
- Kamu Kurumlarında Risk Değerlendirmesi İçin Karar Destek Sistemi ÖnerisiSosyal Guvence, 2018
- Calculation Challenges and Solution Suggestions for Risk Factors in the Risk Analysis Method in the Fine Kinney Risk Analysis MethodUluslararası Muhendislik Arastirma ve Gelistirme Dergisi, 2017
- A framework for the simplified risk analysis of cultural heritage assetsJournal of Cultural Heritage, 2016
- The assessment of risk in conservation refurbishment projectsStructural Survey, 2001
- Risk analysis for revenue dependent infrastructure projectsConstruction Management and Economics, 1997