Removing wolves did not reliably prevent domestic animal losses
Authors:
- Adrian TrevesATAdrian Treves
- Dror Ben‐AmiDBDror Ben‐Ami
- Ari M. CornmanACAri M. Cornman
- Martin Dul'AMDMartin Dul'A
- Igor KhorozyanIKIgor Khorozyan
- Miha KrofelMKMiha Krofel
- Miroslav KutalMKMiroslav Kutal
- José V. López‐BaoJLJosé V. López‐Bao
- Rona Nadler ValencyRVRona Nadler Valency
- Shlomo Preiss‐BloomSPShlomo Preiss‐Bloom
- Francisco J. Santiago‐ÁvilaFSFrancisco J. Santiago‐Ávila
- Jurģis ŠubaJŠJurģis Šuba
Open Access
- 18 August 2026
- journal article
- perspective
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 8 (9) , e70388
Abstract
Humans usually try to kill wild animals that they perceive as threats. However, many scientific findings have raised doubts that killing solves wildlife damage to property. With scant, low‐quality data, uncertainty persists. We reviewed recent studies of killing gray wolves to protect domestic animals. Our inclusion criteria set a minimum threshold for robust study design and transparent data sharing. In five studies in five countries, killing wolves typically had no effect, may have had the desired effect, but more often killing wolves had the counter‐productive undesirable effect of elevating domestic animal losses. We quantified the relative rates of the three outcomes and find the balance in favor of no effect to undesirable effects. We discuss potentially confounding variables and the need for an unbiased, reproducible, transparent, randomized, and controlled trial of predator removal. We find and summarize similarities to other situations from disease transmission to crop damage.Keywords
Funding Information
- The Slovenian Research and Innovation Agency (J1‐50013)
- The Slovenian Research and Innovation Agency (P4‐0059)
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Favourable conservation status: EU Court clarifies crucial yardstick for wildlife preservation and restoration in wave of wolf casesReview of European, Comparative & International Environmental Law, 2026
- Effects of lethal and non‐lethal wolf ( Canis lupus ) management measures on livestock depredation in the Golan Heights, IsraelEcological Solutions and Evidence, 2025
- Robust inference and errors in studies of wildlife controlScientific Reports, 2025
- Testing a conservation compromise: No evidence that public wolf hunting in Slovakia reduced livestock lossesConservation Letters, 2023
- Quantifying and addressing the prevalence and bias of study designs in the environmental and social sciencesNature Communications, 2020
- Reproductive performance of northern Australia beef herds. 8. Impact of rainfall and wild dog control on percentage fetal and calf lossAnimal Production Science, 2020
- Dingo baiting did not reduce fetal/calf loss in beef cattle in northern South AustraliaAnimal Production Science, 2018
- Reproducibility: A tragedy of errorsNature, 2016
- Tolerance for Predatory WildlifeScience, 2014
- Lamb predation and fox control in south‐eastern AustraliaJournal of Applied Ecology, 2000