When Can Prediction Market Prices Be Trusted? Price Informativeness, Calibration, and Bias on Polymarket
Preprint
- 2 October 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Prediction markets provide real-time probability estimates that are increasingly used by managers, analysts, journalists, and investors. Using 1.5 billion trades across 779,000 Polymarket markets, we examine when these prices can be trusted as probability estimates. Overall, prices are highly informative and improve with market maturity, with higher trading activity associated with better forecasts, particularly at early stages. However, accuracy varies across categories: weather markets are most precise, whereas mentions and geopolitics markets are least precise. We also find no general market-level longshot bias. Instead, low-probability outcomes are initially underpriced before reversing late in the lifecycle. Default outcomes are persistently overpriced. In sports markets, Polymarket matches professional bookmakers' accuracy. However, live trading shows that rapid information arrival can generate temporary distortions even as overall forecast accuracy improves. Prediction market prices therefore offer valuable probability estimates, but their interpretation should account for when, where, and under what trading conditions prices are observed.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Decision models and online betting behavior: Comparing mean-variance, expected utility, and prospect theoryJournal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2026
- Informational efficiency and behaviour within in-play prediction marketsInternational Journal of Forecasting, 2022
- The temporal evolution of mispricing in prediction marketsFinance Research Letters, 2019
- When are prediction market prices most informative?International Journal of Forecasting, 2019
- Longshots, overconfidence and efficiency on the Iowa Electronic MarketInternational Journal of Forecasting, 2019
- External validity of prospect theory: The evidence from soccer bettingJournal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 2016
- Prediction accuracy of different market structures — bookmakers versus a betting exchangeInternational Journal of Forecasting, 2010
- Prediction market accuracy in the long runInternational Journal of Forecasting, 2008
- Interpreting the predictions of prediction marketsEconomics Letters, 2006
- Status quo bias in decision makingJournal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1988