Are soil sealing indicators sufficient to guide urban planning? Insights from an ecosystem services assessment in the Paris metropolitan area
Open Access
- 27 September 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 16 (10) , 104019
Abstract
Urban sprawl impacts are critical in the evaluation of planning decisions and often monitored by indicators of soil sealing. In France, these indicators are required by law to be reported in environmental assessments of planning documents. Although monitoring of soil sealing is important to limit environmental impacts, focusing on this sole dimension in urban planning can be reductive. In this paper, we explore to what extent ecosystem services (ES) indicators, measuring the benefits to humans provided by healthy ecosystems, are captured by soil sealing indicators by comparing their temporal and spatial evolutions. Through consulting with urban planning stakeholders, we model and map the spatial and temporal evolutions over a 35 year period of soil sealing and eight priority ES in the Paris metropolitan area (agricultural potential, groundwater recharge, global climate regulation, water quality regulation through nutrient retention, urban heat mitigation, flood mitigation, recreational potential and natural heritage). We highlight the spatial and temporal matches and mismatches between the two types of indicators (ES and soil sealing) and demonstrate that a large part of ES variations are not well captured by soil sealing indicators in time and space (spatial match with the eight ES is only found for 10% of the Paris metropolitan area). This calls for finer, ES-based, diagnosis in land use planning that could usefully illuminate the gains and losses related to land use and land management policies by taking into account the environmental and societal impacts of urban sprawl.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministère de la Transition Ecologique
- Agence de l’Environnement et de la Maîtrise de l’Energie
- AgroParisTech
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Resilience of and through urban ecosystem servicesEcosystem Services, 2015
- Integrating ecosystem services in landscape planning: requirements, approaches, and impactsLandscape Ecology, 2014
- EU agricultural reform fails on biodiversityScience, 2014
- Assessment of Soil Sealing Management Responses, Strategies, and Targets Toward Ecologically Sustainable Urban Land Use ManagementAMBIO, 2014
- Integration of ecosystem services in spatial planning: a survey on regional planners’ viewsLandscape Ecology, 2014
- Futures of global urban expansion: uncertainties and implications for biodiversity conservationEnvironmental Research Letters, 2013
- Strategic Spatial Planning and the Ecosystem Services Concept - an Historical ExplorationEcology and Society, 2013
- The Role of Ecosystem Services in Contemporary Urban Planning2011
- The Need for Simultaneous Evaluation of Ecosystem Services and Land Use Change2010
- Ecosystem services in urban areasEcological Economics, 1999