Abstract
Dutch biodiversity was in a worse state in 2020 than in 1990. However, in 1990, biodiversity was already in decline compared to 1950 and 1900. Nutrient emissions from agriculture played a role in this development. Nature policy plans were developed since 1975. Implementation of these plans suffered from agricultural resistance. Negotiations to reach a Dutch Agricultural Agreement to address this natural history drama and outline perspectives for agriculture and rural areas stalled on June 21, 2023. Farmers objected to 2030 as end date for the proposed transition of agriculture, the critical deposition value for nitrogen and targets on livestock density and herd size. One of the ideas of the Agricultural Agreement was to use spatial zoning to find prospects for agriculture, rural areas, nature and landscape. This landscape zoning is an incomplete answer to the Dutch natural history drama when it does not make explicit the moral conditions that agriculture must meet in the various zones. Preserving and restoring biodiversity in natural landscapes requires space, tranquillity and time. In semi-natural landscapes it benefits from lower nutrient emissions. In cultural landscapes agriculture plays a role in preserving and restoring small landscape elements. This moral landscape zoning does not come about without enabling revisions to the moral conditions embedded in liberal market economics. The proposed transition is complex and agricultural resistance understandable but denial of the natural history drama is not a solution. It is better to try again with a taskforce with a timebound assignment to outline how to introduce prohibitive levies on use of artificial fertilisers and concentrate feeds in agriculture by 2050. Such levies lead to extensification of farming practices, reduction of nutrient emissions and restoration of nature.