Article Commentary: Ethics of cochlear implantation in young children: A review and reply from a Deaf‐World perspective
Authors:
- 1 October 1998
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Wiley in Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery
- Vol. 119 (4) , 297-313
Abstract
This article examines ethical dilemmas related to cochlear implant surgery in children. These dilemmas arise from the existence of a linguistic and cultural minority called the Deaf World. Organizations of culturally Deaf adults in the United States and abroad, as well as the World Federation of the Deaf, have, on ethical grounds, strongly criticized the practice of cochlear implant surgery in children. Three ethical dilemmas are examined. (1) The surgery is of unproven value for the main significant benefit sought, language acquisition, whereas the psychological, social, and linguistic risks have not been assessed. Thus the surgery appears to be innovative, but innovative surgery on children is ethically problematic. (2) It is now widely recognized that the signed languages of the world are full‐fledged natural languages, and the communities that speak those languages have distinct social organizations and cultures. Deaf culture values lead to a different assessment of pediatric cochlear implant surgery than do mainstream (hearing) values, and both sets of values have standing. (3) The fields of otology and audiology want to provide cochlear implants to Deaf children but also, their leaders say, want to protect Deaf culture; those appear to be conflicting goals in principle because, if there were perfect implants, the ranks of the Deaf World would diminish.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reading Ability in Signing Deaf ChildrenTopics in Language Disorders, 1998
- Lexical Effects on Spoken Word Recognition by Pediatric Cochlear Implant UsersEar & Hearing, 1995
- Constructions of DeafnessDisability & Society, 1995
- A Clinical Report on Receptive Vocabulary Skills in Cochlear Implant UsersEar & Hearing, 1995
- Variables affecting implant performance in childrenThe Laryngoscope, 1994
- The long-lasting advantage of learning sign language in childhood: Another look at the critical period for language acquisitionJournal of Memory and Language, 1991
- Independent Evaluation of the Speech Perception Abilities of Children with the Nucleus 22-Channel Cochlear Implant SystemEar & Hearing, 1991
- Status of cochlear implantation in childrenThe Journal of Pediatrics, 1991
- The Concept of Oppression and the Development of a Social Theory of DisabilityDisability, Handicap & Society, 1987
- Linguistic Interdependence and the Educational Development of Bilingual ChildrenReview of Educational Research, 1979