Abstract
This study by Rojansky et al. provides mechanistic insights into the elimination of paternal mitochondria from early mammalian embryos. Several previous studies have highlighted autophagy pathway(s) in paternal mitochondrial elimination, but they are limited to invertebrate model systems. This is the first study in mammals showing the role of mitophagy in the removal of paternal mitochondria delivered from sperm. First, the authors explored the role of different fusion or fission genes, previously reported for efficient mitophagy, in an oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS)-induced mitophagy paradigm in mammalian cells. They observed that Fis1-/- cells had dramatically reduced mitophagy and FIS1 along with TBC1D15 (FIS1 interacting protein) function upstream of p62 in promoting mitophagy. The authors also examined the role of PINK1/PARKIN in the OXPHOS-induced mitophagy condition. Interestingly, Parkin-/- mammalian cells did not block the mitophagy pathway. However, a knockdown of MUL1 (mitochondria targeted E3 ligase) in Parkin-/- cells significantly blocked OXPHOS-induced mitophagy. The results indicate that Parkin and MUL1 have a redundant function in mitophagy. In collaboration with Ming Guo’s lab (UCLA), we previously showed that MUL1 and Parkin play a role in parallel pathways to regulate mitochondrial integrity in mammalian cells, including mouse cortical neurons {1}. Second, the authors then extended their findings to mouse embryos to test for a mitophagy pathway(s) involved in eliminating paternal mitochondria. Depletion of both MUL1 and Parkin significantly blocked the elimination of paternal mitochondria from mouse embryos. Embryos with a depletion of TBC1D15 and p62 also showed strong suppression of paternal mitochondrial loss. Overexpressing dominant-negative FIS1 mutant (FIS1-DN) resulted in a significant inhibition of paternal mitochondrial loss in mouse embryos. While this elegant study provides promising evidence as to how mitophagy assists parental mitochondrial elimination in early mammalian embryos, several important questions remain to be addressed in the future. For example, (1) what are the upstream signaling events that activate the MUL1 and/or PINK1/Parkin pathways for the selective removal of parental mitochondria in early mammalian embryos; (2) how do parental mitochondria lose their membrane potential shortly after entering the oocytes; (3) does Fis1 act as a receptor for the selective degradation of paternal mitochondria during early embryogenesis? The current findings will lay a solid foundation to explore these important issues.