Cultural challenges to the adversarial cooperation framework in bioethics: a Confucian critique
Authors:
- 27 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 52 (1) , 16-17
Abstract
This commentary challenges the cultural universalism implicit in Parker’s model by expounding its incompatibility with Confucian ethical traditions prevailing in East Asian societies, such as China, Korea and Japan. Framed as procedural and dialogical, Parker’s model emphasises modes of engagement for resolving value polarisation and moral disagreement rather than prescribing a specific substantive outcome. The adversarial cooperation approach calls for a carefully designed process where participants with divergent values come together to deliberate and to seek consensus. While this approach offers a promising avenue for navigating bioethical conflicts, its liberal procedural foundations raise questions about its applicability across diverse cultural, especially collectivist, contexts, on top of the other explicitly discussed challenges.Keywords
This publication has 4 references indexed in Scilit:
- Lessons from li : a confucian-inspired approach to global bioethicsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2025
- Bioethics and the value of disagreementJournal of Medical Ethics, 2024
- A Confucian view of informed consent in biomedical practice2021
- The Role of Qing (Positive Emotions) and Li 1 (Rationality) in Chinese Entrepreneurial Decision Making: A Confucian Ren-Yi Wisdom PerspectiveJournal of Business Ethics, 2013